Black Friday Is Almost Here!
The Inventory team is rounding up deals you don’t want to miss, now through Cyber Monday. Click here to browse!

Mario Maker 2's Final Update Would Be Better If It Weren't The Last One

Illustration for article titled iMario Maker 2/is Final Update Would Be Better If It Werent The Last One
Screenshot: Nintendo

Super Mario Maker 2 received its big version 3.0 update today, adding a bunch of new items, characters, and a whole new mode for building entire worlds. There’s a ton of great stuff to play around with in it. But as a final update, it leaves a lot on the table.

Advertisement

First the big stuff: version 3.0 adds Super Worlds. You can now take all of those courses you’ve built and stitch them together into a larger journey. Super Worlds can only be constructed using the Super Mario World aesthetic, but they do a pretty good job of approximating the feel of the SNES game’s maps in miniature. They can also be made up of courses from any of the other game styles. Each Super World can have up to eight sub-worlds, and each sub-world can have up to six courses. That means Mario Maker creators can now in effect make their own mini-Mario games.

The new overworld maps feature additional tracks like the Ice World music from the All Stars version of Super Mario Bros. 3.
The new overworld maps feature additional tracks like the Ice World music from the All Stars version of Super Mario Bros. 3.
Screenshot: Nintendo
Advertisement

For each world you can choose between one of the eight different world themes, from ground or sky to volcano or space. You can then go about customizing each of the 28 tiles on the world maps to add things like rivers, mountains, green pipes, and Toad house mini-games. You can also tweak blank squares to add ornamental details like smiling hills on a bucolic world or dinosaur bones on a desert one. While there aren’t a ton of options, it’s still a nice way to package courses and control the pacing of and order in which players experience them. And remember skinny Mario? Well, he’s finally back.

There are some frustrating drawbacks, however. You can set the number of lives players start with, but nothing happens if they die: There’s no checkpointing and no progress is lost. Players’ power-ups don’t carry over after they beat a course, either. As a result, a world’s courses feel like individual and separate obstacles rather than part of a larger challenge. You can also only upload one Super World at a time, a limitation that’s understandable and also means if you finally find one you like and have been working through it, it might not be there when you eventually return.

Mario can now walk on water if he’s carrying an item and running while in the Frog suit, something that wasn’t in Super Mario Bros. 3.
Mario can now walk on water if he’s carrying an item and running while in the Frog suit, something that wasn’t in Super Mario Bros. 3.
Screenshot: Nintendo
Advertisement

The new Super Worlds are only part of the update though. Here’s a quick overview of the rest:

New items:

  • Super Mario Bros. 2 Mushroom (Super Mario Bros.)
  • Cursed Key (Super Mario Bros.)
  • Frog Suit (Super Mario Bros. 3)
  • Power Balloon (Super Mario World)
  • Super Acorn (New Super Mario Bros. U)
  • Boomerang Flower (Super Mario 3D Worlds)

New enemies (all game-styles):

  • Larry
  • Iggy
  • Wendy
  • Lemmy
  • Roy
  • Morton
  • Ludwig
  • Mechakoopa
Advertisement

Finally having the Koopalings is great, and the Mechakoopas come in new varieties including one that fires homing missiles and another that shoots lasers. The real highlight is the new Super Mario Bros. 2 mushroom, which transforms Mario, Luigi, and Toad into the Super Mario Bros. 2 versions of themselves, complete with that game’s level up sound effect. In addition, getting the power-up will also change the music in certain courses, like underground-themed ones, to the respective Super Mario Bros. 2 tracks. It’s a nice set of little easter eggs.

These details aren’t quite the Super Mario Bros. 2 mode many fans have been hoping for, unfortunately. It was surprising when Super Mario Maker 2 came out without a Super Mario Bros. 2 mode. It seemed likely it might get added in a future update. Here we are less than a year later in what Nintendo says is the game’s final update, and the nods inherent in the mushroom power-up seem like the closest we’ll ever get.

Advertisement
The Super Mario Bros. 2 mushroom power-up lets you pick up enemies and throw them at others.
The Super Mario Bros. 2 mushroom power-up lets you pick up enemies and throw them at others.
Screenshot: Nintendo

In the end, a lot of the version 3.0 update feels like good ideas worth expanding on in a future one. Super Worlds are fun and a completely new way to go about exploring other people’s courses, but are ultimately fairly linear. There’s room to do more with them, like Super Mario World’s own branching paths, just like there’s more to do with the Super Mario Bros. 2 aesthetic, including finally making Princess Peach playable and letting you fly around levels. She does appear in Super Worlds, but only as the damsel to be rescued by completing all of the courses.

Advertisement

Mario Maker 2 players are some of the most creative, using the existing building blocks Nintendo’s given them to create complex death traps, ingenious mazes, and unique storytelling machines. It’s a shame they won’t continue getting more.

Kotaku staff writer. You can reach him at ethan.gach@kotaku.com

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

SageofMusic
SageofMusic

I think you’re the only one that’s disappointed by this update.

1. Super worlds can’t have powerups carry over because a lot of challenging courses have to specifically dictate what powerups, if any, the player has at the beginning. Allowing the player to carry some over would mean you would have to have some mechanism at the beginning of every level to de-powerup the player which would just be annoying.

2. The addition of an entire Super Mario Bros 2 theme is problematic in the same way 3D world was. That style of gameplay is just too wildly different from normal Mario Bros and they would basically have to make it into an “extra themes” mode like 3D World. So they added just the mushroom to give the game a lot of extra variety.

3. The game already had a ton of content when it first came out and was easily worthy of having the sequel moniker placed on it. And even then they came out with two massive updates that radically increased the variety and possibilities in the game. Being disappointed that a free content update doesn’t give enough, especially when it gives so much, seems entitled.

4. They said that this is “last major update” which could easily leave room for future DLC. As it stands now, it’s strange that there’s only 1 theme in the extra themes section that can clearly hold more, so I wouldn’t doubt they release a SMB2, SML or some such in the future but as DLC not as an update.