Everyone here is pretty much concurs... I just have to throw this in. Some games make it impossible to achieve these medals... Uncharted is not one of those games. I'm sure alot of games require some type of skill in order to recieve these trophies. But some are just a tad bit too challenging. (i.e. Warhawks Lone Wolf (top player, no deaths) and Wipeouts' Beat Zico, namely)
At the time I played the hell out of those games, but I still can't get them trophies. I was really happy with the Uncharted trophy list... these are very doable and may be my first (hopefully, not last) platinum. #uncharted2
"We didn't want people playing through the game and feeling there was no way to ever get the platinum trophy, that there was no way to get all the trophies because it was so super-complex," Minkoff said. "We decided, if it's core to gameplay, it gets a trophy. If it's a skill-based honor, like a ‘Hey man, look what I can do,' thing, then it's a medal."
I'm not a perfectionist or an achievement whore by any means (well, excluding TF2) but I really wish more devs would think like this. Achievements should be impressive-but-relevant things like "Kill 6 people at once with 1 grenade" or something. An in-game medal should be "Bounce a grenade off someone's head to kill them". #ps3
I actually think the Uncharted trophies are kind of lame, I would like trophies for harder things, and more for online, or one that requires you to get all of the online medals, that would be fun to try and achieve.. but instead it's just kill this many people with this kind of gun. I do like hunting for all of these though. #ps3
@gachzorge: I thank God that there are only two trophies for online mode, and that it's just "Try these modes, please." Granted, I love playing Uncharted 2 online, but I like doing it my way, not the trophy lists' way. #ps3
I'm just going to throw in my two cents and say how much I love trophies. I think they are a great addition and I agree with everything this article talks about. #ps3
Fuck yeah, these guys rule. I wish other devs were like this with their trophies. I have yet to get the platinum in Resistance 2, because I don't feel like getting 10,000 kills in competitive mode, got all the others though, co-op was a blast. #ps3
The Uncharted games (and PacMan Championship Edition) are the only ones where I actually bothered to get platinum/full gamerscore. They are actually FUN to get, unlike lots of other games. #ps3
Although I didn't really enjoy the first Uncharted (got dizzy and had other games to play =/), the late introduction of trophies and how well they worked and explored more of the game felt like that should have set the tone for trophies for Playstation 3 games. Now, the trophies for recent games feel like ordinary achievements. I'm not saying this to bash on the 360's achievements or hate on developers for being lazy and porting the lists over or saying people aren't being creative with the exploration of their games, but I had high hopes for trophies after the first Uncharted's trophies. Instead of being a topic of conversation, a story, or something to be proud of, games' trophies are starting to feel like mundane checklists. Uncharted 2 does it well, so I'm guessing these great trophies are a Naughty Dog thing... Please PS3 devs, follow their example. Reward us for doing random shit and finding the things way off in the distance. In-game incentives are nice too . #ps3
I believe companies attempt to bolster their online participants or create longevity for their multiplayer aspects by putting in ridiculous multiplayer trophies/achievements.
That being said, I hate them, not only does it cut off those who don't have their systems connected to the internet from ever obtaining them, but its just a cheap way for them to try and say, hey, look how many people we have playing our game online, even if the online completely sucks.
Thus I must say, I love Naughty Dog for keeping their trophies to single player only, the same as CoD Modern Warfare. It had amazing online so they didn't need to implement achievements into it to get people to play it.
Ya know, I always find the real treasure being the stories you can relate to your friends. I may not have many of these stories on my own, but I can recall how breathless a friend of mine was after having countered E-Honda's torpedo thing with Guile's Ultra whatever combo.
A trophy is just a paperweight in your cabinet. Sure, having a goal creates lucrative incentive to go further than you might do otherwise. But the real joy is telling people "how" you bowled that 300. #ps3
The thing I like most about UC2's trophies is that, with the exception of "Charted! - Crushing", ALL of them are doable by a player of essentially any skill level, time permitting.
I hate forced multiplayer trophies and achievements, so I'm glad to see they didn't put in a ton of those. The only two in the game are incredibly easy to pull off. #ps3
@Archaotic: Yeah, that's something I noticed to. I have a friend who's a trophy whore but with real spotty internet, so he can't really get any multiplayer trophies. He hates it. #ps3
@Archaotic: I hate multiplayer trophies and achievements too. =/ They're nice and all, but shouldn't be mandatory for that Platinum trophy.
That or let's put a higher tier above platinum (like diamond) so that distinction could exist. lol
You people are insane. I've done the spiked columns with no damage before without really even thinking about it. I have never understood why people find it so difficult; I'm not saying anyone should be able to get the trophy his first try, but unless they change the mechanics of that challenge, it won't be frustratingly difficult at all.
Anyway, wow, this is great. The fact that I already beat both on God and Titan mode respectively had turned me off of doing it again to get the trophies, but since those won't be trophies, looks like I might go trophy hunting after all. #godofwarcollection
"I have never understood why people find it so difficult."
And? What's your philosophical point? That you're too good? Or that most players are tards?
According to Santa Monica themselves, The Styx was the only level that didn't go through focus tests, and it painfully shows. On my first playthrough, I died about 50 times trying to top those fucking columns because of the buggy collision masks.
Two years later, on my second playthrough, despite being dead nervous at the idea of having to deal with those bloody columns again, I climbed both of them on my first try -- go figure. All I can say is that I am positively certain the collision mask was much tighter the second time around. #godofwarcollection
My point was that I don't understand why people find it so hard. Yeah, the collision detection is off, but after you get hit once or twice you can make adjustments and estimations about how close Kratos can be to the spikes. #godofwarcollection
These collection just increased it's sales a bit by having 2 plats. Trophy whores everywhere are foaming at the mouth at the prospect of 2 platinums for 40 bucks.
@Archaotic: Yeah, that blast shard trophy was crazy hard. I actually spent like 2 hours just getting the trophy for having half of the blast shards and then gave up on the rest. #godofwarcollection
@Slagathorian: I'm missing one. Exactly one. I've combed all three islands, I've searched every easily missed location, and I just can't friggin' find it. #godofwarcollection
@Archaotic: God don't remind me of those damn shards, i thought it was going to be easy finding them(being able to see them on the map and all)but damn it was i wrong. #godofwarcollection
@Curse lily: It WAS easy finding them until you get to the VERY LAST one. I think Sucker Punch needs to make them show up on the full-size map after you beat the game. It's only fair. #godofwarcollection
@Archaotic: the one most people miss in on the east coast on the first island out on a pylon sticking up out of the water. The shard-dar barely picks it up. #godofwarcollection
@enaero: the stunts is the worse of the 2. because with teh stunts, only some can be done done at certain points in the game. im trying to muster the patience to get the stunts, cuz the other i have left are a cakewalk next to that trophy. #godofwarcollection
This still has the demo for GoW 3 right? Either way, I'll probably snap this up at some point.
Really, there should be more compilation releases like this. That Mega Man compilation was such a great buy. I'd love to see Nintendo lump every Zelda from OoT up to Twilight Princess onto a compilation with a few features. Or if Square would throw all the SaGa games onto a compilation. Or, "Ratchet and Clank's Greatest Hits": put trophies into the PS2 games and toss them all together, with a couple more interlocking features. That's good gaming. #godofwarcollection
11/01/09
At the time I played the hell out of those games, but I still can't get them trophies. I was really happy with the Uncharted trophy list... these are very doable and may be my first (hopefully, not last) platinum. #uncharted2
11/01/09
Marco!
Polo!
I stumbled across that set by accident and got such a laugh... #uncharted2
10/31/09
I'm not a perfectionist or an achievement whore by any means (well, excluding TF2) but I really wish more devs would think like this. Achievements should be impressive-but-relevant things like "Kill 6 people at once with 1 grenade" or something. An in-game medal should be "Bounce a grenade off someone's head to kill them". #ps3
10/31/09
10/31/09
10/31/09
10/31/09
10/31/09
10/31/09
10/31/09
That being said, I hate them, not only does it cut off those who don't have their systems connected to the internet from ever obtaining them, but its just a cheap way for them to try and say, hey, look how many people we have playing our game online, even if the online completely sucks.
Thus I must say, I love Naughty Dog for keeping their trophies to single player only, the same as CoD Modern Warfare. It had amazing online so they didn't need to implement achievements into it to get people to play it.
10/31/09
A trophy is just a paperweight in your cabinet. Sure, having a goal creates lucrative incentive to go further than you might do otherwise. But the real joy is telling people "how" you bowled that 300. #ps3
10/31/09
Ones given through the normal course of play are fine and all, but they get no response out of me at all. :O
If you give me a trophy for backstabbing 500 enemies in Demon's Souls, i'm game.
A trophy for every boss I beat? 'meh, whatev'.
'Beast Mode' sounds like a trophy worth having. #ps3
10/31/09
I hate forced multiplayer trophies and achievements, so I'm glad to see they didn't put in a ton of those. The only two in the game are incredibly easy to pull off. #ps3
10/31/09
10/31/09
10/31/09
That or let's put a higher tier above platinum (like diamond) so that distinction could exist. lol
10/27/09
Anyway, wow, this is great. The fact that I already beat both on God and Titan mode respectively had turned me off of doing it again to get the trophies, but since those won't be trophies, looks like I might go trophy hunting after all. #godofwarcollection
10/27/09
"I have never understood why people find it so difficult."
And? What's your philosophical point? That you're too good? Or that most players are tards?
According to Santa Monica themselves, The Styx was the only level that didn't go through focus tests, and it painfully shows. On my first playthrough, I died about 50 times trying to top those fucking columns because of the buggy collision masks.
Two years later, on my second playthrough, despite being dead nervous at the idea of having to deal with those bloody columns again, I climbed both of them on my first try -- go figure. All I can say is that I am positively certain the collision mask was much tighter the second time around. #godofwarcollection
10/27/09
My point was that I don't understand why people find it so hard. Yeah, the collision detection is off, but after you get hit once or twice you can make adjustments and estimations about how close Kratos can be to the spikes. #godofwarcollection
10/27/09
10/27/09
These collection just increased it's sales a bit by having 2 plats. Trophy whores everywhere are foaming at the mouth at the prospect of 2 platinums for 40 bucks.
Hahaha... #godofwarcollection
10/27/09
DAMN YOU, BLAST SHARDS! *shakes a fist at inFAMOUS* #godofwarcollection
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
Really, there should be more compilation releases like this. That Mega Man compilation was such a great buy. I'd love to see Nintendo lump every Zelda from OoT up to Twilight Princess onto a compilation with a few features. Or if Square would throw all the SaGa games onto a compilation. Or, "Ratchet and Clank's Greatest Hits": put trophies into the PS2 games and toss them all together, with a couple more interlocking features. That's good gaming. #godofwarcollection