Website Says Nintendo Threat Forced Them To Pull Hundreds Of Fan Games [UPDATE]

A screenshot of webpage that hosted one of hundreds of games Nintendo targeted at GitHub. The page was cached on Google.
A screenshot of webpage that hosted one of hundreds of games Nintendo targeted at GitHub. The page was cached on Google.

In a mass filing under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), Nintendo has apparently flagged over 550 titles for takedown. Focusing on the site Game Jolt, a notice said to come from Nintendo listed a total of 562 titles for removal from the site. The majority of these titles were fan made tributes or independent works.


Update—10:55 p.m.: A mistake was made in the previous update regarding sources we reached out to for confirmation. We incorrectly stated that a Nintendo representative offered confirmation. While follow up confirmation was offered by Game Jolt, there has been no further comment from Nintendo at this time. I personally apologize for this error.

Update—8:05 p.m.: After reaching out to a Nintendo representative, Kotaku has received confirmation that the company did file the claim in question.

The alleged statement shows that the company seeks to protect copyright over the Super Mario, Legend of Zelda, and Pokemon franchises. This comes after the prominent Metroid 2 remake AM2R received a DMCA from the company and the creators of fan game Pokemon Uranium pulled download links from their own website after mirror sites received takedown notices as well.

Trademarked material is required to be protected by harsh measures so that their meaning isn’t diluted. For instance, too many unofficial Mario games without action would imperil the trademark on Mario. Nintendo are well within their rights to protect their works. That is not in dispute. Still, the company has proven highly litigious, cracking down hard on fan creations with a particular swiftness.

The subject can be tricky to navigate. Given the visibility of Nintendo’s franchises and their clear continued desire to use their trademarks, I find it hard to believe that the company was at risk of losing much here. On the other hand, a gross failure to police trademarks can be grounds for losing them.

For now, Game Jolt has created a system for game creators to quickly make their games private. Invisible and locked away from the public, hundreds of games will hang in legal and existential limbo, visible only to their creators. It’s a shame. There was a BMX game with Mario. I totally would have played a BMX game starring Mario.

Former Senior Writer and Critic at Kotaku.



In order to have a copyright and a trademark you MUST go after all things that infringe on said intellectual property, failure to do so risks you losing your copyright. Nintendo is just doing what Nintendo has to do. They capitalize on IP, not on hardware sales.