The Plot Twist In Star Ocean: Till The End Of Time Is A Lot More Believable Today

Illustration for article titled The Plot Twist In Star Ocean: Till The End Of Time Is A Lot More Believable Today

Most video games are content just to string the player along through dungeons, towns, or corridors full of machine gun cover while dishing out character arcs and weapon upgrades. Only a few try to reflect on the nature of reality and human existence. Star Ocean: Till the End of Time tried to do both.


The fourth game in developer tri-Ace’s science-fiction RPG series, Till the End of Time, which came to the PS4 last week, was notable for a few different reasons. It was the first entry to appear on a semi-modern console with the PS2, and thus the first to bring players into a 3D world inhabited by polygons instead of sprites. It was also the last game in the series that you could say was totally great without wincing or having to recite a list of caveats the length of a novel.

But most importantly, it was the Star Ocean that revealed its characters’ world wasn’t real. Fayt, Sophia, and the rest of the motley crew were all part of a computer simulation created by an advanced civilization. They were avatars inside of a video game, inside of a video game. In classic Star Ocean fashion, the threat that brings the game’s characters together early on turns out to be rather parochial by the mid-way point. The intercontinental struggles of alien races who inhabit familiar fantasy settings are eventually superseded by the real threat: monsters called “Executioners” who act like a virus trying to delete anomalies in the character’s simulated universe.

Illustration for article titled The Plot Twist In Star Ocean: Till The End Of Time Is A Lot More Believable Today

It all starts when your characters bust through a magic time portal and arrive in a futuristic city occupied by a few NPCs. One of them screams. Another simply states, “Something came out of the Eternal Sphere display,” while a third responds, “Cool is that a new feature?” Instead of ending up in some dungeon to fight an esoteric boss, the characters are transported outside of the game simulation that created them, resulting in a series of long conversations that approximate the nonsense spouted by The Matrix: Reloaded if it had been passed through a JRPG localization team first. It was supposed to be an amazing twist. The first time I played Till the End of Time I thought it was massive cop-out.

Almost thirteen years later, I feel a bit differently. At the time the twist felt completely out of left field, with the melodrama of the characters reacting to their new existential crisis adding an additional series of eye rolls. Now, the questions poised by the game’s bizarre turn of events do feel more science fiction than untethered fantasy. After all, tech billionaire Elon Musk is a believer. Knowing the trajectory technology is on and the eventual likelihood of convincing virtual realities that might proliferate in the future, what are the odds that our reality is the original one? Not to mention how much of our lives already seem to resemble the weird logic of a designed game.

Illustration for article titled The Plot Twist In Star Ocean: Till The End Of Time Is A Lot More Believable Today

In a panel discussion last year, resident blockbuster movie debunker Neil deGrasse Tyson made a similar argument. It’s not so much a scientific question of whether empirical evidence or the mathematical equations that help explain how are universe functions can shed light on whether we live in a computer simulation as a philosophical one. If we could be living in a video game, how do we know we aren’t?

The result of this paradox is one that René Descartes spent his life’s work trying to unravel. “I think therefore I am,” he famously quipped, not solving the problem so much as collapsing it into irrelevance. If you can’t prove you aren’t living inside an illusion created by a malevolent demon, or in Till the End of Time’s case, a massively-multiplayer online RPG, does it really even matter?

Illustration for article titled The Plot Twist In Star Ocean: Till The End Of Time Is A Lot More Believable Today

The game come’s to a similar conclusion by the end as well. In what remains one of the most confusing climaxes in a video game, Fayt, Sophia, and their friends manage to defeat the “creator” of their simulated universe, but not prevent the mass deletion of it he set in motion. Still, everything seems to turn out just fine, with life returning to normal, potentially thanks to a “Eternal Sphere backup,” but also maybe not. The game can’t seem to resolve the paradox at the center of its big plot twist either, choosing instead to shove it aside and simply let it hover over the game’s different endings. Maybe the characters were deleted and by the end we’re simply witnessing the echos of their consciousnesses. Or maybe the creators they thought they were encountering in the “real” world were simply the constructs of another simulated universe created by somebody else.


Now that the game’s available again on PS4, you can always go find out for yourself. I definitely recommend doing that over trying the latest addition to the series, Star Ocean: Integrity and Faithlessness, proof that our universe might be real after all, since no civilization advanced enough to create a digital simulation of another would ever add that to it.

Kotaku staff writer. You can reach him at





As a huge fan of Star Ocean: The Second Story (the first one localized), I just want to say: FUCK this twist. Fuck it straight to hell. SO3 - and the series itself as a whole - was better before it happened. It wasn’t just a twist for the characters of this game - it affected the entire Star Ocean universe and its lore. It effectively threw out ALL the lore building with the various alien races and worlds and said, “The universe in this series is just an MMO! Go home folks, we’re done!”

The series has struggled to recover from this mistake ever since, with SO4 being a prequel to the entire series that only serves to explain where the Underdeveloped Planet Protection Pact came from, and SO5 was... well SO5 was even worse. If they were to finally make a Star Ocean game that takes place after 3 - which, due to the severity of this plot twist would require a retcon of it entirely - the series might actually be able to live on.