Lawsuit Claims Capcom Stole Pictures For Resident Evil And Devil May Cry

resident evil 4 lawsuit
Screenshot: Capcom

A designer is suing Capcom over improper use of licensed material, Polygon reports. According to a lawsuit filed Friday, Capcom used unlicensed photographs as art assets in Resident Evil 4, Devil May Cry, and other games.

Advertisement

Judy A. Juracek, an author and artist, filed suit in U.S. District Court in Connecticut on Friday. In 1996, Juracek published Surfaces: Visual Research For Artists, Architects, And Designers, a compendium of detailed photographs largely focusing on surface textures and how they change over time. In addition to interviews with a handful of design experts, the book is intended to allow people to use those photos in projects. But, as Friday’s suit states, using the photos for commercial purposes requires a licensing fee, which Capcom allegedly did not pay.

Juracek supplemented the complaint with more than 100 pages of supporting documents, showing photographic comparisons between screenshots of Capcom’s video games and photographs from Surfaces. In one, you can clearly see the facade of a door in Surfaces matching the facade of a door in Resident Evil. Another photo directly mirrors the cracked-glass designed that characterizes the “4" in the Resident Evil 4 logo.

An exhibit from the lawsuit showing similarities between images from Surfaces and Resident Evil
An exhibit from the lawsuit showing similarities between images from Surfaces and Resident Evil
Screenshot: Judy A. Juracek/ Capcom via Courtlistener

Theoretically, it is very technically possible that, in making these games, Capcom sent photographers to each and every cited location in Juracek’s tome. That seems highly unlikely, and would be a high bar to clear in court.

Friday’s suit states that Capcom owes Juracek anywhere from $2,500 to $25,000 per photo, and says that Capcom unlawfully used around 80 photos in total. The suit also claims Capcom could owe Juracek up to $12 million for copyright infringement, alongside legal fees. Lawyers are requesting a jury trial.

Capcom told Polygon it is “aware of the lawsuit” but declined to comment further to the outlet.

Advertisement

Read Polygon’s report here, which includes an uploaded copy of the complaint and exhibits in full.

Staff Writer, Kotaku

DISCUSSION

masterchief3624
MasterChief3624

I don’t understand how they took so much time to file this suit...  I would think they want to do it when Resident Evil is hot, hot, hot, but why not bring it up right before Village came out?  Why not wait for the RE4 remake?  It’s just weird to me whenever these suits take so long to actually come out.  It’s always suspicious timing.  But I 100% am on the side of the person suing.  Those are blatant.