I tried hard to get into this but I couldn't. At first it wouldn't let me download it- at all. Then it froze on me - twice. I probably played almost one session and it's a nice concept, just too much frustration on my end.
The problem with it is that people spamming X can get into the mob, while people really playing don't get a chance.
My girlfriend and I played all season, but the algorithm for getting in is ridiculous - neither one of us made it into the mob, even though we had scores way above others and played more than other people. I chatted with one guy in that had gotten in the mob 6 times. Six!
It should be random, and accounts should only be allowed in once per season. I watched someone be The One and then was in the mob the following round.
When you realize you don't actually have a chance to get in unless you cheat, it takes the fun out of it. #1vs100
@jayntampa: I got into the mob several times without any sort of cheating. Just normal play. When there are tens of thousands of people playing, the odds just aren't great that you'll be picked. #1vs100
@Tim Reilly: It's been pretty clearly documented. Check it out.
And, again, you just proved my point that it sucks ... you got in several times while most people didn't get in once. That's not fair. It should be a one shot thing per season.
Do they have live shows that aren't on a Friday or Saturday night? I remember looking at the last run and I think they were all on either of those nights. I see the extended play kicks off on a Thursday, but there's no details regarding the Live Shows. I think that it would be great if they had one midweek Live Show. #1vs100
Getting into the live game was easy. The problem is, it requires taking advantage of what was essentially a bug in their algorithm for choosing contestants.
Before I learned about the bug, I could play all of the extended play sessions I wanted and I never made it in once. After I learned about the bug, I could not play all week and still be in the mob within the first half hour of the live show.
With any luck, they'll have fixed it this time around. Cheating the system shouldn't work. #1vs100
My sister has been bugging me and asking when it was coming back. I kept saying winter, because I saw the date December 31st, 2009 on the Primetime Channel. Good thing I just got my Gold membership back because she's gonna wanna be playing it. #1vs100
@Phydeaux: I'd be so upset by that. If there's an achievement for it, you sure as hell know more people are going to play trying to get them, lessening the odds of getting into the Mob or being the One. #1vs100
@nerdrage32: The Group Hug achievement would be the hardest to get, but it's definitely doable in extended play.
Other than that, I'm happy - none of these other than Low Rider are overly disruptive to the game, and that one should only affect the individual playing. #1vs100
With the frequent, full blown commercials that run in the show, I fully expect this gameshow to be available for those with Silver accounts. At least when it comes out of Beta. #1vs100
I spent a lot of time playing this. The beauty of is that it's a game that your girl can get excited about, too (at least mine did). We had a lot of good laughs, and some friendly competition doing it; it is a decent break from all the high intensity games. If you are only playing for the prizes, though, I don't think you'll like it. #1vs100
@Sorzante: Hah, "know enough to realize what it is" theyre not exactly an underground band, being the Godfathers of european power metal, anyone thats into metal knows them.
but yeh man, absolute class act! one of the first ever singles I got was Dr stein, brb, gonna have to listen to the entire discography. #1vs100
1 vs 100 pisses me off. :( For a long time I played thinking I had a chance of getting something out of it, but apparently I was just a "viewer" or whatever, WATCHING the real people play, and just playing along. I thought everybody who played was put in a group of 101.
That's not fun, microsoft!
Once I realized I had no chance of winning anything, even like 10 ms points, I lost interest. But I still played a bit, hoping for a chance to be the main guy or at least part of the 100. But then I was told the ridiculous requirements for such a thing to even POTENTIALLY happen, and just didn't bother. I was weeks behind and had no chance of catching up, and it just totally was no longer any fun.
The idea of a widespread tons-of-people-play gameshow video game complete with prizes is really awesome! But not when there isn't the slightest chance of getting in unless you played from the very start.
Komrade Kayce promoted this comment
Edited by WhiteMage says fix the comments grr at 11/09/09 9:43 AM
WhiteMage says fix the comments grr was starred
WhiteMage says fix the comments grr was unstarred
You know you can still win things and not be part of the mob or the one, right?
The top couple of players in the audience always go home (or in this case, stay home) with free ms points or arcade games. You just have a much much larger base of people competing against you for them. #1vs100
@WhiteMage says fix the comments grr: You are never weeks behind. The game resets for extended play every week. Your lifetime score carries over of course but they do not select for the mob or the one based on lifetime score, only your performance in extended play in the week prior to the live show.
They use a lot of different criteria to choose the one and the mob. I got to be in the mob once and I was a pretty casual player of the game.
What I think is odd is the fact that you seem to think that everyone should get a chance to be the one or in the Mob. The reality of the situation is that there are too many players and so you have to perform well in order to get into the big show. I don't think that's unreasonable... I think that's life.
@Slothboy: I played very regularly, at least one live show, and easily a dozen or more extended play sessions a week... my scoring was frequently very good (eg had runs of 22 or 23 correct answers), including winning an extended play session, and being 'placed' in a few others.
Yet I *never*got into the mob.
Now, I'm not saying - as you seem to be suggesting that Whitemage is saying - that "Aww gee whiz, everyone should have a go!" but it does seem stupidly calculated. I have seen on *at least* three occasions, somebody get picked as The One who had a gamerscore of zero. Zero! Now, I realise there's no achievements etc for 1vs100 yet, but a gamerscore of zero says that the person doesn't really play games, and so is unlikely to have put in huge amounts of effort into this one to up their chances of being picked. That's not a certainty of course, just an assumption, but it did frustrate me in ways I can't quite articulate...
And the number of times that The One fumbled a pathetically easy question - sometimes even the first one of the round - I couldn't say, but it was a LOT. And I know the old saying "It's only easy if you know the answer", but when you get something like (and I'm making this up as an example, but it WAS this level of stupidity) "Who was Prime Minister of Britain in WW2?" and the player ignores the answers "Winston Churchill" and "George Washington" and plumps for "Emperor Ming The Merciless"... you've GOT to wonder if the selection process isn't somewhat 'faulty'!
@ZombieDispatch: Later in the beta people figured out an exploit to get into the mob/be the one very easily. Since one of the game's criteria for selecting the mob/one was "answering speed" folks figured out they could mash a button and get super speed. It didn't take into account fastest RIGHT answer, just fastest answer.
Lots of the zero gamerscore were people on second accounts trying to be the one again, using the same exploit, because you can only be the one once per season.
Look for that to be fixed this time around so you should have a better sampling of people that actually play it straight making it into the mob.
I still haven't even played this. To be honest, I've never even seen the show. Is it worth paying attention to? Most modern game shows are just painfully stupid, I find.
I'm personally a fan of Gold Case on NBC. :O #1vs100
@Archaotic: The show notsomuch (though the bits where they get particular groups of people involved is funny, i.e. 5 nuns have been added to the mob, 20 auto workers have been added to the mob, etc.), but the game on LIVE is good if you just flat like trivia.
I love the concept of this game - you actually win real prizes (ms points but its still real).
I want something like this to be on my ps3 - i have buzz and that is good for get togethers but not when i want to actually win real prizes.
The thing is; do you have to pay to play this game or what? I know it says it's a Beta, does this mean that it will get a commercial release and you will have to pay for the real game?? #1vs100
11/09/09
I'll stick to my Netflix and games. #1vs100
11/09/09
My girlfriend and I played all season, but the algorithm for getting in is ridiculous - neither one of us made it into the mob, even though we had scores way above others and played more than other people. I chatted with one guy in that had gotten in the mob 6 times. Six!
It should be random, and accounts should only be allowed in once per season. I watched someone be The One and then was in the mob the following round.
When you realize you don't actually have a chance to get in unless you cheat, it takes the fun out of it. #1vs100
11/09/09
11/09/09
And, again, you just proved my point that it sucks ... you got in several times while most people didn't get in once. That's not fair. It should be a one shot thing per season.
11/09/09
Also, you never accepted the invites to play with us! *shakes fist* #1vs100
11/09/09
11/09/09
11/09/09
They didn't last season, but they always could in the future. #1vs100
11/09/09
Before I learned about the bug, I could play all of the extended play sessions I wanted and I never made it in once. After I learned about the bug, I could not play all week and still be in the mob within the first half hour of the live show.
With any luck, they'll have fixed it this time around. Cheating the system shouldn't work. #1vs100
11/09/09
11/09/09
11/09/09
And please for the love of God if there is, no "Got into the Mob", "Became The One" achievements. {shudders}
11/09/09
11/09/09
Low Rider - 5G -Answer instantly and incorrectly three times in a row
Showboating Specialist - 10G - In a single 1 vs 100 LIVE round, max out your Avatar Action 10 times.
Thrifty Skipper - 10 G - Extended Play: In a single round, save up the maximum of three skips.
Speedy Delivery - 20G - In a single round, score a total of 1300 points through time bonuses.
Game Show Guru - 25G - In any single round, achieve a Streak of 12 correct answers.
Quick Draw - 25G - In a single round, receive six consecutive Instant Answer Bonuses
Golden Century - 25G - Answer a total of 100 questions correctly.
Hair Trigger - 15G - Get three consecutive questions right while receiving an Instant Answer Bonus for each.
Trivia Fanatic - 30G - Answer a total of 500 questions
Go Streaking! - 15G - In a single round, achieved a Streak of 5 consecutive correct answers.
Group Hug - 10G - Your team of four achieved a simultaneous Streak of three consecutive correct answers.
Quarter Century -10G - Answer a total of 25 questions correct
Seems fair enough. #1vs100
11/09/09
Other than that, I'm happy - none of these other than Low Rider are overly disruptive to the game, and that one should only affect the individual playing. #1vs100
11/09/09
11/09/09
11/09/09
11/09/09
11/09/09
11/09/09
04:17 AM
11/09/09
11/09/09
Unrelated, just wanted to say your user pic is the greatest to ever grace these fine walls of Kotaku. #1vs100
11/09/09
11/09/09
but yeh man, absolute class act! one of the first ever singles I got was Dr stein, brb, gonna have to listen to the entire discography. #1vs100
11/09/09
That's not fun, microsoft!
Once I realized I had no chance of winning anything, even like 10 ms points, I lost interest. But I still played a bit, hoping for a chance to be the main guy or at least part of the 100. But then I was told the ridiculous requirements for such a thing to even POTENTIALLY happen, and just didn't bother. I was weeks behind and had no chance of catching up, and it just totally was no longer any fun.
The idea of a widespread tons-of-people-play gameshow video game complete with prizes is really awesome! But not when there isn't the slightest chance of getting in unless you played from the very start.
11/09/09
You know you can still win things and not be part of the mob or the one, right?
The top couple of players in the audience always go home (or in this case, stay home) with free ms points or arcade games. You just have a much much larger base of people competing against you for them. #1vs100
11/09/09
They use a lot of different criteria to choose the one and the mob. I got to be in the mob once and I was a pretty casual player of the game.
What I think is odd is the fact that you seem to think that everyone should get a chance to be the one or in the Mob. The reality of the situation is that there are too many players and so you have to perform well in order to get into the big show. I don't think that's unreasonable... I think that's life.
I'm super excited for the new season. #1vs100
11/09/09
Yet I *never*got into the mob.
Now, I'm not saying - as you seem to be suggesting that Whitemage is saying - that "Aww gee whiz, everyone should have a go!" but it does seem stupidly calculated. I have seen on *at least* three occasions, somebody get picked as The One who had a gamerscore of zero. Zero! Now, I realise there's no achievements etc for 1vs100 yet, but a gamerscore of zero says that the person doesn't really play games, and so is unlikely to have put in huge amounts of effort into this one to up their chances of being picked. That's not a certainty of course, just an assumption, but it did frustrate me in ways I can't quite articulate...
And the number of times that The One fumbled a pathetically easy question - sometimes even the first one of the round - I couldn't say, but it was a LOT. And I know the old saying "It's only easy if you know the answer", but when you get something like (and I'm making this up as an example, but it WAS this level of stupidity) "Who was Prime Minister of Britain in WW2?" and the player ignores the answers "Winston Churchill" and "George Washington" and plumps for "Emperor Ming The Merciless"... you've GOT to wonder if the selection process isn't somewhat 'faulty'!
(This was playing in the UK, by the way) #1vs100
11/09/09
Lots of the zero gamerscore were people on second accounts trying to be the one again, using the same exploit, because you can only be the one once per season.
Look for that to be fixed this time around so you should have a better sampling of people that actually play it straight making it into the mob.
11/09/09
I'm personally a fan of Gold Case on NBC. :O #1vs100
11/09/09
Kenneth Parcell's idea was wonderful, if a bit flawed in execution. #1vs100
11/09/09
It's worth trying once. #1vs100
11/09/09
11/09/09
11/09/09
11/09/09
11/09/09
I want something like this to be on my ps3 - i have buzz and that is good for get togethers but not when i want to actually win real prizes.
The thing is; do you have to pay to play this game or what? I know it says it's a Beta, does this mean that it will get a commercial release and you will have to pay for the real game?? #1vs100
11/09/09
11/09/09
11/09/09