By Edge, anyway. They're saying that an underworld Overlord II foursome takes the cake, precisely for what it does not show.
Overlord II's "foursome" scene is the best of the year. Yes, it's a scene where you, the hero, have a foursome. And yes, it's juvie wish fulfillment. But it's also a smartly done and properly incentivised scene that in two minutes, gets everything right.
In the video above, you see how your three evil mistresses have chosen to call a bedroom truce, leaving everything and nothing to the imagination of course. I did like the gratuitous booting of the imp midway through. Like, come on bro, didn't you see the tie on the doorknob?
Two things: One, it's interesting they award this now, when we haven't seen all that Dragon Age: Origins has to offer. And that has demon tits. And implied bestiality. I get that Edge wanted to reward a creative depiction of sexuality, but seriously, you think Dragon Age isn't gonna pack some titillation?
Overlord II: The Best Sex Scene of the Year {Edge via Joystiq]