Maybe Yoda Was Actually Horrible, Awful, and Totally Evil

Illustration for article titled Maybe Yoda Was Actually Horrible, Awful, and Totally Evil

Fairly or unfairly, Star Wars creator George Lucas is often pegged as public enemy number one for a variety of reasons. But for sci-fi author David Brin, there's another baddie: Yoda.


Brin, a NASA consultant and a Dreamcast game scribe, has discussed his distaste for both Lucas' work and the Jedi Master on multiple occasions—such as in Star Wars on Trial. Recently, he told Wired:

I consider Yoda to be just about the most evil character that I've ever seen in the history of literature. I have gotten people into tongue-tied snits unable to name for me one scene in which Yoda is ever helpful to anybody, or says anything that's genuinely wise. "Do or do not, there is no try." Up yours, you horrible little oven mitt! "Try" is how human beings get better. That's how people learn, they try some of their muscles, or their Force mechanism heads in the right direction, that part gets reinforced and rewarded with positive feedback, which you never give. And parts of it get repressed by saying, "No, that you will not do!" It is abhorrent, junior high school Zen. It's cartoon crap.


Tell us what you really think, David! In the rest of the Wired interview, the author also discusses his brand new novel, Existence, among other topics. More in the link below.

Why David Brin Hates Yoda, Loves Radical Transparency [Wired]

(Top photo: nooblar | DeviantArt)

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


He did condone creating a disposable army out of millions of clones who had no choice but to get murdered in a variety of creative ways by unfeeling robots. I hesitate to get TOO in-depth about the particular morals of Star Wars characters for obvious reasons, but it does seem a little contrary to his peaceful space-monk act. There's also all that creepy religious 'sex-is-sin' stuff too.

Little green fucker.