Back in February, the open-source indie game engine Godot, used to make hits like Slay the Spire 2, was in the midst of a pretty messy problem: the engine’s GitHub repository, which allows developers to contribute to the engine itself, was drowning in AI-generated pull requests. Contributors complained of a ā€œshitshowā€ where nothing made sense, and game developers using the engine noticed a massive bottleneck where pull requests took significantly longer to gain approval. Currently, Godot’s GitHub has over 5,000 unresolved pull requests. It even caused Godot’s project manager, RĆ©mi Verschelde, to speak out about the ongoing mess.Ā 

ā€œHonestly, AI slop [pull requests] are becoming increasingly draining and demoralizing for #Godot maintainers,ā€ Verschelde wrote on Bluesky in February.

On Tuesday, Godot revealed changes to its contribution policy that require ā€œall code to be human-authoredā€ in an attempt to curb the onslaught of AI-generated junk. The policy also enforces the engine’s preexisting ban on vibe coding. However, using AI for ā€œmenialā€ tasks like finding and replacing phrases, or autocompleting code, is still allowed as long as it’s accompanied by a proper disclosure.

ā€œAI contributions have the added pain of being demoralizing,” the update reads. ā€œReviewing PRs is already tedious work, but it is rewarding because reviewers generally feel that their efforts are contributing to educating a new contributor (who may become a future maintainer/reviewer). If your feedback on PRs is just being absorbed by a machine and not going towards mentoring a potential future maintainer, it becomes much harder to justify spending your free time on PR review.ā€

The policy also requires that communication in messages, like descriptions of GitHub issues or pull requests, must be written by humans.

ā€œWhen our maintainers volunteer their time to review your issue, PR, or proposal, they do not want to talk to a machine,ā€ the policy reads. ā€œThis is a basic principle of respect.ā€ Nice!

Godot’s contribution policy was already fairly anti-AI, mentioning that the team is ā€œconvinced that human effort results in better and more relevant contributions.ā€ But this new, more explicit policy might help curb the bottleneck caused by contributors who ignored the team’s preference. Godot users seem pretty happy with the change, too.

ā€œThank god, hope this helps out in the long run,ā€ one Reddit user wrote.

Godot is a fantastic little engine (I’ve worked with it myself!) that grew increasingly appealing after titans like Unity and Unreal began incorporating generative AI tools and introducing wacky policies that alienated developers. I know I’ll be using it again whenever I get around to my next game dev project.Ā 

šŸ•¹ļø Level up your inbox

Don’t miss the latest reviews, news and tips. Sign up for our free newsletter.

You May Also Like