Backhanded Box Quotes: "Tolerable With Friends ... but So Is Dying of Bowel Cancer."

Welcome back to "Backhanded Box Quotes," a collection of measured, thoughtful criticism from the user reviews of Metacritic, Amazon and elsewhere.

Two games this week released to nearly universal acclaim, unless you're The Wall Street Journal. Borderlands 2 and Torchlight II. But in the great shining ideas marketplace and opinion democracy known as consumer reviews, both games have to answer to a harsher authority.


Borderlands 2

Released: Sept. 18

Critic: neilsmif1980 (Metacritic)
"I was stuck I couldn't move forward or back just after I got past a really hard part at the beginning of the game. It froze on me! So I restarted it and I had to start nearly back to the beginning?"

"The game itself is just like Borderlands EXCEPT you have a mini map."

Score: 0.

Critic:Get bodied (Amazon)
"It becomes tolerable if you do it with some friends around, but so is dying of bowel cancer."


"It's been a while since I've seen in-game menus as bad as these. It's like PowerPoint threw up on a Cluedo board and died."


Score: 1 Star.

Critic: Sock_Factory (Metacritic)

"Borderlands 2 is a game where you shoot guns at stuff till it dies."

Score: 0.

Torchlight II

Released: Sept. 20

Critic: disinterested (Metacritic)
"TLDR: Diablo3"

Score: 1.

Critic: Token 40k (Metacritic)
"crappy light gamma."

Score: 0.

Backhanded Box Quotes will be an occasional feature of Kotaku's Anger Management hour, unless it isn't.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter