Kirk: The audio is incredible. And Kenji Yamamoto’s music! Both just so, so good. As I was escaping the pirate ship in the prologue, I was certain the “Escape!” music was playing a busy signal. I have a note that says “Is this a busy signal?” And it totally is, check it out.

Advertisement

So good! Not many video game soundtracks are that good.

I’m sensing some of the smart things you’re talking about with the design and how it signposts things, but not all of it. Lots of games have lifted that sort of design, obviously, in the years since Metroid Prime came out. The idea of walking into a room, seeing a door you can’t open and thinking “Okay, I’ll just come back and open it when I’m able.” But Metroid has an unusual amount of subtlety going on with all that. It’s a remarkably subtle game in general, really. I’ll have to pay more attention to the audio cues you’re talking about—I’m sure there are a lot I’ve been missing.

Advertisement

Have you found yourself approaching the game differently now than you’d imagine I am, as a newbie? Do you do some things first, since you know what’s coming, or is the path the game carves for you generally still the thing to stick to, at least at first?

Stephen: I have the advantage of knowing how much I can’t do yet. Like most of those audio cues? You can’t do anything about them. Now that you’ll be listening for them you’ll notice where they are coming from, and you’ll realize how many parts of the rooms that you’re in are out of your reach.

Advertisement

And this is where Metroids make or break players, because some gamers loathe the concept of having to backtrack. Me? I love going back to one of the game’s starter areas, now with a radically different power set, and getting past previously un-passable obstacles.

Kirk: Oh yeah, I’m the same way. Partly because games have trained me to be, I think!

Advertisement

Stephen: One huge thing that will be lost on you is the historical impact of the game for people who grew up with Nintendo.

Advertisement

Kirk: It comes across, at least a bit. You mean that it’s a FPS?

Stephen: You had all these 2D games in the NES and SNES, right? Mario, Zelda, Metroid were three of the top games.

Advertisement

The N64 comes around, PlayStation is already clearly beginning to kick Nintendo around, and yet Nintendo figures out this thing where they can take a beloved 2D franchise and through the magic of polygonal graphics, put you in. Mario, but in 3D! You are IN the Mushroom Kingdom.

Advertisement

And so they do this for Mario and make arguably the best game ever. Then they do it for Zelda and top themselves, some would say.

But they go the whole N64 era with zero Metroid games on console.

And then they go to the GameCube and we’re in the moment of GTA and Final Fantasy X and all that, and Nintendo finally brings Metroid back, but... as a first-person shooter... largely developed by Americans.

Advertisement

So you have this very weird back-story, all these reasons to be skeptical, but the magic of the game for people who had been on that journey is that they do that magical thing again. They take a character and a world you only ever saw in 2D and they put you in it.

In fact, they put you even more in it, by putting you in Samus’ suit!

That’s hugely impactful and might be akin to finally going to the movie version of a novel you loved.

Advertisement

But, you, Kirk, you didn’t read the Metroid novel, so you’re like, whatever.

Kirk: Hahaha.

Stephen: The space station prologue is a terrific microcosm of the game, though. It doesn’t teach you backtracking, but it really sets the Metroid mood. You’ll fight a little, explore a lot, and you get to be a cool, silent lady bounty hunter in the process... though I guess there’s some looping back in it... not quite backtracking.

Advertisement

Kirk: I do get that part of it—I wasn’t a Nintendo Kid growing up, but I played Metroid on Game Boy, and loved the heck out of it. I can get how people would’ve thought it was amazing to step into Samus’ suit, to see through her visor. Plus, the game does a really good job of putting you in the suit in subtle ways. The way she uses her other hand to steady her gun arm when she shoots, how it places various things around on her HUD.

Advertisement

Samus really is a fascinating character. So many thinkpieces have already been written about her, and I wouldn’t dare try to add anything substantive at this point, but I do get a sense of her character from small things in the game. Related to that, a question: Do you think that the text that pops up when you scan something is her? Or is it just her computer? I keep feeling like I’m getting a small sense of her personality from each of those blurbs, but maybe I’m misreading it.

Stephen: Oh, I don’t read those as her. I read them as her computer or the spaceship (maybe one and the same). I am a scanning maniac, by the way.

Advertisement

Kirk: I keep forgetting to!

Stephen: I don’t know why I love scanning. I’m not usually a lore person.

Kirk: Maybe because they make it active?

Stephen: Yeah. Maybe it’s because you get the lore with little interruption.

Kirk: So all Dragon Age had to do was make your Inquisitor take out a magnifying glass in every scene and manually dig up lore entries. Problem solved!

Advertisement

Stephen: Yeah, that’d be nice. The scanning teaches you a lot more about the world.

Kirk: The scanning is indeed cool. I played a bit of Hunters on DS a looong time ago, and I remember finding the scanning charming even in that game. I like games where you can hit a button and get a “new” view of the world you’re already in. Which makes me think... was Metroid’s scanning visor a precursor to Arkham Asylum’s detective mode? It’d be interesting to look at all the ideas this game had that turned up in later games.

Advertisement

Stephen: Hunters was horrible. It’s barely a Metroid game.

Kirk: Ha, I thought people liked it! I didn’t play much.

Stephen: But you know the lead game designer and art director of the Prime games made that Batman Arkham Origins Vita/3DS game? Which is why it’s so Metroidy. Not as good a setting or moveset, though, so I didn’t feel like they got to strut their stuff as best they could.

Advertisement

To wind things down, let’s discuss the magnificence of the morph ball. You’re essentially also playing one of the, if not the, finest Transformers games ever made.

Advertisement

Kirk: Yeah, the morph ball is great. I just re-got it, and am glad to have it—though I already miss the ability to blow things up while in ball-mode. I like that it makes the game into a hybrid first- third-person game, which opens up all sorts of different possibilities for puzzles and exploration. Halo sort of did the same thing in 2001, but the third-person camera wasn’t something you could toggle on and off like you can in Metroid.

Advertisement

Stephen: Yeah, it’s a credit to them that they pull off the morph ball without making the whole thing look absurd. It’s one of the last vestiges of the goofy movement ideas you’d get in 2D games that was effectively brought into 3D gaming.

I wonder if you noticed some half-pipe-looking parts of the rooms you were in. Imagine if there was a way to use them with the morph ball. Hmmm. You have so many awesome things to discover!

Advertisement

Do you think you’ll keep playing?

Kirk: I do! You know me, I’ve always got too many things to play, but something about having this entire trilogy right here is too enticing. Not only does it feel like an important missing piece in my “I can’t believe you haven’t played that” backlog, it sounds like all three games are really fun. So yeah, I’ll keep playing as long as I’m having fun, which I sense will be until I finish.

Advertisement

Do you think you’ll keep playing? If so, maybe we can circle back once we’ve both played more.

Stephen: Yeah, I usually don’t re-play old games, because I’m skeptical about my enjoyment of them and am convinced that most older games were products of their time that have been improved upon in terms of design and hospitality to the player. But I’ve loved my return playthrough of Majora’s Mask on 3DS, and I’m delighted with my time back in Metroid Prime. I’ve tried to go back to them before and always stopped somewhere in the first game.

Advertisement

I know that Prime 2 is the least-loved entry of the series, but I remember liking it the most (of course). It has the most visually-striking area of the entire series and also the most unusual visor mode that I can’t wait to re-experience.

I want to play all three all over again, so, yeah, I’m back in—if a bit bummed that I can’t play these Wii U games on the GamePad with the dual-analog controls. Oh well.

Advertisement

Let’s definitely do this again when you’re further in. How about this. Let’s not do it again until you see Samus’ face. That’s a teaser for you!

Kirk: !!!! Okay, sold.

UPDATE: Read the next part of this conversation.