Warcraft Fans Are Warring Over What WoW Classic Should Be

Image credit: Blizzard.
Image credit: Blizzard.

When World of Warcraft first came out, it meant a lot of different things to a lot of different people. Now that WoW Classic’s been announced, that’s become a problem—one that’s forced Blizzard to step in and pry people’s figurative hands off other people’s figurative throats.


The central argument centers around how much current WoW people want in their WoW Classic. Some players are open to the idea of the game’s current balance and graphical techniques seeping into old-school WoW’s beloved but cracked foundation, while purists argue that Classic should represent the vanilla experience exactly as it was, annoyances and all, because that makes progress more rewarding in the end.

Many discussions on the official WoW Classic forums have turned into heated arguments. One thread about class balancing—that is, revamping old classes to make them less specialized and more broadly capable—got locked by Blizzard after things got out of hand.

“We do not want players on our forums attacking each other left and right. People are free to have their opinions, on both sides of these arguments, and we will be following them closely,” wrote Blizzard community manager Bret “Ornyx” Forbus. “We will not, however, play into the hands of people directing their followers to make attacks against our community or otherwise conflagrate the community we have on these forums.”


As of now, Forbus wrote, it seems like the majority of potential players are against class balance, something Blizzard will be taking into account as it irons out its vision for Classic servers.

Since then, however, other threads discussing the pros and cons of everything from more convenient travel options to threat management options for tanks have popped up, some more civil than others.

Kotaku reached out to Vaelanor, lead GM of the unofficial WoW legacy server Light’s Hope (and, before that, Elysium, which lost most of its staffers after a major scandal), to ask why, in the days following Blizzard’s simple announcement of Classic, things have already reached a boiling point.


“Passion,” he said over Discord. “The purists have been fighting to get Blizzard to re-release Vanilla for 12 years. Most of us have dreamed of, fought for, and cried over being told this was happening. It’s this passion that overwhelms many and prevents them from having a level-headed conversation over why a change isn’t a good idea.”

While WoW Classic is still an undefined quantity, this situation has been revealing in one concrete way: it’s become clear that, no matter what, Blizzard’s official take on the legacy server idea, won’t be able to please everyone. Vaelanor knows this from personal experience, having made changes to popular unofficial legacy servers, only to see some players get up in burly, green orc arms. As a result, he thinks it’s possible that unofficial legacy servers like Light’s Hope will stick around even after Classic comes out.

Illustration for article titled iWarcraft /iFans Are Warring Over What iWoW Classic/i Should Beem/em

“Some people will feel WoW Classic wasn’t good enough,” he said. “Every legacy player has a line in the sand. If Blizzard cross enough of those lines then yes, there will be a demand from the community for unofficial legacy servers that stick more true to Vanilla.”


Vaelanor, though, is planning to get out of the legacy game as soon as WoW Classic launches, regardless of its quality. Right now, he just wants to see everybody be constructive, rather than combative. More craft, less war.

“I’d like to openly appeal to all members of the WoW family to be kinder to each other,” he said. “Whether you’re a purist or an enthusiast, you’re still a WoW lover. We must be able to have conversations about things that we care about without devolving into insulting each other just because we don’t agree.”

Kotaku senior reporter. Beats: Twitch, streaming, PC gaming. Writing a book about streamers tentatively titled "STREAMERS" to be published by Atria/Simon & Schuster in the future.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


This was inevitable.

No matter how you look at it, the want for a Classic/Vanilla server involves a lot of nostalgia. It’s not just the game that you want; it’s the feeling you had when you were playing the game.

Some people will cling to the dream that their current self, 12 years separated from Classic WoW, will somehow log in and everything will be as amazing and beautiful and new / shiny / whatever as it was Day One when they first logged in and laughingly created their first female Night Elf so they could stare at a pixellated ass.

Others are... more ambitious I think. They seem to realize that their nostalgia-boner is like beer goggles for what WoW was when it first launched and would prefer to make a few remodels before moving back in.

To each of them I laugh.

I laugh at those that cling to pure nostalgia, because they are bound for disappointment. You cannot reclaim your childhood; and while I’m sure you’ll enjoy some of what Classic WoW offers you it’s never going to be what you had hoped, because what you had hoped involved all the context of a where you were in life 12 years past.

I laugh at those who want ‘some’ changes... because all you’re really doing is vying for your own personal idea of what WoW was/is/should be. Congratulations, you’re telling developers how to do their jobs - something that has been par for the course for every WoW subscriber since the dawn of the damned game.