The Battle of the Portal-Singing Lasers is Joined By Two Amazing Versions of "Want You Gone"

Last week I posted Chris DePrisco's fiber laser rendition of Jonathan Coulton's "Still Alive", the ending theme from Portal, with an implied suggestion that Portal 2's "Want You Gone" receive similar treatment. Well it did. Twice. From two completely different types of lasers.

Advertisement


Late last night one David Grossman shared with me a different sort of laser singing. Instead of using the pitch of the laser to replicate sound the way DePrisco did with the fiber laser, Grossman transformed his 250 watt CO2 laser into a working speaker.

David explains: "In essence, the laser is firing at a fixed repetition rate - there's around 30k pulses hitting the material every second. Each of those pulses disrupts the material, and has an associated flash of light and plume of ejected material, which pushes air outwards, making a sound.

"The circuit that's driving the laser pulsing is using the audio signal to vary the energy of each of those pulses.
As such, each plume is ejecting a different amount of material, which is also pushing air differently, causing different sounds."

To put it simply, the music is being played by tiny explosions.

As I prepared to write up Grossman's video, I got another email, this time from the original laser Portal engineer.

Chris DePrisco was dropping me a line to let me know he had followed up on the :Still Alive" video with a two-track fiber laser version of "Want You Gone". Using his single laser he recorded two tracks and spliced them together into one slightly-off but still incredible impressive video.

I couldn't decide which to post, so I posted them both. That I live in a world where such decisions are necessary pleases me to no end.

Portal 2: Want You Gone - Played with Fiber Laser

Portal 2's 'Want You Gone' Played by CO2 Laser [YouTube]

DISCUSSION

Boter
Boter

The one by the guy who did the original one is TONS better. kudos to the other guy for trying but I couldn't even make it out until he turned up the original music. (Still, music with explosions is a neat idea.)

But, DePrisco with his harmonizing lasers? Not only is it the better of these two, but it's SO much better than his one for Portal 1. I dodn't know if it's the harmony or if he's just getting better at it but it sounds a lit better than his Still Alive version.

Maybe I should ask him if he can do one to the Mirror's Edge version of Still Alive where it etches Faith's arm tattoo... *off to YouTube*