Disgraced Magic: The Gathering Star Banned, Removed From Hall Of Fame

Magic: The Gathering pro Yuuya Watanabe, the star at the centre of cheating allegations following the discovery of marked cards in a tournament earlier this month, has been found guilty and heavily punished by officials at the The Magic Pro League.


Despite protestations of innocence from both Watanabe and his sponsors, the MPL today issued a statement that reads (emphasis mine):

The Magic Pro League completed a thorough investigation following Yuuya Watanabe’s disqualification for marked sleeves at Mythic Championship II. As part of this investigation, the sleeves in question were examined multiple times by multiple judges and tournament officials, we reviewed recordings of matches from Mythic Championship II as well as past tournaments, and we considered statements from Watanabe as well as Mythic Championship II judges and tournament officials. The result of that investigation is that, effective immediately, Watanabe is banned from DCI-sanctioned events for a period of 30 months, is removed from the MPL, and is removed from the Magic Hall of Fame.

Information on his replacement in the MPL will be announced early next week.

That’s a stern judgement, especially the more long-term punishment of being removed from the Hall of Fame, but it shows how seriously Magic have taken the whole affair, especially in light of the evidence available to them.

For anyone just joining this, officials at Mythic Championship II in London earlier this month discovered that a small selection of Watanabe’s cards had very specific marks on them, which would help him identify which type of card they were even when they were face-down.

Illustration for article titled Disgraced Magic: The Gathering Star Banned, Removed From Hall Of Fame

The ban comes after his sponsor, Team Cygames, said they “strongly believe Yuuya is innocent of any wrongdoing”, while Watanabe himself claimed at the time “I don’t have any explanations as to what happened to my sleeves, I can honestly say that I never made those marks on my sleeves.”

Watanabe won Magic’s World Championship in 2012, was Player of the Year in 2009 and 2012, has seven Grand Prix victories, was inducted into the Hall of Fame (that he’s now been removed from) in 2016 and won the World Magic Cup in 2017 with Japan.

Luke Plunkett is a Senior Editor based in Canberra, Australia. He has written a book on cosplay, designed a game about airplanes, and also runs cosplay.kotaku.com.



It’s pretty obvious that those were marked by pressure, so I’m quite sure this was unintentional. Maybe his deck box was smashed somehow and those lands were the top or bottom few cards (assuming he hadn’t shuffled yet, since he had just re-sleeved his cards).