Saying āhistory will not be kind to [thing or person]ā is a practice that has always fascinated me. Who are we to judge the futureās thoughts on the topics of today? Thatās the futureās problem. All we can do in the present, as historians or otherwise, is evaluate what has come before us.
Itās impossible for us to say what the futureās history will or will not be kind to, just as it would have been impossible for people 50 or 500 years ago to imagine what inseparable part of the fabric of their daily lives we would find indispensable (or unpalatable) in the 21st century.
I think about this a lot when it comes to video game reviews. A lot of my reviews for Kotaku end up being for big strategy games because thatās my passion, and theyāre games Iāve poured decades of my life into playing. But every time I sit down to review one, Iām plagued with doubts and uncertainties.
Big strategy games are often played (continually, I mean) well beyond the lifespans of many other genres. Fans will clock up thousands of hours on the battlefield or world map, developers will release countless patches and updates and expansions and the experience of playing something like Crusader Kings might change dramatically in the weeks, months and years after release.
What the hell am I writing about, then, when I sit down to review one of these games? How can I hope to definitively give my verdict on an experience if the future has the power to changeāor even undermineāthe way people ultimately end up playing it?
Allow me to confess: I have said some strategy games are great in a review on this website, only to find that over the months and years to followāthrough updates, or changes to systems that only break after hundreds of hours of useāthat I donāt actually like them that much. In my Company of Heroes 2 review, for example, I end by calling the game an āoverwhelming successā. By the time I was writing my Company of Heroes 3 review, I had downgraded my opinion on its predecessor to ādogshitā.
Iām sorry! Itās not my fault. Itās a structural, inherent flaw in reviewing video games at launch, and while strategy games are far from the only genre vulnerable to this (MMO players, I see you), itās the one I specialise in, so itās the one Iām taking responsibility for here. And itās not to say those initial reviews are worthless, far from it. Theyāre useful and correct for the time, itās just that as strategy games evolve and bed themselves in over months and years, those day-one thoughts can become increasingly irrelevant.
Of course while timely reviews can be a problem in this instance, they can also be the solution. In an attempt to atone for my critical sins Iāve spent the last few years re-reviewing some of the biggest, grandest strategy games on the PC, from Crusader Kings to Hearts of Iron, weighing their expansions and updates and shifting mechanics against the games we were able to play at release.
I also wrote one in 2016 for Sid Meierās Civilization V, a game first released in 2010. Which leads us to the subject of todayās re-review: Sid Meierās Civilization VI, a video game released back in 2016 and which has been updatedāthough not necessarily improvedāsince.

I was kind to Civilization VI at launch, with some predictable caveats. I knew from my Civilization V experiencethat these games no longer released whole, and that it would like take an expansion or two for the full grandeur of Firaxisā planned experience to take shape.
Thatās exactly what happened, and when it did I had some more kind words to say. But while Civilization V received two expansions that helped cement its legacy as one of the best strategy games ever made, Civilization VI hasnāt hit quite the same heights.
Let me be blunt: in 2023 I think itās the worst mainline Civilization game. Thatās a deeply relative thing, of course. I also think itās a wonderful strategy game, full of depth and nuance, oozing with character and a modern standard-bearer for the seriesā classic āone more turnā addiction.
But itās also the first Civilization game that I have ever stopped playing. From the original to V, through spin-offs in space and the 16th century, I have always played Civ games for as long as they were the most recent, as long as that ended up being the case.
Yet until revisiting it for this re-review I hadnāt reached for Civilization VI in years. And it wasnāt down to genre fatigue, because I got very excited forHumankind and loved every second I spent with Endless Legend, so my fire for the 4X genre itself is definitely not dying out. Indeed Iāve gone back and played more Civ V in recent years than VI. Itās not me, babe. Itās you.

At first play Civilization VI is just like every other Civilization game. It features charismatic world leaders, you explore a map, you develop technology. You expand the borders of an empire, you exterminate enemies, you let off some nukes, you go into space, it ticks every box on the Civilization checklist. When I say āitās a wonderful strategy gameā, it is, in that I think itās impossible to take this well-established formula and make a bad video game out of it.
Regardless, Civilization VI realised, like V before it, that the series was still in need of some innovation. That it needed to set itself apart from its predecessors, many of whom remain very playable even now, decades after their release. Where Civilization V did this with hexagonal tiles and the abolition of army stacks, which have proven to be a monumental upheaval, Civilization VI tried to get bookish.
Civilization VIās lead designer, Ed Beach, is also a board game designer of note, having released stuff like Here I Stand. Even if you didnāt know that, the board game influence on Civ VI is inescapable. Itās everywhere, from the gameās visuals to its systems, and as someone who also reviews board games for a living, bringing the series full circleāthe original Civ was itself heavily inspired by the classic board game of the same nameāmust have seemed like a no-brainer.
But in practice, as a pivot for a long-running strategy series that was already dangerously close to being perfect, I donāt know if making Civ more board gameyāor at least this particular kind of board gameyāhas proven to be the right decision.
When you break them down, a lot of board games are just elaborate means of working with, and adding up, numbers. Players do things to earn points, sometimes you do a few in a row to score a combo, sometimes you build an āengineā to start building points for you. Most board games will have a winner, and that winner is the person who got the biggest number. Itās naked, and simple, and would be utterly boring in the same way using a calculator for hours on end would be if not for the themes the games are wrapped in and, even more importantly, the fact youāre playing alongside friends in a physical space.
Civilization VI takes a similar approach. It burdens the game with numbers, numbers everywhere, expressed in their rawest and least immersive form, and after seven years those numbers have buried many of the things I enjoy the most about Civilization

The defining aspect of Civilization VI, the thing we will remember it for the most, is its district system. Itās a huge part of the game, based around the idea that after you build a cityāwhich occupies a single one of the worldās tilesāyou can then strategically expand it across the map, placing ādistrictsā based on things like science or entertainment or the military, and these provide adjacency bonuses based on things like their proximity to other districts, or which natural resources they contain. Itās a system that is absolutely essential to getting the most out of your empire, and you canāt play Civilization VI without at least trying to master it.
Itās very much the kind of thing youād expect to see in a board game, one where you would deliberate for ages between turns looking at arrows and icons and tiny numbers, lay a little cardboard token down on a hex then do some counting afterwards. And it sucks! Civilization is not a city-builder, nor is it a puzzle game, but the district system reduces much of your planning timeāusually an imperial glance across a map, or a fun little act of constructionāto agonising over numbers. I just want to build something, man, I donāt want to bethe Math Lady meme every time I need a new harbour.
Thatās just one example, but this board gamey emphasis on combos and sums, on systems layered over ideas layered over systems, is everywhere. There is–and I canāt believe Iām saying this about a strategy game–just too much going on. The World Congress is an absolute chore to click through, reducing what could have been a chance for delicate global communication to a series of simple +/- decisions. The entire civics concept, so great on paper, is another I just click straight through. Same for era scores, and diplomacy, and and gah!
Thereās so much of Civilization VI that I simply donāt care about, that exists as a system for a systemās sake, and the fact you can win games on higher difficulties by completely ignoring almost everything I just mentioned says a lot about how much theyāre really adding to the experience.
Had this been an actual board game the Catan-like experience of putting little districts down on the map would have been amazing, and stuff like its dense visual design, and tactile tasks like making the player build farms and some roads by hand mean this is in many ways the most hands-on Civilization game ever. Yet by reducing so much of our interaction with its world a numbers game itās also the Civilization that makes you feel the most removed from the action.

I donāt want to make it seem like Iām attacking numbers here for numberās sake. Like their tabletop counterpart all video games are just numbers, strategy ones especially, but Civās greatest strength as a seriesāand a big reason for its continued mainstream success that rivals like Paradox simply havenāt been able to matchāhas always been about the way it has dressed them up, hid them behind visual cues like happy and sad faces, little crab icons, the slow expansion of cultural borders across the map, the marching (and demise) of armies and the ever-jarring (and hilarious) contrast between spearmen and tanks existing at the same time. So much of Civās number-crunching has been hidden under this visual layer, creating worlds that felt truly alive and always in motion.
Most of those things are still here in Civ VI, just to be clear, but despite the best leader animations in the series (and maybe in all of video games), and a world that looks like you can reach out and touch it through the screen, the crushing weight of scores and bonuses and figures, thrown at you repeatedly throughout the ages, wears them all down. In Civilization VI I donāt feel like a disembodied leader watching over a world evolving through the ages. The longer Iāve played the game, the more Iāve felt like an accountant staring at a stop-motion video of a stranger building a LEGO set.
Itās a damn shame that Civilization VI could never take all these ideas and systems and tie them together, or at least tie them to the world you were lording over, because individually so many of them were so good! The game tackled climate change in a really interesting way for the genre, and its implementation of religion, while far from perfectāstrategy games can seemingly never separate church from stateāwas at least more interactive than previous attempts.
Civilization VIās happiness system is the best in the series, which can also be read as the one I hate the least. And Iām sorry itās taken this long in the review to get to Giant Death Robots, one of the most wildly overpowered and as a result immensely satisfying military units in 4X history.
I love the way Civilization VIāagain, in contrast to a lot of other its other, less successful ideasāmakes the gameās culture such a tangible force. Watching your borders spread like a virus in earlier games was one thing, but manually controlling archaeologists and artists and rock bands in the field is a blast. Itās these areas, where the game asks you to get down on the ground and shape your Civilization directly, that itās at its strongest. Where the numbersāwhich are always there, in every video game, I knowāfade into the background.
Weāre now seven years into Civilization VIās lifespan. Thatās a record between Civ games, weāve never gone this long without a whole new entry in the series. Iām sure many fans will point to this longevityāand continued support for the game, which has just released a bunch of new and reskinned leadersāas proof of its success.
And like Iāve hopefully got across, it has been a success! This is still a Civilization game, and itās still a very good strategy game. It just also happens to be the weakest entry in that series, the one least equipped to endure this long of a wait between games.
