Another Mar10 Day has come and gone, and with it came several surprisingly big announcements. While Nintendo celebrated the Italian plumber’s holiday by solidifying release dates for the Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door remake and officially announcing a new animated movie, we here at Kotaku celebrated by asking you, the readers, what your favorite Mario games are from the series’ nearly 40-year-long run.
There were a few big games that got multiple shoutouts, with Super Mario Galaxy, 64, and World getting a lot of love. But there were some unorthodox picks that stuck with y’all over the years. Let’s see what the best Mario games are, according to you.