Batman's discussions

@Kotaku Reject: Super Mario Galaxy, Mass Effect 2, not sure, not sure, Tali Read more

@Toshi: New Vegas at most. Read more

@SixTwoSixFour: I'm not that excited or worry about it. It will be of consistently high level quality, like all Bioware games. It will probably follow the same plots, only have a lot more boring greyscape battles. Read more

@Rachel Fogg: I'm actually probably going to ignore the games coming out that year (the only one I was excited for was Dragon Age and now I'm not very excited for it at all) and get a lot of games I missed this year. Read more

@Shami 'Wowie' Sansi: 500-800. Read more

@Nathaniel Lowe: I've had blue poop before, so it's not that original. Read more

@ddhboy: Don't promote a troll. Read more

@n_gamer: Really? The spring level, yoshi's hot peppers as a jet ski, the drill level, the seamless 2D to 3D transitions, the 2D gravity platforming, the flipswitch Galaxy, the fading light platforms, and Whomp's castle were all been there done that? Read more

@BronzeSoldier: Galaxy 2 offered something new in almost every level. You've about reached the end of the game by the time it's stopped experimenting. That's why it's a great game. Read more

@DrkPheonix: Well I don't think Black Ops should have been up there either. Read more

@Møbius: I'm convinced Red Dead will be a PC game. Rockstar has released GTA 3, Vice City, and San Andreas three separate times on PC. PC gamers may not have been that interested in four, but I doubt they can pass it up. Read more

@ScuseMePrincess: Mass Effect 2 is much, much better than the first one. More shootery, better dialog, less Shepard (thank God). It really came into its own as a game. Read more

@Kovitlac: Owen Good probably. He's the most enthusiastic about sports. Read more

@Nerubasasin19: Super Macho Gaiden 2. It's a small game but it has a very dedicated fanbase. Read more

@-MasterDex-: Here are my two points against Starcraft and Minecraft. Read more

So I wrote a long post enthusing about Galaxy 2, but then I decided to rewrite it. It sounds like these games need to push the genre forward to be considered. Starcraft II, for example, has many, many virtues but doesn't seem to push the genre. Here's why I think the list is missing a member: Read more

@UsernameOfTheDead: Bugs? I don't know, never played it. Mass Effect 2 and RDR seemed to get no complaints. Read more

@PossibleCabbage: I heard the PC version was pretty damn broken. Read more

@dsi1: Unfortunately. Twenty minutes ago I had someone complaining that Akali was overpowered in 3v3. Read more

@Paul_Is_Drunk: I don't know if I'd call it a once-in-a-lifetime game. It's a really, really good game, but it still has some glaring flaws. Most Bioware's previous work is on its level. Read more