Disney Infinity: The Kotaku Review

Disney Infinity is a wonderful way for children of all ages to indulge their desire to create and explore, but are all of these colorful pieces of expensive plastic really necessary?

Setting aside the game's creativity-exercising segment for the moment, let's consider the origin of Disney Infinity. The game's roots lie in 2010's Toy Story 3: The Video Game from Avalanche Software.

Disney Infinity: The Kotaku Review

On top of a rather bland collection of movie tie-in levels, Avalanche built an entire separate game they called Toy Box mode. Here there were adventures to be had, scenery to be customized and built, missions to complete and characters to dress. It was an eye-opening way to do a tie-in to a "children's" movie, but it didn't quite scratch the playing with toys vibe as I'd hoped it would.

That same exact experience, right down to the engine and super-deformed non-player characters, is what each of the Disney Infinity Play Sets offer. The three Play Sets available in the Starter Kit — Pirates of the Caribbean, The Incredibles, and Monsters University — could very well have been downloadable modules for that 2010 game. There are variations and additions for each theme, of course — the Pirates Play Set in particular has some amazing naval battles — but it's the same accepting missions, decorating buildings, dressing up NPCs. They've even got the same limitations — the Wii version of Toy Story 3: The Video Game couldn't handle co-op, and neither can this one.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7oIUW...

But this is better, and damn it, it's because of the toys. The same way the Skylanders franchise to date has been so successful despite the actual games being just okay, there's a strengthened connection that comes of having an actual physical representation of your on-screen character in front of you. Being able to pick up Jack Sparrow, look him in the eye and say "Okay mate, you're up." To which he fumbles about charmingly, as he does.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W4X7ue...

That doesn't mean the whole thing isn't an egregious cash grab. The opening moments of Disney Infinity involve a lengthy interactive cutscene that's essentially an advertisement for toys that aren't out yet. As you play the game you're constantly stumbling upon chests that can only be opened by a certain character you may or may not own. They appear all over the place, even in the middle of your deeply-involved Toy Box builds — turn around and suddenly there it is, like some Japanese horror film reject. Don't even get me started on the damn blind-bagged Power Discs (I've spent $20 on them so far).

Oh, and then there's the Hall of Heroes, an entire level dedicated to making children whine at their parents.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q_l3gz...

Back to the Play Sets. Each one is an expansive side-story in its respective property, offering multiple hours of wandering about, completing missions and not-so-much defying death as side-stepping it entirely. It's all very kid-friendly and safe, though the Lone Ranger set might give children the idea that all Native Americans can transform into crows.

Disney Infinity: The Kotaku Review

Strip away the Toy Box abilities and the actual toys and you'd be left with the same sort of mediocre budget movie tie-ins we've been suffering through for year. Just look at that mission-giver in the screenshot above. We've got a high resolution 3D model on the screen, and dialogue is presented by fuzzy 2D picture. That's just sloppy.

It's a sloppiness that runs through all aspects of the game, making it feel as if it was a bit rushed. Choosing to exit or load a level results in several seconds of just sitting there until something happens. There are sound effects missing. The menus are a bit of a mess. Statues in the Hall of Mommy I Want This randomly disappear after they're spawned.

These are all minor annoyances. The only major one I encountered (well, aside from the PlayStation 3 patch error that made the game unplayable for two days at launch) was with the Toy Vault, a mechanic through which players can spend coins gained through adventuring on random items to add to their arsenal of building bits and pieces. There is absolutely no reason for this process to be random, other than to make a grown man cry. Seriously, just watch this.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rQHEU1...

I wanted that Recognizer so badly.

The bits and pieces gained from random spinning and gathered via capsules collected during Play Set exploration become the building blocks of Disney Infinity's greatest feature: Toy Box mode.

Disney Infinity: The Kotaku Review

The Toy Box is where the magic happens. It's where the power of toy-aided imagination is unleashed upon a blank canvas, giving players the ability to create marvelous (and sometimes incredibly stupid) things.

From simply stacking one block on top of another to wiring together triggers and effects to create complicated, Rube Goldberg-esque mechanisms, a player's progression through the Toy Box mode of Disney Infinity imitates the play patterns of children as they grow. They start with blocks. They learn to put them together. Dominoes teach them cause and effect, Erector and LEGO sets show them how to put it all together. These are skills we carry with us the rest of our lives, whether we become architects and engineers or janitors and video game journalists.

Toy Box mode taps directly into the play center of the brain and harnesses its full potential, even if that potential is severely limited.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9O_-UP...

As demonstrated in the early downloadable pre-made levels provided by Disney, there's potential to create works of beautiful complexity in this tool — interactive games, virtual art installations, devious traps for your friends to stumble upon in co-op mode. What's amazing is how simple it is to achieve such complexity. Within a few short tutorials, even the most dense and unskilled creator (hi!) can create linked teleporters, scored mini-games, or spinning dance death machines.

And yes, a major part of that is these stupid plastic toys, giving us something to hold on to. Grounding us in reality as we explore the fantastic reaches of our imaginations, guiding us home when we've stared at the disco ball playing "Sugar Rush" for nearly an hour.

They're actually quite well-sculpted and painted figures. I was provided with a set for review, minus the Cars and Lone Ranger playsets, which I purchased myself, and each figure was relatively flawless — not a speck of paint out of place. That's quite uncommon in toy circles, espcially when they're being produced in such large numbers.

Disney Infinity: The Kotaku Review

And damn if the uniform style they've applied to the design doesn't make impulsively collecting all of them so very easy.

Would Disney Infinity still work without the toys? To an extent, sure. We'd still have an amazing building tool, and a handful of interesting places to explore. We'd have fun, sure, but the moment we turned off our console, it would be gone.

My desk is covered with Disney Infinity toys, the harbingers of digital adventures, the avatars of personal creations both monumental and perpetually in-progress. I can't spend all my time in that colorful electronic world, but the memories are always within reach.