I thought you said "Who Whore It Better".
Having done graphics design in the past, I can really appreciate GamePro's layout.
While Edge's cover may have an edge as far as readability of the magazines contents. I feel that the point is to get the reader attention enough to care to look at the details and GamePro's cover not only shows the title of the game which plays into the games powerful brand in a much more prolific manner, it also makes the content interesting to read by altering the "typical" orientation of text. It's just an excellent presentation.