<![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake? - Kotaku Comments]]> http://cache.gawker.com/assets/base/img/thumbs140x140/kotaku.com.png <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake? - Kotaku Comments]]> http://kotaku.com Mon, 10 Mar 2008 12:14:45 MDT Mon, 10 Mar 2008 12:14:45 MDT http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4621236 Actraiser 2, talk about killing something that didn't even reach its full potential.

maniacmayhem

]]> 9:365347:c4621236 Mon, 10 Mar 2008 12:14:45 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4617187 @Nobuyuki: Suikoden IV definitely.

strideo

]]> 9:365347:c4617187 Mon, 10 Mar 2008 09:14:59 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4616578 World of Warcraft. All my friends would actually have money and want to hang out instead of playing that stupid fucking game all the time.

lol_wut

]]> 9:365347:c4616578 Mon, 10 Mar 2008 08:42:07 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4614603 @Nexus6: Shadowrun FPS?

Seconded! Piece a crap was a disgrace to the IP.

Tarislar

]]> 9:365347:c4614603 Mon, 10 Mar 2008 03:18:39 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4614100 @Aiwokote: Oh I totally agree with you on Xenogears. The first disc had really fun exploration plenty of traveling with the best traveling ship in a J-RPG and then the second disk had absolutely none of that. Its a game I feel really needs a remake, with a lot of the same sensibilities. (2D sprites, Anime Cutscenes. CG Scenes for mechs. It was simply breath taking.

Kounji

]]> 9:365347:c4614100 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 22:56:23 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4613969 Devil May Cry 2 , Wing Commander Arena, Neverwinter Nights 2 ( to make it better) Star Ocean 3 ( that story blew) Tabula Rasa, Planetside, Star Wars Galaxies, Enter The Matrix, and the Matrix Online. and the number one game on my list....

Shadowrun ( for the 360) what a horrible setting for a multiplayer game. It should have been an rpg

Kounji

]]> 9:365347:c4613969 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 22:30:26 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4613382 Enter the Matrix.

You broke my heart you bitch!

EdwinJ85

]]> 9:365347:c4613382 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 20:42:17 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4611926 Well now I don't feel so bad for not reading the thread first, a quick search of the previous 516 post nobody mentioned Oni ;)

DaiMacculate

]]> 9:365347:c4611926 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 15:14:06 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4611914 *DaiMacculate Blatantly refuses to read thread first!*

Oni.

So much potential in the concept, in retrospect I would rather it had died in development hell and spared me the bitter disappointment of the failed execution. I've never tried to like a game that much and still failed. Even though Halo is a pretty good game and its sequels decent, I still don't feel like I used to about Bungie, before Oni was released, even if they didn't control the way it ended up. Like catching your first and (you thought) true love cheating with an ugly person or something ;)

DaiMacculate

]]> 9:365347:c4611914 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 15:11:05 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4610875 @Pornosaur: You may have one of the more interesting nominations I've read yet! If it weren't for Doom 3, wouldn't Paul Steed still be at id? And wouldn't id have made a game that could have actually stood its ground against the bohemoth that is Half-Life 2?

Anyway, yeah, I have to say, I'd unmake ET, and a lot of the games that Atari allowed onto its console, giving videogames such a horribly bad name that people almost stopped buying them.

Close second would have to be the Atari Jaguar. If only they had waited a little longer for technology that was a little more mature. Sure, they had the best Wolfenstein-style game of all time in Aliens Vs. Predator, a fun mech assault game in Iron Soldier, and a phenomenal shooter in Tempest 2000, but they just needed more of the magic that used to make Atari... Atari.

BTW, is anyone else noticing a shortage of 16-bit games on this thread? There are a few out there, but not many.

BtownDesignGuy

]]> 9:365347:c4610875 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 11:31:20 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4610820 @JohnRabbit:
You cant take everything Jack Thompson says to heart.

Old-Noz

]]> 9:365347:c4610820 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 11:15:40 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4610690 Almost all movie licensed games, all mario games unrelated to the mario story, "Starfox adventure" and remake it as it was originaly intended to be "Dinosaur planet" and the Sega Saturn, without the saturn maybe we would have Dreamcast 2.0 today.

mp3

]]> 9:365347:c4610690 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 10:39:36 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4610416 Final Fantasy X but with Jecht's journey.

LVP

]]> 9:365347:c4610416 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 09:14:20 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4610379 Batman: Dark Tomorrow..........and I will completely elaborate...Jesus Christ people.....cant anyone make a descent Batman game.......my God, I havent played a good Batman game in ages....as a matter of fact.......I never played a fairly good Batman title.......anyway.....this is going to be brief, but highly graphic.......and oh yea, speaking of "graphics"....this game has NONE.....underrated, poor quality, N64 graphics, not to mention random ass cutscenes....although they are good quality, they are random, and do not seem to satisfy a gamers craving for an interesting story...The sound is boring, and the gameplay sucks so many pairs of nuts it begins to wonder how big a mouth can stretch......The fighting is atrocious......when you perform a high kick , you suddenly plunge into the air into a Matrix pose, and magically levitate for about 5 seconds and then land.......WOW...highly immersive you bunch of pompous pricks........I'm sorry, but I am honestly glad that I bought this crap on Ebay for $2...because thats about all its worth.....Kemco, you suck for making this piece of elephant turd crap that belongs at the bottom of a sewer, along with any developers who had part in this horrid title. This game needs to be unmade...No holds barred.

acez2087

]]> 9:365347:c4610379 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 09:03:49 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4610192 @Afore Notation: Sorry but Cross had an entirely different fell to it from Trigger not to mention the bastardization of the character of Schala, not to mention the ghosts of Crono, Marle and Lucca.

If you've ever read the source material for Chrono Cross, the text game Radical Dreamers, you'd see how much better it would have been.

The dungeons were boring and uninspiring and collecting all the characters for a single very lame finale was a huge disappointment.

The element allocation system was also badly designed.

There's plenty of reasons why Chrono Cross in retrospect fails Trigger. If they did not try to link the two, even then, the game was a huge yawn fest.

RPGr

]]> 9:365347:c4610192 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 07:06:36 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4610155 I'm actually going to agree with World of Warcraft. Seen it ruin 2 of my friendships. Seen it ruin 1 of those friends careers and almost marriage. Game also went on to show just how terrible people can treat each other and actually be.

Zakuen

]]> 9:365347:c4610155 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 06:19:33 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4610110 @TheIrishNinja: You'll have to get back to me on how this experience goes for you, and who knows, I might come back being one of those who curse FFVII's name to the heavens while lauding FFVI as the Shakespeare of JRPGs--though to be fair, there is a big difference between me and most of the other boys and girls that flip their shit over FFVII; I don't think it is the best game of all time. I think it has many faults, but nonetheless it is the game that made me a gamer and I am hopelessly attatched to the characters, no matter what Square does to them (Dirge of Cerberus), for better or for worse (read: worse.)

Maybe I need to give Trigger another once-over as well, as I can't go long without playing an RPG for I fear I am medically dependant on leveling up and, have no new RPGs to play for a while. I think I'd rather see a remake of Trigger before a remake of VII, especially if they used those beautiful HD sprites developers are whipping out these days. Actually, I even think it would do well in full 3d as long as they made the visuals style over raw graphical power.

Anyways, I just rambled. Damn Daylight savings just slaughtered me.

Captain Internet

]]> 9:365347:c4610110 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 05:26:35 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4610032 @Afore Notation: well, if its worth anything to you, ive decided (from yours and other posts here) to give chrono cross a 2nd go; i feel i mightve been unfair all those years ago for unfairly just wanting trigger again and may've missed out. so yeah, these discussions can do something, anyway.

TheIrishNinja

]]> 9:365347:c4610032 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 03:18:09 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4610028 If I said Donkey Kong...
I think the world would be in a totally diffrent place.


randomshagz

]]> 9:365347:c4610028 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 03:06:40 MDT <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609981 ShenMue in second?

Are you outta your mind? I mean, I'm also a little dissapointed, the story didn't get finished, yet. But it's still one of the best games I've ever played and could catch up with a lot of the games released nowadays…

gr.mon

]]> 9:365347:c4609981 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 01:26:27 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609885 hey ken, GTA3 is one of the greatest games ever. i swear the sperm it took to make you would have been of better use shot across your mothers face.

smoketewmuch

]]> 9:365347:c4609885 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 00:19:29 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609881 Here's one that I bet none of you would think of...

As a teen, I really loved the Spyro franchise. It was quirky, with great level design, compelling platforming gameplay, and fun enemies every which way. All three PSX entries were, in my opinion, outstanding. Most cite Ripto's Rage as the best one, but my personal preference was for Year of the Dragon, because of the interesting sub-characters.

Then the PS2 came around and, lo, there was a new Spyro game, which naturally got me excited. "Oooh, next-gen Spryo!" I was thinking about how cool everything would look and how the levels would be even larger and more detailed...and then I get a chance to rent it, and all I see is this dogshit opening world featuring a crappy camera and bland-as-can-be visuals, as well as a garbage story that I can't remember for the life of me, despite remembering the main plots of the other three games (no Joss Whedon here, but still memorable and entertaining).

So for me, I'd totally unmake Spryo: Enter the Dragonfly. It was pretty much the immediate ending of the franchise's significance to me and everyone else, though I will admit that it's made me remember Insomniac fondly enough that I respect pretty much any offering they've been a part of. Obviously, after Spyro, they moved onto Ratchet and Clank, which is why I owe it to myself to play those games, but I still wish they'd at least left the Spryo legacy in more capable hands.

Superhacker75mil

]]> 9:365347:c4609881 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 00:16:52 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609874 Manhunt 2 the biggest mistake in gaming history. i was excited for weeks waiting for this game. it was easier than the first. and it seemed you only used cool wepons for like 3 stages then it was all guns. im not joking. i beat it then broke the disc in half so nobody else would have to play it.

smoketewmuch

]]> 9:365347:c4609874 Sun, 09 Mar 2008 00:06:26 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609806 Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - Seriously, most recognizable license on the planet, and you make a Dynasty Warriors clone?! It was the first step to ruining a great franchise.

Dead or Alive: Xtreme Beach Volleyball - Just when I thought there was more to it, there wasn't. Then I just felt ripped off and dirty.

...and one to unmake, then make now: Jurassic Park: Trespasser. It was the Crysis of the 90s. Awesome tech, but not for the layman gamer.

boopadoo

]]> 9:365347:c4609806 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 23:37:44 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609804 How about unmaking Splinter Cell: Double Agent. It was basically the same old single player game with a new multiplayer mode that basically stripped away the brilliance of Chaos Theory's spies vs mercs mode. Crestfallen accurately describes my mood towards Double Agent.

Stinkfinger

]]> 9:365347:c4609804 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 23:37:10 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609649 Grand Theft Auto III

Screw Rockstar for what they brought to gaming... Open worlds existed beforehand and would exist afterwards.

Ken

]]> 9:365347:c4609649 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 22:26:06 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609501 @themissinglink_42: I dunno, I think the can hand it out. Just has to be a good company. Like Capcom.

Loved those Oracle games.

2NinjasTapedTogether

]]> 9:365347:c4609501 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 21:30:51 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609372 Oh, here's some more: Mickey Mouse Capade (NES). It's a childhood trauma.

Descent 3. Or maybe Descent 2. First one was great... I remember thinking that it would spawn a great series of games. But then, they made the ship control too complicated, and ruined it.

Doom 3?

Quake 4.

Red Faction 2.

Bokusatsu_Tenshi

]]> 9:365347:c4609372 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 20:58:26 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609348 Wow... so many selfish spoiled comments.
Most of them are about sucessful franchises that made possible gaming being as big as it is today.

As for me... I'll start with DAIKATANA.
Because it simply would be better if remained vaporware.

Most Sonic titles after the first ones... because they are just bad.

Doki Doki Majo Shinpan. Not because it's an "adult game" wannabe on DS, but because it sucks. I'd accept if it was a proper adult game, though. But truth is: It's so bad that it couldn't even generate real polemic around the theme.

I could say Actraiser 2... but I heard some people liked it. So it's not that I would undo it, but certainly unplay it in exchange for a proper Actraiser 2 with the whole gameplay.

X-COM 3 and up. Because the changes they made to it killed the series. X-COM UFO Defense was great, and Terror from the Deep was also nice... both had the same system.

Leisure Suit Larry 6 and up. And whatever game was responsible for killing creative adventure games such as Monkey Island (first 2), Indiana Jones, and some others. Because I loved them. Though I still didn't try the latest Sam & Max games... seems they are looking good.

Guess that's it. Must be more, but I can't quite remember right now...

Bokusatsu_Tenshi

]]> 9:365347:c4609348 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 20:54:34 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609268 Red Steel.

They implemented those new controls so completely wrong.

Then everyone copied those awful controls, scratched their heads in bewilderment at the low sales, and determined from the results that the Wii would never do well with "hardcore" gamers.

Now, using the revolutionary Wiimote and Nunchuck combo almost a year and a half later, there are only two solid controlling FPS's on the Wii, and only one of them is actually a really good game.

What an unbelievable shame.

wonder6oy

]]> 9:365347:c4609268 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 20:36:39 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4609242 FFXI. It should have at least been called FF: Online. Or Waste of Your Life: The Cheesy Storyline Level Grinder Fetch Quest Plagued with Bugs.

Bandito

]]> 9:365347:c4609242 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 20:32:15 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608773 Grand Theft Auto.

Maybe then this whole "video games are the source of evil!" thing would have been a thing of the past.

When people say "violent video games," only a few leftover activists would think of Mortal Kombat and the issue wouldn't go much further.

Ping

]]> 9:365347:c4608773 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 18:49:30 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608691 Halo. Bungie rocked up until M$ bought them out, and their previous masterpieces like the Myth and Marathon games were fantastic.

I still can't believe I stood in line to buy an original XBox for Halo. What a disappointment. That being said, Halo 3 was pretty great, and I think that was really what Bungie was going for when they started work on the first Halo.

unmarkedone

]]> 9:365347:c4608691 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 18:31:38 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608518 What do people have against FF VIII? That was the first RPG that I'd ever played and completed, and I tried playing FF VII afterwards, and found it utterly boring. I didn't really care for FF IX either, but FF X was teh shit!

jspeed04

]]> 9:365347:c4608518 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 17:55:21 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608490 @Witzbold: Damn you sir! I can play that game IN MY MIND complete with stereo sound. Never before or since has a bottle of holy water been so useful when interacting with floor tiles. AND YOU CAN THROW GARLIC! WTFBBQ!

@PowerglovedBelmont: Yes, Shaq-fu is certainly up there.

I think saying the CD-i Zelda games would be too easy and too cheap. I'm gonna go with the original Myst, because despite its powerful effect on the industry (complete with parody games), it had many things I loathe:
1. Overdemanding Windows PC requirements. (10MB swap file?!?)
2. Hotspot hunt-and-click with a lack of actual gameplay. (Oh look, a valve.)
3. Slideshow navigation. (GO EAST. GO EAST DAMMIT! Get ye flask.)
4. Live video cutscenes. (Seriously Atrus, spank your kids and STFU.)
5. MOTSS - More Of The Same Sequels

With the one saving grace of using books as the main theme, which is why I played the Myst series at all, and totally skipped Return to Zork.

Brackynews

]]> 9:365347:c4608490 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 17:49:45 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608478 "Star Wars: Episode 1: Racer" for the Nintendo 64.

Verum

]]> 9:365347:c4608478 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 17:48:18 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608458 Halo 1

zkillz

]]> 9:365347:c4608458 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 17:44:43 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608457 @trigger2:
Are you kidding me? First of all, Ocarina of Time did not have any cutseness. Secondly it was by far the best Zelda Game, and in many people's opinion (myself included) the best video game ever made. Why do you think it's still listed as #1 on top 100 video games lists, includeing IGN's


themissinglink_42

]]> 9:365347:c4608457 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 17:44:31 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608400 The Zelda games for the Phillips CD-I (shudder)

What were you thinking Nintendo!? You can't give Zelda rights to someone else

themissinglink_42

]]> 9:365347:c4608400 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 17:32:07 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608362 Every video game ever in existence should be undone.

Then we can all start taking drugs that make us lose all emotion and some of us can neglect that drug and become sense offenders.

I wanna be a Cleric that fights the good fight.

/Centrum chewables = yummy.

xMaverick

]]> 9:365347:c4608362 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 17:24:30 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608352 @DigiMish: the best shooters "EVAR" made...
Fixed that for you. ;-)

Brackynews

]]> 9:365347:c4608352 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 17:21:32 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608325 Rockman X6 and X7 totally crap!!!!

the american localization for rokman games

Starfox Assault

ZEROmaverick

]]> 9:365347:c4608325 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 17:16:32 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608306 @daschupa:
Bungie was the modest king of FPS companies long before Halo.

The Maginomicon

]]> 9:365347:c4608306 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 17:10:42 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4608133 Breath of Fire 3, because then I'd have 80 wasted hours of my life back.

Fitz Rhapsody

]]> 9:365347:c4608133 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 16:30:57 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607983 If they don't have to be released yet, Fallout 3.

Otherwise, Final Fantasy 7 as it would save me from knowing what the first five pages of any given best-of-anything-to-do-with-rpgs thread are.

FellTheDabus

]]> 9:365347:c4607983 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 16:01:02 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607910 @jspeed04: yeah it sounded like any game in general with a super heros was crap. but the fighters are the only ones i can stand i am 100% with you about the other Super Hero games.

MURDERFACE

]]> 9:365347:c4607910 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 15:44:40 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607898 @SaintWaldo: Guitar Hero 3 yeah i agree but not rockband.

MURDERFACE

]]> 9:365347:c4607898 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 15:42:28 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607823 @MURDERFACE:

Marvel Vs. Capcom, I don't consider to be a Super Hero game, but a fighting game created by Capcom, who are notoriously known for making great fighting games. Guess i should have made my post more clear though huh?

jspeed04

]]> 9:365347:c4607823 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 15:26:24 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607766 Cyberswine, so the trauma is gone. Either that or Half-Life

HikariOblivion

]]> 9:365347:c4607766 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 15:15:28 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607762 Orphen - I wasted $3.00 T_T
and any movie games


goldwings

]]> 9:365347:c4607762 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 15:15:10 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607761 @jspeed04: What about Marvel Vs. Capcom?

MURDERFACE

]]> 9:365347:c4607761 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 15:15:03 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607734 Predator (NES)
Rambo (NES)
ET(Atari 2600)

now for the controversial titles.

Tetris (so that every clone of it would also disappear.)
Sims (so mommies can be mommies again)
World of Warcraft (so people can return to life again)

dadeisvenm

]]> 9:365347:c4607734 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 15:09:38 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607729 That crap named Invisible War (doesn't deserve to have the title Deus Ex).
And there is nothing anyone can say that can make me change my mind.

Tikey

]]> 9:365347:c4607729 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 15:08:04 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607681 How bout Madden. Then maybe we'd have some competition in the market for football games...heck, how bout erasing EA all together?

Saklas

]]> 9:365347:c4607681 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:58:45 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607675 Every Tony Hawk after Tony Hawk 4. They cock teased you by adding a new type of way to link tricks together. Bam Margera totally ruined what was a decent series, and made me realize that skateboarding is not about spray painting and shooting tomatoes out of a cannon, or fucking racking up points by manualing through an entire level, or mediocre controls that got worse every year.

Just about every super hero game maybe with the exception of Xmen Legends, how can you fuck up a genre as simple as a super hero game? From Batman, to Superman, Hulk, Spiderman, and dare I say, about all Xmen Games. I specifically recall an Xmen game on Sega Genesis that only allowed you to have Wolverines claws out for a couple of minutes until they retracted and you had to find a power up to use them again! Fuck despicable. Iron Man's gonna suck too.

All video games that are based off of movies that are hyped up and said to have budgets of tens of millions of dollars, Transformers and Spiderman 3 I'm looking at you. All Mario Party games, Sonic games post Sega bankruptcy.

And the big whammies

Nintendogs, Pokemon, and Army of Two.

Nintedogs is not a videogame, just a way for Nintendo to corner the market that they are currently going after, children.

Pokemon was soooooooo awesome when I was a kid. Then they started just releasing games based off the color of the month, and just abusing their power with sucky, ugly ass pokemon with crappy ass powers, and the more games that they released, they never even changed the formula of the fight, and those games have now spanned 7 count them SEVEN consoles. NOTHING improved over the first one. Anyone who says that I suck or that I'm crazy I just have two words for you, Pokemon Snap. I rest my case

Army of two...Sigh, the bad part is that people actually bought it.

jspeed04

]]> 9:365347:c4607675 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:57:05 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607659 The Wii. I don't care if its not a game, if it was unmade it would affect games the same way a game affects games.

Gam3r

]]> 9:365347:c4607659 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:54:45 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607655 The entire Virtual Boy collection and the system itself too.

MURDERFACE

]]> 9:365347:c4607655 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:53:21 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607631 Unmake Suikoden 4 and the second disc of Xenogears. From there, I'd give them both the true respect they both reserved and actually make a full effort to make it an excellent game.

Aiwokote

]]> 9:365347:c4607631 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:48:53 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607619 @GUNDAM-RX-78-2: I disagree, but I bet I'm the only one who does haha! I loved that combat system so much better than the crappy 3rd one!

amost

]]> 9:365347:c4607619 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:45:44 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607587 @TheIrishNinja: Its okay man, I accepted long ago that I am in the RPG minority. I am actually going to play through FFVI again when I am done with Lost Odyssey, just to really make sure I am not missing anything.

And I'm just not sure about Trigger. I played it before Cross came out, and I thought it was pretty good. But Cross is just so beautiful even today, with such an amazing soundtrack. I also love the characters, though some I could do without (the rockstar guy) and felt like the story was ridiculously compelling, especially when they whip out the deep info on Lavos right before the last boss fight.

I really don't know why we all feel the need to defend games; I know it isn't going to change any minds or anything, I guess I just feel like I owe at least this much to some of these games.

Captain Internet

]]> 9:365347:c4607587 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:37:57 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607561 Originally, I was gonna say Shadow Hearts: From the New World, so that it could be unmade and leave open the space for a good third SH game.

But in reading the comments here, I know that my answer is undoubtedly Kingdom Hearts. Kingdom Hearts represents the success of style over substance to the extreme, not only design-wise, but in the genericness of its plot that causes me to weep softly in the night (let's listen for the words "light," "darkness," and/or "heart" every other sentence during plot points!). KH and Advent Children gave me a clear impression of Tetsuya Nomura's design policy: he makes flat character personalities, and in the case of pre-existing characters, flattens them. It's like a monitor displaying 256 colors that gets shunted down to 16 colors. The KH2 seemed like it'd be more of the same, so I didn't bother buying it.

The success of the first, though, opened the door for incredibly vapid game stories to lay claim to massive popularity via stylish looks, high production values, and blatant fan-pandering, and if I could un-make KH, and in doing so send the associated creators down better paths, I would do it a hundred times over.

tenken

]]> 9:365347:c4607561 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:31:03 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607491 I definitely agree that POP: WARRIOR WITHIN should be unmade. Goddamit they might as well call it GTA: Persia

The 3d Mortal Kombats, FF7, SRPGS, Shadow the F"n Hedgehog!

C&C3, NBA Lives 2006-2008. God of War: Chains of Olympus (unmake and remake since its too short for a goddamn good game)

KaliKOtt

]]> 9:365347:c4607491 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:10:42 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607489 I would like to see the Pimp my ride series unmade....plus any sports related games should get the boot too. Leave sports outside...where they belong.

Teh1337Pirate

]]> 9:365347:c4607489 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:09:50 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607478 @blizzardjesus: oddest complaint evar.

@Afore Notation: i like your points, but saying FF VI is beaten out by the mess that was FF VIII makes my head hurt.
and Chrono Cross was better than Trigger for you? really?

TheIrishNinja

]]> 9:365347:c4607478 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:07:53 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607456 FF VII

Why does it have 3 different graphical styles. Its like a game version of schizophrenia. FMV cut scenes, World Map and Battle Models of all the characters are completely different. Pick one and stick with it.

blizzardjesus

]]> 9:365347:c4607456 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 14:02:54 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607423 Wario Ware, so we could have Wario Land 5.

Kawaii-e

]]> 9:365347:c4607423 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:55:30 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607421 @zingbot:You must stay away from Mass Effect then, friend. As beautiful of a game as it is, and as much as it hurts me to give this advice, I think you'd bite your own tongue off just to escape it.
@endercatbus: Just to play devil's advocate, coming from someone who has played all the Final Fantasy titles with the exception to 1-3, I think 7,8,10, and 12 are better in every way than 4,5,6, and 9. And I have played a LOT of RPGs. I'm talking a lot. Well, I take that back; 6 had great characters (terrible antagonist though) and 4 had a great turning point for the main character.
@creid: You are right. They could have managed to spread that very last bit of awesome story out a bit more, so more people who understand it, thus, understand that is surpasses it on every level save for stubborn nostalgia.
@RPGr: See the above.
@shikaningen: You are certainly entitled to your opinion, and those are the things I always hear from people who don't like XII, but the enviroments? Really? I actually stopped just to look at them quite a few times throughout the game; there was so much detail and the whole world had such a coherent look.

Captain Internet

]]> 9:365347:c4607421 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:54:56 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607365 @Wolfers: To be fair, wasn't that Kingdom Hearts 1? I mean, in 1 you recreated them to the T, and in 2 they actually came up with some original content.

Captain Internet

]]> 9:365347:c4607365 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:41:26 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607364 @Nikuma: godbless you, friend.

@cnas: eh, wasnt part 3 & veronica going in that direction anyway, though?

@Witzbold: ...Simon's Quest? color me surprised, i loved that one.

@King Seafoam: aw, dont say that, i was just looking at buying that one offa half.com cause i need more ZAMN in my life. no good?

@Repsode: good point, however sad.

@justhesh: stop it stop it

@Shimmergeek: but hey, it had Deapool!

@nmlss: every FF except crystal chronicles? i think you got that backwards.

@shikaningen: which i knew which FF's past VI (in your book) had solid characterization, then.

i wish to unfriend any of you unkined to MGS or shenmue! but, you know, there's a lot of fair calls on here. i just think its funny to think that taking out CS or halo or something somehow equates FPS not dominating as a genre eventually.

oh, and mine for today is Aztec Adventure for sega master system. Just horrible, and repeats the bosses too much.

TheIrishNinja

]]> 9:365347:c4607364 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:41:15 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607349 God of War, that game sucked. I cant believe it was considered the best game on ps2. So many better games then that.

babyfood

]]> 9:365347:c4607349 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:37:37 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607345 @SpartanQ77: I hate everything that you choose to be.

2NinjasTapedTogether

]]> 9:365347:c4607345 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:36:45 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607336 Unmake shenmue? What the hell? Shenmue is a great franchise, it should have spawned a genre. It had it's flaws, but they were hardly that bad.

Feba

]]> 9:365347:c4607336 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:35:03 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607335 World of Warcraft. Without it Blizzard woud have a perfect record. Glad to see they aren't ruining Starcraft by making it an MMO.

slikz21

]]> 9:365347:c4607335 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:35:01 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607323 @Vanst: I think DDR is an ok game. it was one of the first rhythm games that without it GH may not have been made. I personally don't like DDR's marketing idea because the equation is simple:
basic concept + new music - skill + new boss song = new game
I'd only hate it primarily for wiping out ITG because it was DDR that worked with a completely different skill level and introduced new elements to the DDR community. And because ITG was community driven the quality of music + skill levels were aimed at the people who played DDR.
DDR also was something that probably contributed to the wiiFit.

MadModderX

]]> 9:365347:c4607323 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:33:29 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607310 Kingdom Hearts 2. Recreate key scenes in disney movies then add a bunch of generic enemies to mash buttons at. Biggest letdown ever.

Wolfers

]]> 9:365347:c4607310 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:31:09 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607280 Metal Gear Solid.

Gray665

]]> 9:365347:c4607280 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:24:53 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607260 @Ndogg550: You know what I hate more than life itself? People who casually state that most Wii owners consider it a let down, when said statement is blatantly untrue. Sure, SOME Wii owners consider it a let down, and those same Wii owners are those who expected it to be something it was never going to be. Some PS3 owners consider it a let down I'm sure, as would some 360 owners. Doesn't mean any of them are. Personally, I think all three consoles are fantastic for their own markets.

awkward91

]]> 9:365347:c4607260 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:20:17 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607203 Yaris.

elsilento

]]> 9:365347:c4607203 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:09:59 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607181 Super Mario Galaxy. Beforehand, the Mario platformers were serious games that I could always enjoy, but at the same time the game was always better than me and kept me coming back to those levels I just couldn't beat time and time again. Now, it's a laughably easy and ridiculously shallow experience that offers throwaway fun for a fortnight and remains untouched thereafter. I will never be able to look at the Mario games as completely consistent again, and I will never be able to completely trust the games media for showering it with praise despite its glaring shortcomings in many departments.

awkward91

]]> 9:365347:c4607181 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:06:16 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607165 Two Worlds, Madden, Lair, and Two Worlds.

SoulPunch

]]> 9:365347:c4607165 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 13:03:16 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607033 Dragon Ball Z: Budokai Tenkaichi (1, 2 and 3 the gameplay sucks, thank God the new one will feature the ol' budokai engine Tenkaichi sucked big time)

Inuyasha: Feudal Combat and Inuyasha: The Secret of the Cursed Mask, both an insult to a great anime, specially the last one.

The special edition (defangued) of Devil May Cry 3, the original was better and much more harder

Aquatopia, not a game by the way, but the worse 2 bucks ever spent

Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door (after 30 minutes it was ready for the trash can, hated the rpg element they added)

Super Monkey Ball: Banana Blitz (need to say more?)

Kane and Lynch (the concept was good, but terribly translated in to code)

Madden for the PS3

ajiezer

]]> 9:365347:c4607033 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 12:37:45 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607007 Unreal Tournament

BigMoose

]]> 9:365347:c4607007 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 12:32:32 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4607001 there are somethings I think shouldn't even exist - like say crazy frog racer, or some of the imagine series and the awful 'I did it, mum' ones(sure you could say it's for below 5 year olds but I know many who didn't enjoy). Maybe tasteless movie tie ins as well hmm the earliest i can think is the terminator one for the megadrive[not sure if it was for the first one or the second].

Comments 'rnt Us (usually)

]]> 9:365347:c4607001 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 12:30:56 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606799 Guitar Hero and Rock Band.

Kotaku - The Happy Clique for Hypocrites!

]]> 9:365347:c4606799 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:56:21 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606781 Hmm... probably E.T., Sonic the Hedgehog '06, Bomberman: Act Zero, CD-i Nintendo games, things of that nature.

GuardianEarth

]]> 9:365347:c4606781 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:54:19 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606759 FINAL FANTASY XI!!! It was fun until level 10, where they practically forced you to go with a group...

Amazon_Chris

]]> 9:365347:c4606759 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:51:25 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606757 Area 51 and San Francisco Rush. The arcade industry has done nothing but copy Atari for the 10 years since their death, and mainly the last two franchises they made. We want new trackball games!

supercrap

]]> 9:365347:c4606757 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:51:16 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606737 Sonic the Hedgehog for the X-Box 360/PS3 hands down.

Homard

]]> 9:365347:c4606737 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:48:15 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606650 Sonic the Hedgehog the "remake". Never played it, except the demo, but from what I've heard about it's storyline, it's simply unplayable gameplay wise and unplayable from the standpoint of a hardcore sonic fan, who bought every game, then stopped when he decided to never bother with Sonic Riders, a racing game where fast running characters have to ride hoverboards in a future world of some sort.

Shadow the Hedgehog comes in a very close second.

Third goes to an expansion pack, Ultima Online: Renaissance. Contrary to it's name, it KILLED a classic, rather than revived it. Not that it had died before then, UO just ended up being the first game of many MMORPGs to expire their welcome after about 2 years...

Codexx

]]> 9:365347:c4606650 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:32:02 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606616 Imagine: Anything or Horsez and company...

MelodyKitn

]]> 9:365347:c4606616 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:25:56 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606608 OK, i know i will be speared for this but...
Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of time.

It so UnZelda-ed me with all the surreal cutesness. Then the rest of the games just kept it up. Sigh.

trigger2

]]> 9:365347:c4606608 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:25:16 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606595 Mortal Kombat: Mythologies. I'd rather be anally assaulted by a randy mule than play that hunk of shit again.

Revolution0620

]]> 9:365347:c4606595 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:23:20 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606575 Has to be Shadowrun. In recent memory I have never been more disappointed by how a game turned out. I don't even know why they bothered to use the IP. Could've called it something else and saved some money.

negativexer0

]]> 9:365347:c4606575 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:20:11 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606571 I would unmake WoW because it has pretty much destroyed the MMO market.

Now you're either WoW or you're 'failing'.

Its a mess which is going to severely limit the number and variety of new MMOs coming out for years.

brent_w

]]> 9:365347:c4606571 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:19:37 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606502 Kingdom Hearts II

I absolutely loved the first Kingdom Hearts. As a game, Kingdom Hearts 2 surpassed it. As an experience, it was...pretty bad. It utterly raped my favorite Disney movies in the eyesocket. Not to mention the lack of exploration (and this is coming from someone who loves linear games) in areas.

If KH got a 9 from me, KHII would get an 8. So I guess you could say I wouldn't so much Unmake it, as remake it.

physical

]]> 9:365347:c4606502 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:06:38 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606478 Superman 64

Neo-Senku

]]> 9:365347:c4606478 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:03:07 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606471 Halo 3 (Not a fanboy) Probably the most overhyped/rated games ever. Below average, Infact also Halo 2, I did like 1 though.

MenoJazz

]]> 9:365347:c4606471 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 11:02:07 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606441 @etho: I choose to unmake the concept that I just had for a masturbation Wii game. Oh god. You and your "dick-waggling" giving me awful thoughts!

baked ham

]]> 9:365347:c4606441 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:55:56 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606438 @knikola: Silly person. That game doesn't exist.

sadisticfreak432

]]> 9:365347:c4606438 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:54:59 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606432 Halo, with out a doubt and i subscribe what ErskinPig said about it. You hit the nail right on the head there.

The fact that many ppl think Halo is the best Fps ever made, is ruining the genre and leading it to a place that is dark and ugly.

Oh, and Final Fantasy Tactics, purely because its the best FF ever made and the best turn base ever to exist, leading to the inevitable comparison to it for the rest of time and the thought that nothing will ever beat it.

Krumm

]]> 9:365347:c4606432 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:53:55 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606413 Myst should be un-made. At the time it sucked people in with great graphics (static screenshots however) and with the new CD games format. Everyone bought it and 10 years later when neophytes got their first computer they still continued to buy it thinking it was the best game out there because it had the only title they recognized. Unfortunately the game and it's evil offspring all sucked.

Fergie24

]]> 9:365347:c4606413 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:50:35 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606408 I'd have unmade all the Virtual Boy games... (we miss you Gumpei). Also, the Power Glove game. And of course, NINJA BREADMAN!

onomeister

]]> 9:365347:c4606408 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:49:55 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606403 everquest.

sloan

]]> 9:365347:c4606403 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:49:34 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606396 Those are all very good but think big... Lets start videogames from the scratch... A new begining!

I would unmake... PONG.

I feel like god!

P.S. best thread ever

droideka

]]> 9:365347:c4606396 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:48:22 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606337 1. Doom
2. Quake
3. Unreal Tournament

I select those because I feel they led directly to the FPS genre becoming the testosterone-soaked juvenile dick-waggling competition that it is today. They took a genre with tremendous storytelling potential, and turned it into something where storytelling is an afterthought. FPS's with good stories are few and far between, and I hate that.

etho

]]> 9:365347:c4606337 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:39:37 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606332 @knikola: I've never seen any evidence that Duke Nukem Forever was ever made. Sure, the concept exists, and some video, but I see no evidence of a game there.

baked ham

]]> 9:365347:c4606332 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:37:55 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606304 Mario Party 2. And every EA sports game after '94.

Danarcho

]]> 9:365347:c4606304 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:33:58 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606274 Final Fantasy

gamadaya

]]> 9:365347:c4606274 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:29:46 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606270 This is the easiest question ever.

I would unmake WoW.

Kamakazie

]]> 9:365347:c4606270 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:28:21 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606227 Harry potter and the goblet of fire.

LordChris915

]]> 9:365347:c4606227 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:21:58 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606210 DUKE NUKEM FOREVER

knikola

]]> 9:365347:c4606210 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:19:20 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606196 Shadow the Hedgehog and Sonic the Hedgehog (360). Nuff said.

blackadvent

]]> 9:365347:c4606196 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:17:43 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606184 Star Wars Galaxy.

Tear

]]> 9:365347:c4606184 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:16:32 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606121 Halo actually! Of course! Duh, I feel silly for not immediately thinking of it. Not a bad game, but not a good game either and CERTAINLY not a great game. It played on the ignorance of console owners who had never previously been exposed to FPS and consequently gained an undeserved reputation as some sort of messianic product. The only moderately cool thing about it was the vehicles and co-op, but it remains lacklustre regardless. A triumph for marketing, a defeat for common sense.

ErskinPig

]]> 9:365347:c4606121 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:06:45 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606090 Medal of Honor: Pacific Assault

Worst $50 I ever spent

FLYBOY611

]]> 9:365347:c4606090 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 10:01:50 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606078 @ Jim Reilly Breath of Fire 5 was awesome, and this is coming from a Breath of Fire fanboy.

Personally, I choose all the BS Final Fantasy sequels that have been coming out for 7. and 10.

NukaCola

]]> 9:365347:c4606078 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:57:52 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606066 Bomermand Land Touch. Shit. Crap. 20 minutes of cutscenes to start a game that fucking blew.

Kingdom Hearts series is a close second.

I hate, hate, hate heavy dialogue.

zingbot

]]> 9:365347:c4606066 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:54:58 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606051 Me? I'd have to unmake any of the three Legend of Zelda CD-i games. I'd unmake all three if I could. Oh, the absolute horrors and atrocities they did to poor Link!!

potatojones

]]> 9:365347:c4606051 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:53:42 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606044 What game would I un-make?

Hrm...

Oh! I know!

Final Fantasy Spirits Within.

It's not a game!? That's stupid. It looks like one. :o

Losbullitt

]]> 9:365347:c4606044 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:52:22 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606021 @PaulHunter: I just hope that Blizzard doesn't decide one day to turn Starcraft into an MMO.

It'd be the end of South Korea as we know it they did.

XenonXylophone

]]> 9:365347:c4606021 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:48:01 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4606008 From my own experience most movie based games were all pretty crappy. So I'd have to nominate that all movie based games be "unmade." Have you ever tried Blade 1/2 on PS2(see it was so crappy I forgot which part it was)? I rest my case.
Love Hina Gallery

LilBigMac

]]> 9:365347:c4606008 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:44:39 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605997 Halo 2...

iStoner

]]> 9:365347:c4605997 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:43:59 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605982 As far as killing a franchise i loved from the start goes, I'd have to say C&C Generals. C&C 3 bought me back to the fold, but the franchise is still tarnished with Generals.

ManiacFive

]]> 9:365347:c4605982 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:40:52 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605977 If this question could be unmade I'd settle for that.

As time goes on gamers increasingly feel as though their input and their taste should be involved with the creative process of making a video game, making it less a product of the minds of developers and more a service they coldly provide to our every whim. Now, certainly there are alot of games that I don't like, and I don't buy them of course, but personally I think saying as though a game should never have been made is disrespectful to the developers and undermines their creativity. We shouldn't be telling them what a good game is, they should be telling us, with something we've never seen before.

StarStabbedMoon

]]> 9:365347:c4605977 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:39:39 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605951 1 word.....HALO

Nikral

]]> 9:365347:c4605951 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:32:27 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605924 @shikaningen: Someone needs a hug.

Sparky13

]]> 9:365347:c4605924 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:27:53 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605912 I'm going to go with Halo, both for what it brought about and for its own sake.

Pantsman

]]> 9:365347:c4605912 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:25:28 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605908 And Kasumi Ninja. Sorry for the double post but I'm having really bad memories of my Atari Jaguar...

So many lawns mowed for that thing...

Sparky13

]]> 9:365347:c4605908 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:25:09 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605903 Can I unmake the SEGA 32X? Let's just pretend I did for a minute. Okay, there, much better.

Oh, and Trevor McFur and the Crescent Galaxy. All kinds of bad going on with that one.

Sparky13

]]> 9:365347:c4605903 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:23:47 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605900 Hmm, probably Brain Age. I think all "casual gaming" can be traced back to this title.

kylenalepa

]]> 9:365347:c4605900 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:23:23 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605867 Final Fantasy XII and Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess and perhaps Wind Waker.

Those were TERRIBLE games. They didn't have even a shred or modicum of the 'magic' - if you'll permit me to use such an platitudinous and saccharine phrase - that their forerunners had had. They were terrible disappointments.

If you care to hear the reasons why I think so:

FFXII had a highly compressed and attenuated story. There was just so little there; almost no character development. The environments were so bland that I was almost certain at times that they had been completely computer generated. The "political elements" that so many say the game had were scattered about, it seemed, to pet egos and make people feel satisfied with themselves - to make them feel adult and mature. Political intrigue and the like do not a good game make (not necessarily). And the fact of having participation or interest in or understanding of politics, despite what you may think, does not mean that you are mature, intelligent, adult, or any of those things; just look at politicians.

LOZ:TP was likewise stripped down to a bare-bones forumla only vaguely reminiscent of that of preceding games which was instituted, I can only guess, to pander to the vulgar and unsophisticated interests of the great unwashed, or more precisely to their incompetence and desire for an easy game. So many classic staples of the series were ablated. The overworld, while expansive, was utterly tedious and uniteresting: there was nothing to do, really. Everything just came off as half-assed, boring, bland, non-descript, etc...

shikaningen

]]> 9:365347:c4605867 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:16:52 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605848 Fallout 3, like the last...two guys said.

Rohit_N

]]> 9:365347:c4605848 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:13:38 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605847 Halo series

Thoas

]]> 9:365347:c4605847 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:13:31 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605829 I'm kind of dissapointed with most of the games mentioned. I guess that most of your aren't really hardcore gamers. The games that should be un-made are games like WOW, and Dynasty Warriors, your Need for Speeds, yes, even Rainbow Six Vegas 2 because 3 is already being made I bet, its these generic entries that the same people posting here keep buying, those are the ones that are destroying video games...just look at the Wii...(shivers)...you can un-make the game before it ever happens, don't buy a bad product over and over.

wezlypipz

]]> 9:365347:c4605829 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:10:10 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605816 GTA III. I can't think of any other game that has made cast such a bad light on our industry. It helped give gamers a bad name. On top of that, it helped push out game-after-game-after-friggin'-game of shovelware me-too "free-roaming city crime" games. Seriously, if I have to hear the word "Sandbox game" one more time I'm gonna be sick.

Nate128

]]> 9:365347:c4605816 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:07:48 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605812 @Machete_Bear: i dunno machete, it was alright... it was good mindless jumping around and killing. i think if you saw it for more than that you would be disappointed... then again i paid 4 dollars for it..

dropoff

]]> 9:365347:c4605812 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:06:30 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605805 98% percent of movie based games.
Pokemon and all its knock offs and bastardized versions that followed.
The ATROCITY that was Deus Ex 2.
Any Sega CD game that had FMV.

How many Samurai/Dynasty Warrior games are out there?

dropoff

]]> 9:365347:c4605805 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:04:37 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605802 Seaman. Oh, man, that fucking game was TERRIBLE. Here's the concept: You have this little fish-guy who's a fucking prick, and doesn't like you, and doesn't listen to anything you say into the microphone, doesn't answer questions, and is generally pointless. Brilliant!

Strangelove

]]> 9:365347:c4605802 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:04:09 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605792 @Zero_: hmm, because fights with telepathic bosses that read your memory card and make you put your controller down so it can rumble across the table, undead robotic ninjas, and clone brothers battling over a giant nuclear robot isn't "fucked and sci-fi"?

i don't know if i'd necessarily unmake it, but ffx was one of the worst games i've played. most everything that people complain about the final fantasy series came to a head in ffx, leading everyone to look at the past games in a different light (mostly, people displacing the features of ffx onto ffvii)

adaorardor

]]> 9:365347:c4605792 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:02:00 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605791 Crackdown, without a doubt. Then I would have my $8 rental fee back, and hundreds of people would have had to wait to play Halo 3 online just like me. Plus the game was pure shit.

Machete_Bear

]]> 9:365347:c4605791 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 09:01:59 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605782 Christ, this is harder than I thought. I guess all the really terrible games I must have played have been filed away in some part of my brain waiting to be discovered years later during some sort of breakdown.

Erm...whichever game kick-started the WII FPS spree. That & all the WWII shooters that followed it.

ErskinPig

]]> 9:365347:c4605782 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:59:38 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605767 One game to obliterate from the world, GTA III is a prime choice, as it is a mediocre game which has done nothing but spawn equally mediocre direct sequels and caused trouble for the gaming industry. GTA IV looks awesome, but I will take the hit of it not existing if it means I will never hear Jack Thompson whining about GTA.

Anything Tomb Raider made past 1998. Attention license holder, WE NEITHER CARE OR TRUST YOU ANYMORE!

Manhunt, for the exact same reasons as GTA III, excepte replace "mediocre" with "terrible".

Finally, Star Wars V for the gameboy, as I think everyone wants to take revenge on one game that gave them trouble as a child.

dragonsword

]]> 9:365347:c4605767 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:55:26 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605766 Eternal Sonata...god that was awful. Had potential though...

Goodthymes

]]> 9:365347:c4605766 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:55:11 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605758 Dungeon keeper 2.
Really didn't compare to the first.


JamieA

]]> 9:365347:c4605758 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:53:05 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605751 I'd like to see every Harvest Moon game after 64 unmade. HM64 was truly one of the best games I had ever played. Too bad every single other HM after it sucked huge balls. Save the Homeland, the GCN one, the DS one. All of them were terrible when compared with the greatness of the 64 version.

Rune Factory was a step in the right direction, but once again the devs still undervalue the amount of fun to be had in interacting with the town, having holidays, and progressing through the drama of a small rural town as opposed to planting veggies.

JAcK0R

]]> 9:365347:c4605751 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:51:16 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605721 @Huxle: Umm, all the halo games are hyped up and ended up being average.

Ndogg550

]]> 9:365347:c4605721 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:43:03 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605716 The Nintendo Wii.

There has never been so much smoke and mirrors hyping up a console to #1 even though most of its owners would agree it is a HUGE letdown.

signed,
a let-down Wii owner who adores his expansive 360 library.

Ndogg550

]]> 9:365347:c4605716 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:41:35 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605714 @WillyFourEyes: every Double Dragon game after the third one

the third was really bad, I'd unmake that first. Super Double Dragon and Double Dragon Advance (the latter released a few years ago) are both great entries that came after the 3rd. Get your stuff straight or get out there and rediscover these gems.

roker

]]> 9:365347:c4605714 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:41:14 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605707 Hmm. Thought I'd take a look at this list after another 100 + comments arrived. I now realize three things:

1. Gamers have varying opinions on what sucks and what is good

2. A large amount of you despise Tetsuya Nomura

3. Deathtrap Dungeon still freakin' sucks.

Well, at least Kotaku is varied. Makes for good discussion. ^_^

Saint Anima

]]> 9:365347:c4605707 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:38:34 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605706 Lost Planet. Too simple, too weak...

goliathvv

]]> 9:365347:c4605706 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:38:09 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605700 Pac Man for the 2600. The programmer, Tod Frye, wanted to use 8k of memory for the game which would have solved a lot of problems but Atari insisted that he use a 2k cartridge. And Pac Man on a 2k cart = major suckage.

Gamebrain87

]]> 9:365347:c4605700 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:37:06 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605696 Remake Halo to make it crap so Microsoft would not be the force it is today!

More seriously, remake Outrun on the 8-bit computers as that game was such a crushing disappointment for all Speccy, C64 & CPC owners.

Remake Pro Evo & Orange Box on PS3 & the Atari classics range on XBLA.

DreamcastRIP

]]> 9:365347:c4605696 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:36:34 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605689 @Truepatriot: "all movie based games,and fable.fable pushed me over the edge to buy an xbox 180(get it?!?)"

ha ha

I get it! You should be a SIT down (get it?) comedian.

I'd go with Saints Row or all the GTAs made for the PSP

Really, the series hasn't been good since Vice City, hopefully they get it right with GTA IV

roker

]]> 9:365347:c4605689 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:35:23 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605652 I'm discovering a lot of things about Kotaku commentors here, today. And I don't like what I'm seeing. Oh well.

baked ham

]]> 9:365347:c4605652 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:24:40 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605628 Thats easy, Oblivion, perhaps with that overrated PoS gone, standards might be higher.

I am tempted to say Fallout PoS, though.

deuxhero

]]> 9:365347:c4605628 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:17:15 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605624 "Totally Rad" for NES anyone? "Back to the Future" for NES. Oh yeah, the number 1 crappiest game of all time to be released for the Xbox : "Bruce Lee: Quest of the Dragon." I was on ship when i bought that game and was counting on it to be a great way to kill time... well it sucked so fucking bad it left a bad taste in my mouth.

wtf007

]]> 9:365347:c4605624 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:16:07 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605602 Myst. It helped kill the adventure game genre.

Atomicvege

]]> 9:365347:c4605602 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:10:37 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605593 @Dang-fuzz: You sould like one ignorant mother fucker. ;]

Old-school Sonic fanboy

]]> 9:365347:c4605593 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:04:25 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605588 Sonic '06 for sure. x_x

Old-school Sonic fanboy

]]> 9:365347:c4605588 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 08:03:17 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605565 "Me, I'm going for Prince of Persia: Warrior Within"

Yes! That's the first thing that popped into my head. It turned Sands of Time from a fantastic trilogy to two games with a piece of crap sandwiched between them. It's the reason I'm kind of hesitant to replay the Sands of Time trilogy. I'm crazy and I'd force myself through the second game before playing the third. xP

Roto13

]]> 9:365347:c4605565 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:55:26 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605564 I would unmake Robocop for the NES. This desire is strictly based on the disappointment I felt when I dropped 50.00 bucks on it for my 13th birthday. I found myself laughing at the craptacular animations and rough and inconsistent game play.

Come to think of it, I think unmaking Data East's ability to make NES games would be a better option.

M15ant470p3

]]> 9:365347:c4605564 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:55:13 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605558 Deadrising on 360...I tried to like it but had enough zombie smashing in Resident Evil (except the part where you get to run over them with a lawnmower outside the mall).

jmsalal

]]> 9:365347:c4605558 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:54:10 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605551 NIGHTS JOURNEY OF DREAMS

HarmanSmith

]]> 9:365347:c4605551 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:52:14 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605548 Dues Ex 2.

Single handedly ruined the cyberpunk genre in gaming after one of the greatest games of all time.

huginn

]]> 9:365347:c4605548 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:51:28 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605545 Honestly, Halo 3. I was so hyped for it, and then it turned out to be average. I'd remake it to be somewhat close to how MS portrayed it to be

Huxle

]]> 9:365347:c4605545 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:50:48 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605544 @GUNDAM-RX-78-2: I agree, the weakest in the trilogy (or quadrilogy if you consider Xenogears part of the series). What really made me yank my hair out was the mandatory, pointless bullshit sidequests you all but had to complete in order to progress with the boss fights. Battle system I could forgive (and actually liked for innovation), but the game seemed really unpolished. Boy are you in for a treat with Episode III, though. If you want the bulk of the story, there are places to find the cutscenes from ep.2 online if you look hard enough.

jmsalal

]]> 9:365347:c4605544 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:49:51 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605536 @Truepatriot: I know what you mean about Fable. Peter Molyneaux (I probably spelled his name wrong) gets me every time with his damn hype. Both Black & White and Fable failed to deliver on the awesomeness promised. With that said, I will check out Fable 2 because I can't help my love of rpgs.

shintobreak

]]> 9:365347:c4605536 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:47:08 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605533 Without any doubts, Devil May Cry 2, how can someone make such a weak sequel to one of the best games ever made!

zetopazio

]]> 9:365347:c4605533 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:46:54 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605519 Marvel Ultimate Alliance for the Wii. That game shows us everything that is wrong with the Wii.

Dragonis

]]> 9:365347:c4605519 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:42:35 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605504 Hey all you going after the Sonic series, just pick one, I'm sure you can figure out which one really needs to go.

ila

]]> 9:365347:c4605504 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:35:34 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605503 Kingdom Hearts II.

Americo

]]> 9:365347:c4605503 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:35:24 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605501 Gran Turismo (all of them)...there...I said it.

DCSimian

]]> 9:365347:c4605501 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:34:47 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605497 I'd definitely unmake The Legend of Zelda: The Phantom Hourglass. Then I'd remake it. A non-existent story line (after The Wind Waker's wonderful one) bland dungeon design, that terrible Temple of the Ocean King. Ugh. Hopefully not a sign of things to come.

Smash_Bro

]]> 9:365347:c4605497 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:32:44 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605484 Mass Effect. But don't unmake the elevator rides.

DaveB

]]> 9:365347:c4605484 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:29:06 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605482 master chu and the drunkard hu for nes

oldirtdog

]]> 9:365347:c4605482 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:27:52 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605475 @NeoAkira: Actually I played Kingdom Hearts. for two hours and was forced to watch it for three more, and felt the exact opposite. Everything about Kingdom Hearts was purely derivative, the combat was brainless button mashing, and the story was given in 10 minute chunks, in between which you had to sit through 2-3 hours of "help character A defeat villain." And I have nothing against Disney, Lion King was fucking awesome, but I really would have preferred to keep the decent characters you get in the different worlds, instead of having to use an unlikeable Goofy/Donald combo.

Blind_Evil

]]> 9:365347:c4605475 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:25:07 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605474 Silent Hill 4 The Room

Tales of Legendia (You can beat this game with your character set to automatic. Really.)

The Witcher Potions. Completely lame combat. Potions.
Voice acting from high school drama class dropouts. Video glitches. Potions...


brianwh

]]> 9:365347:c4605474 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:25:03 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605473 @RPGr: I don't think those games blemished their franchise or genre in any way. It's like James Kane said when a reporter asked how he felt about the fact movie adaptations had ruined his books, he responded: "No they haven't young man. They're on that shelf right there and they're all just fine."

Chrono Cross, whether you like the game or not, hasn't had any effect on Chrono Trigger.

baked ham

]]> 9:365347:c4605473 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:24:13 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605472 Every Tomb Raider, Final Fantasy (except Chrystal Chronicles) and Tekken.

nmlss

]]> 9:365347:c4605472 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:24:07 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605465 Sonic Adventure: fuck talking sonic and double fuck unskipable cut scenes.

FFX: Fuck tidus and whiny turd protagonists.

Super Paper Mario: fuck nintendo for making this game that I sooooooo wanted to love. Seriously: that level where the puzzle is solved by holding the d-pad in one direction for 15 minutes is fucking retarded. that and the 100 samurai fight.

Dang-fuzz

]]> 9:365347:c4605465 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:21:28 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605463 I read the first 50 or so, and so far I gotta say that I'm glad every single one of the games mentioned was made. Every last one was good for the industry or the genre in some way. It showed how something good could be blundered and that leads to it being done properly the next time. In fact, a lot of them are games I particularly liked. Like ShenMue, I think that was a good game and in many ways it was good for gaming. I also liked Deathrap Dungeon: it was fun.

To the one who mentioned all the games that Uwe Boll has made films of, that was funny and I laughed out loud, but I see no problem with their existence either. It's fine and his films have a right to exist (and be laughed & pointed at!).

I stopped reading at that point, so I'm not sure what was mentioned thereafter.

I can't really honestly mention a single game that I would unmake, because no game that has ever been made has ever reduced my livelihood by sucking. If I've played a sucky game (and I have) I usually got a good laugh out of it, or I just hated it and let it go away so I could play something I do enjoy, but it hasn't effected me emotionally in any way and it certainly hasn't prevented good games from being made.

baked ham

]]> 9:365347:c4605463 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:20:18 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605448 Any 3D Castlevania

Eltigro

]]> 9:365347:c4605448 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:15:46 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605435 Every game that looked to exploit anything in the pop culture realm. IE: American Idol Games, Bratz games (Well, I'd just go ahead and unmake Bratz in general), those old Barney games, that ET Atari game, etc.

CheckersMcGavern

]]> 9:365347:c4605435 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:10:21 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605431 From the big names:

KOTR 2 - anyone who has played both will agree

Final Fantasy 7 & 8 - could have spun off into a new series

WoW - as others have said, this game has completely stalled any innovation in the MMO arena

Sonic Adventure 2 - regarded as the series' death note

From the smaller names:

Blue Dragon - disappointment
Chrono Cross - not a Chrono game

To me in order for a game to be unmade, it had to have blemished either a great series or failed to live up to promises made by (big-shot)developers. Otherwise, there's always room for another game in the market.

RPGr

]]> 9:365347:c4605431 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:07:50 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605429 Pokémon Blue/Red.. I like the game.. but after it was made, every game needed to have some kind of collectible card or animal or something with more than 100 kinds.. it's influence ruined a lot of good games.. -_-'

CockroachMan

]]> 9:365347:c4605429 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:07:22 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605426 Pitfighter on SNES. I actually paid for that shite and never heard the end of it...

shufflemoomin

]]> 9:365347:c4605426 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:06:17 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605413 Years ago there was a game called "Cosmic Race" I believe. I wish with all the power of the Universe I could un-see and un-pay it.

-EDGE-

]]> 9:365347:c4605413 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:00:51 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605407 counter strike so I could regain a few years of my life back.

Virgil Tibbs

]]> 9:365347:c4605407 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 07:00:03 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605404 @grumbel: I wish I could hate you to death for even hypothesising that MI3 should be unmade. MI4 was crapish but MI3 is still one of my favourite games and one of the last great Point-and-click adventures.

el_rezzo

]]> 9:365347:c4605404 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 06:58:17 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]> http://kotaku.com/365347/which-game-would-you-unmake#c4605401 Shaq-FU

SAKY

]]> 9:365347:c4605401 Sat, 08 Mar 2008 06:57:06 MST <![CDATA[Which Game Would You Unmake?]]>