Kotaku 
Enter your username and password.
Denver, 10:40 PM
Sat Nov 28
18 posts in the last 24 hours
Tip us:
Editor-In-Chief:
Brian Crecente
| AIM | Twitter
Deputy Editor:
Stephen Totilo
| AIM | Twitter
Senior Editor:
Michael McWhertor
| AIM | Twitter
Senior Contributing Editor, Japan:
Brian Ashcraft
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, East Coast:
Michael Fahey
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, Oceania:
Luke Plunkett
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, Weekends:
Owen Good
| AIM | Twitter
Correspondent, San Francisco:
AJ Glasser
| AIM | Twitter
Columnist:
Leigh Alexander
Columnist:
Tim Rogers
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.
11/18/09
11/18/09
11/18/09
11/17/09
Trust me AJ, i will wholeheartedly enjoy them (^_~)
P.s let me add one more pic to the list ^_^ #tombraider
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
Is that why TR had to re-invent itself over the last few games? #tombraider
11/17/09
Legend, Anniversary, and Underworld look different than the older games because they're made by Crystal Dynamics now, not Core. But that's beside the point.
My point is that too many people compare Uncharted to TR when they're not really in the same genre. It's like.. if TR is Resident Evil 2, than Uncharted is Resident Evil 5.
Both TR and Uncharted have exploring, puzzles, and shooting.. but Uncharted concentrates the most on the shooting, and the puzzles and exploring are just there to fill the gaps between gunfights. TR also has shooting, but it's obviously only there because it's hard to sell an adventure game without any enemies (which is why the combat is kinda blah). In my opinion, it's not far to compare the two as there's an audience for both. #tombraider
11/17/09
11/17/09
Don't get me wrong. I love the TR series, but let's be real here. The last few TR games were shallow and short. The next TR needs bigger production values, better acting, better story, multiplayer, better villians, better controls. The list goes on. Uncharted 2 rewrote on the book on action adventure games. GOTY!!! #tombraider
11/17/09
Also, I'm really not seeing what everyone else sees in the Uncharted games (yes, I own both and have finished of them). I'm honestly not trying to troll here, so please understand that I found the Uncharted games to be quite entertaining and I enjoyed playing through them.
However, the environment navigation that was taken from TR was done sloppily, inaccurate, and also a bit heavy handed on the "oopsie-daisies" when you missed a jump. It made you feel like you were ice skating at the best of times and teleporting at the worst of times. IMO, that's not better than TR.
Also, the puzzles in both Uncharted games are literally a waste of time. I mean, they have the damn answers written for you in a book. They're not even hints; they're totally just answers. They're all something along the lines of "turn this thing till it looks like this image". With puzzles that totally mindless, I'd have rather had Drake solve them in a cutscene since it obviously doesn't require my thought processes to solve them.
Those are my two biggest issues. For the Uncharted series to render the TR series into useless, it needs to actually be better than the TR series when it comes to its strengths.. and those are the environment navigation and puzzles. TR has never been about the combat, so I don't see a point in even comparing that. I mean, I think there's more enemies in the first chapter of Uncharted than all of TR:Underworld. #tombraider
11/18/09
I agree, that while the puzzles are easy in Uncharted 2. They are nice looking and fun, even if they're easy to solve. I had no real issue with the jumping and climbing. I loved it! I especially liked the good acting and constant chatter while you're playing the game. TR legend's dialogue puts you to sleep.
Now, I agree that TR essentially created this genre in gaming. If you've followed all my post on Kotaku, often I'm defending TR, about not getting any regonition in the gaming industry. It's always seen as just that TNA game. I love the TR series and Uncharted was no doubt influenced by TR & the Indy series. So the comparison is obvious.
Let's get to the real point though. TR has flopped in sales for the past ten years. It got ok to awful reviews at best in those years. It's lucky Square came along. The franchise is on it's last legs.
The reality is, the Uncharted series has set a new bar for this genre, starting with game play, graphics, dialogue, story, length, multiplayer and combat. It's a damn fine game and most important, Fun! Gamers and critics can attest to that. You my friend are in the minority.
Combat today is very important in action and adventure games. It's time for TR series to start using more combat and have a better combat system. I mean shooting bad A.I. of animals is getting way old. The TR series looks old and silly next to today's games. I really hope Square tackles TR with a more modern approach. One that that appeals to today's gamers.
11/18/09
Why? Because the industry now considers Uncharted the premiere action puzzle adventure game. The benchmark has been set. #tombraider
11/18/09
Tomb Raider Anniversary: = 77
Tomb Raider Underworld: = 76. None of those are awful scores. I hear what you're saying to a degree, but having now finished Uncharted 2, the exploration side was lacking. I have to agree with Tayruh, I got a whole lot more out of Tomb Raider, and felt Uncharted, whilst a graphical tour de force, was lacking. But that doesn't mean I'm right of course, I thought GTAIV set a new bar for sandbox games, and most people call it an 'overhyped' game that didn't compare to San Andreas or (le horror!) Saints Row 2.
And finally, there's nothing wrong with being in the minority. The minority are the ones purchasing games like NMH, The World Ends With You, most of Atlus' back catalogue etc. Heck if you want to try the "you're in the minority" argument, then everything = minigames/rhythm games/COD for evermore.
11/18/09
That's why I feel it's not fair to compare the two. They're always compared by their combat systems and nothing else.
It's kinda weird, really. The only reason Uncharted gets compared to TR at all is because it stole its environmental navigation techniques (I think it would have been better off stealing Assassin Creed's, to be honest), which most people that enjoy Uncharted don't even seem to give a crap about. You never see anyone saying "Aww shit! Gears of War is totally done for now!"
@TearsandScreams: Dammit. :P I hate using the "I'm in the minority" argument, because I hate seeming like I hate everything just because everyone else likes it.. but I have to say that I'm a huge SMT fan, think that TWEWY is one of the greatest DS games ever, and really want NMH. I guess you have me pinned pretty well. I just like actually deciding which games *I* like and not having some stuck up reviewer throwing out some score on the 4 point scale to tell me what's worth playing.
(P.S. I really like Call of Duty also, so I guess I don't fit 100%.)
11/18/09
11/18/09
11/18/09
That's all? Are you sure? How about that they're both treasure hunters. They both solve puzzles in tombs. They both feature collecting treasure and artifacts.
TR has been sucking for years. Remember when it was nominated for game of the year? Oh yeah it never was, remember how everyone was gushing over TR. Oh yeah they don't. What planet do you live on?
I understand you love all the TR games. That's fine, but I'm talking about the big picture here. The bottom line is Uncharted 2 is loved by almost everyone in the industry. Regardless of what you say and it will win game of the year on many different sites. When TR does that. Will talk again.
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
I've gotten stuff taken down with little more than "look, it's obviously a drawover of original art!" #tombraider
11/18/09
Does that pay well?
11/19/09
Any comparisons to "snitchin'" will be disregarded.
11/17/09
Putting the face of Natalie Portman on Lara Croft is totally Batman. #tombraider
11/17/09
11/18/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
so basically this one.
[maxcdn.thedesigninspiration.com]
The rest are just "look at my giant breasts and dumb expression oh yeah mmm sexy" :| #tombraider
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
Samus on the other hand.. #tombraider
11/17/09
Thanks for sharing, some nice stuff to look at there indeed. #tombraider
11/17/09
A lot of the drawings sure are sleazy!
11/17/09
05/22/09
05/22/09