This guy should be locked up for good. He likely caused permanent scarring on her body, and he'll get out in probably less than a year. We need less people like this in the world. Don't let them back in.
@SacGamer: If he's mentally ill, then he can't be held liable in the same way that a mentally healthy person can. "Mental illness" isn't just some buzzword tossed around, it's a disability like any other.
"We need less people like this in the world".
Well, let's see... there's two ways of doing that. One involves providing the necessary help, and the other involves genocide. And since you obviously think that the mentally ill don't deserve help, then that leaves option two.
So... when should we show up for the execution, sir? I spent quite a few years in institutions and therapy, so I guess I've forfeited my right to exist in society as well. Wouldn't want one of us nutjobs going out and killing people, after all.
@SacGamer:
You can only be evil if you knowingly and maliciously perform an evil on another person. This guy read a guide and apparently followed it as fact or truth in his own demented mind. You can't punish someone for a crime they were unaware of. This itself though is a sticky situation, the guy is not an immediate threat to society but at the same time can be manipulated to being a threat.
@SacGamer: Societies are judged by how they treat their most vulnerable members, and the mentally ill can be very vulnerable. Try suppressing your knee-jerk reactions for a second and think about the ways society can respond to help prevent/reduce things like this happening in future. Clue: punishment isn't the answer.
@Paradice: Neither is "helping" them, because the girl still got stabbed. The only way to remove threats like this for good is to remove what caused the threat for good. What if this man stops taking his medication? That happens all the time and usually they (the crazies) end up doing something bad. Then not only is he responsible, as far as I'm concerned, society is responsible for letting him live in it.
@SacGamer: I don't think I'd be happy living in the society you're describing, where you don't help but just 'remove the threat for good' (presumably by killing or permanently imprisoning the offender). Iran has laws like that. Take this example from Kotaku sister site:
@SacGamer: "The crazies"? You never cease to astound, my friend. What next? "The jews and negroes"?
You have no idea how it works, do you? As long as he is a danger to himself or others, he won't have a choice in the matter. They will force him to take the meds. And most of these meds are fatal or debilitating if stopped suddenly, anyway.
I'm starting to wonder if you're not one of us after all. Hell, you may be the head honcho of "the crazies". You're talking about some Hitler-level segregation here.
I said earlier that I wouldn't wish mental illness on you. Consider that sentiment revoked.
You need to walk a mile in this guy's shoes. You need to live in the daily fear of losing control of your own mind. You need to meet people who think like you do, and be outcasted by them for having a disease that you never asked for or wanted.
@ShaggE wants to join the Egg Council.: Sorry, I'll be more sensetive to monsters like this who victimize innocent little girls in the future. Oh wait, no I won't.
I hope to god you never have a daughter. She could be victimized and you would do nothing about it.
"The prosecutor wanted hem tried for attempted murder but the court stepped in and said, no, it's quite likely this guy is nuts."
I'm really glad the court didn't say "no, it's quite likely that ZOMG VIDYA GAEMS MAKE YOU CRAAAAZY! BAN VIDYA GAEMS FROM EVRYTHING FOR ALL ETERNITY!!!", because to be honest, video games are probably the most popular scapegoat of this generation, right behind "the internet".
Reminds me of a show I went to where a guy was dancing around with a hunting blade and making slashing motions into thin air. Needless to say, everyone was giving him space and nobody wanted to stand near him.
While I'm terribly sorry for the girl and hope she is okay now, I am slightly glad that SHE was attacked rather than a baby, which is what I thought had happened when I saw that picture.
@maraxusofk: The "joke" was not obvious from the article.
Then again I expect nothing from Owen any more after he threw away his journalistic integrity after his recent "article" where he insults and bashes other countries and culture despite, and most likely because, living in the most ignorant country in the world.
@RilleL: Well, RilleL, let me clear this up for you.
You see, when one loses connection to the Internet, one often seeks out to remedy that problem. Due to a general lack of expertise many people choose to consult a set of instructions, often a manual of some sort, to determine the cause of the issue. This is called troubleshooting.
Now, if you're still following, this is the regular process a person might take. Upon reading said troubleshooting manual one would often follow any instructions printed on its pages in order to try and remedy the problem.
On account of this, many people often associate the idea of dropped internet with some sort of manual. Therefore it's not far fetched to venture the idea that any actions taken in response to internet trouble would be at the behest of some sort of instructive book.
The article also connects the stabbing of a girl to a dropped internet connection. With these two connections established -- manuals and stabbing both in response to internet -- it is possible that a writer could deduce that the stabbing is undertaken due to urging from a troubleshooting manual. However, the idea of such content inside a manual is quite ludicrous, and this instills amusement in many readers. That would qualify this deduction to be classified as a "joke."
I understand it wasn't obvious at all, but I'm hoping that my post has cleared up Owen Good's attempt at humor for you and any other confused readers. I suspect the only reason I was able to glean his obscured grab for a chuckle is due to my education training me in the study and analysis of literature.
@RilleL: Welcome to the internet. Guess what? Kotaku is and always has been a blog. Granted, it's a prolific gaming blog, but it's never, ever going to become the media you're wanting.
Go back to IGN and cry me a fucking river, because I'm sick of hearing all this shit about journalists, etc.
For god sakes, these guys/girls report what they can, and post whatever they can to keep content fresh, even if that means putting their opinion out there which others might not like. The website isn't meant to be "SRS BUSINES", that's why (if you look back fairly recently) there was a blog post consisting of something along the lines of "porn porn porn porn pr0n porn porn. Porn porn, porn porn porn (porn porn)."
TL;DR Die in a fire
as a side note, I ALMOST followed that with proper HTML termination o____O
10/11/09
10/12/09
I wonder how old she is now?
10/12/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/12/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
"We need less people like this in the world".
Well, let's see... there's two ways of doing that. One involves providing the necessary help, and the other involves genocide. And since you obviously think that the mentally ill don't deserve help, then that leaves option two.
So... when should we show up for the execution, sir? I spent quite a few years in institutions and therapy, so I guess I've forfeited my right to exist in society as well. Wouldn't want one of us nutjobs going out and killing people, after all.
10/11/09
You can only be evil if you knowingly and maliciously perform an evil on another person. This guy read a guide and apparently followed it as fact or truth in his own demented mind. You can't punish someone for a crime they were unaware of. This itself though is a sticky situation, the guy is not an immediate threat to society but at the same time can be manipulated to being a threat.
10/11/09
10/12/09
10/12/09
[jezebel.com]
10/12/09
You have no idea how it works, do you? As long as he is a danger to himself or others, he won't have a choice in the matter. They will force him to take the meds. And most of these meds are fatal or debilitating if stopped suddenly, anyway.
I'm starting to wonder if you're not one of us after all. Hell, you may be the head honcho of "the crazies". You're talking about some Hitler-level segregation here.
I said earlier that I wouldn't wish mental illness on you. Consider that sentiment revoked.
You need to walk a mile in this guy's shoes. You need to live in the daily fear of losing control of your own mind. You need to meet people who think like you do, and be outcasted by them for having a disease that you never asked for or wanted.
10/12/09
I hope to god you never have a daughter. She could be victimized and you would do nothing about it.
10/18/09
10/19/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
Is there WiFi where he's going?
10/11/09
I'm really glad the court didn't say "no, it's quite likely that ZOMG VIDYA GAEMS MAKE YOU CRAAAAZY! BAN VIDYA GAEMS FROM EVRYTHING FOR ALL ETERNITY!!!", because to be honest, video games are probably the most popular scapegoat of this generation, right behind "the internet".
10/11/09
Crazy people + knives do not mix.
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
Oh, wait... [www.youtube.com]
10/11/09
10/11/09
Joke
-----
Head
10/11/09
Then again I expect nothing from Owen any more after he threw away his journalistic integrity after his recent "article" where he insults and bashes other countries and culture despite, and most likely because, living in the most ignorant country in the world.
10/11/09
10/11/09
10/11/09
Also, RilleL, to reinforce the point, and make it a tiny bit clearer:
Joke
------
YOUR Head
10/11/09
10/11/09
You see, when one loses connection to the Internet, one often seeks out to remedy that problem. Due to a general lack of expertise many people choose to consult a set of instructions, often a manual of some sort, to determine the cause of the issue. This is called troubleshooting.
Now, if you're still following, this is the regular process a person might take. Upon reading said troubleshooting manual one would often follow any instructions printed on its pages in order to try and remedy the problem.
On account of this, many people often associate the idea of dropped internet with some sort of manual. Therefore it's not far fetched to venture the idea that any actions taken in response to internet trouble would be at the behest of some sort of instructive book.
The article also connects the stabbing of a girl to a dropped internet connection. With these two connections established -- manuals and stabbing both in response to internet -- it is possible that a writer could deduce that the stabbing is undertaken due to urging from a troubleshooting manual. However, the idea of such content inside a manual is quite ludicrous, and this instills amusement in many readers. That would qualify this deduction to be classified as a "joke."
I understand it wasn't obvious at all, but I'm hoping that my post has cleared up Owen Good's attempt at humor for you and any other confused readers. I suspect the only reason I was able to glean his obscured grab for a chuckle is due to my education training me in the study and analysis of literature.
10/11/09
*golf clap
10/11/09
10/11/09
Go back to IGN and cry me a fucking river, because I'm sick of hearing all this shit about journalists, etc.
For god sakes, these guys/girls report what they can, and post whatever they can to keep content fresh, even if that means putting their opinion out there which others might not like. The website isn't meant to be "SRS BUSINES", that's why (if you look back fairly recently) there was a blog post consisting of something along the lines of "porn porn porn porn pr0n porn porn. Porn porn, porn porn porn (porn porn)."
TL;DR Die in a fire
as a side note, I ALMOST followed that with proper HTML termination o____O
10/11/09
10/11/09
Bang bang stupid Youtube Remixes made sure! That he was dead~~!
[insert Moog synthesizer transition]
10/11/09
10/11/09
*Runs to buy some more of that Lincoln Shoe Shine*