How much do you make yearly? I dont expect it to be alot, mabey 30-50k a year? I'd love to do your job but the issue is money... you dont make enough right?
@Stephen Totilo: True true, I respect that. I myself am majoring in Electrical Engineering into the power field mainly for the 100-200k a year lols. I wanted to be a programmer and make video games but realised that programmers are over worked and under payed, however a game journalist like yourself really interests me, even with average pay I'm sure its a fun job if gaming is your life right? Your also famous haha, you get put on T.V and people respect you, thats something money cant buy.
I might in my far future consider game journalism as a hobby and who knows I might make it to Kotaku someday if I'm good lols
Stephen out of all the Kotaku writers, your my favourite, why? Other than being a hard worker, Because your so dang cool, thats why^^ I love your personality you truly seem like a very nice guy.
@berober04: Reporting is harder. The labor of reviewing involves playing a game, thinking about it and writing about it. Mechanically, that's easy, which isn't to detract from the talent of those who do it well. Finding out information, particularly information people don't want you to know or didn't hand to you on a platter -- but that you think your readership would be interested in -- is, generally, harder.
@Stephen Totilo: I guess that's how it is though. I always thought the idea of having to play a game over and over, to get the feel of it was quite hard, especially when the game was rather quite bad.
I guess that's why good reviewers are good though, they can get the job done and go on to the next one all the same
@Artibeus: I guess...but it does look pretty silly when a lot of the site is "Here's some stuff other people reported on, we're just gonna borrow it and reword it" though I know that's how lots of places work.
That's why I like stephen's articles, because they are usually(if not always) actually his.
@WhiteMåge: Sometimes it can't be helped. A lot of sites get tips from people, or, they are lucky and just spot something first. I tend to like actual on site stuff too; but you can't expect that to always be what's posted.
That reason would be why I love E3; over time (if you stick to a website) you kinda know what the writer likes / dislikes and what games he or she likes / dislikes. So when they do hans on stuff (at E3 amongst other things) it can give you a much better feeling as to if you are going to like the game or not.
@WhiteMåge: I just started working as an intern at a games website, and while the veil was lifted for me a while ago, I've realized just how much content isn't necessarily borrowed from other sites, as much as it is sent out by PR firms to each and every games journalist there is.
That's why you see a lot of the same stuff from site to site. It's being broadcast out to several outlets. Maybe there are a few websites who take straight from other sources, but most everyone is on the mailing list for the press releases that detail release dates, contests, new screen shots, etc.
That being said, Kotaku does a lot of original reporting that you can see wrapped up at the end of every week by Owen.
@Daniel @ playreadwrite.blogspot.com: Just to clarify, when I say "borrow stuff from other sites" I don't mean they post the same information, I mean the article literally consists 100% of things from another site, linked at the bottom, usually with much, much more information. Half the time the summary of the linked article is incorrect or missing key details, at that. :\
@WhiteMåge: We do have different roles at Kotaku, which is why you'll typically see me write fewer posts than some of my colleagues. My location in New York, which gives me in-person access to a lot of traveling developers and executives, as well as my experience reporting made reporting original stories part of my mandate. We all overlap, and not one of the people on the Kotaku team is unimportant or doing the "easy" work. I admire the effort and energy of everyone here. As for reviews, we spread those duties out just about evenly.
@WhiteMåge: Yeah, because we don't all have time to go to every little site that has news and read it... so Kotaku, which is a blog, tries to aggregate information that is relevant to their blog subject. Also, people don't always want to read the story but instead want a good summary and the option to read the original article or information elsewhere. If you don't like the approach, why don't you troll 5000 other sites instead of just one.
I'm gonna agree with the 360 fans on this one... It's better than a 3 minute install ever hour or two like MGS4 had... I wish MGS4 allowed a SINGLE INSTALL. Then I'd love it even more. #notebookdump
@Pombar: I was going to say the same thing. Call me old-school, but I'm actually excited about a multi-disc Final Fantasy game. Now as long as they don't skimp on the packaging.... #notebookdump
@KagaSakai: Yeah, seriously. Lost Odyssey packing that fourth disc into a little sleeve is not an acceptable way to present four discs. In Japan/Asia, at least, they got a case capable of holding four discs naturally! #notebookdump
@Pombar: While it's certainly better than multiple installs, how can it be nostalgic since the first 6 FF games didn't do it... OH RIGHT! You started with 7.
I hate switching discs, but I hate multiple installs more. #notebookdump
@bobtheduck in Korea: @iiqulo: I'm sorry, are you trying to make me ashamed for starting with 7? Elitist, much? S'not like I haven't played all the previous ones.
I appreciate old school as much as the next guy - the hours I sank into the likes of Etrian Odyssey, Dragon Warrior and the like are enough proof for me, anyway - but let's not start with the "my old school is better than yours". That's just ridiculous.
Oh, and it is possible to be nostalgic about disc changes - nostalgic doesn't mean anything about 'the original' way something was done. Merely something that isn't generally done anymore. 'The pain of wishing to return' doesn't require the place of return to be the first evarrrr. Just some time/place/etc you remember fondly.
@Pombar: You say "the original way" I think thats the point here, FF7 isn't the original way it was done. Refer to my other reply to your post. 3 FF's out of 12 just means you're nostalgic for your PlayStation 1 not for the FF games of old. FF fans of 3 separate generations will not be "nostalgic" for Disc swapping. #notebookdump
@KazeEternal: This just patently isn't true - I'm nostalgic for my secondary schooling in equal parts with my primary schooling - my entire childhood was made up solely of neither. In the same way a fan might be nostalgic for 16 bit spritework, or the pre-ATB turn based battles, you can equally be nostalgic for disc swapping or any of the other features of the 32 bit FFs.
Nostalgia has nothing to do with the most common, the most 'original' or any other such quantifier - you can be nostalgic about anything that's in the past. #notebookdump
@Pombar: Ok then lets break this down, you are nostalgic for PS1 FF's (please don't use bit count for identifiers you could easily call FFXIII a 32 bit FF since it is running on an X360), because you miss the PS1's disc swapping days. This has nothing to do with Final Fantasy. Given the history of FF the only gamers who would be nostalgic for disc swapping are PlayStation 1 and Sega Saturn gamers.
Anyone else would welcome a single disc because they don't want the technology getting in the way of the experience. Honestly that is something we've been trying to get away from since the SNES days which is why CD's were first used in the first place.
Now when it comes down to it, it doesn't matter which version of the damn game you play. However proclaiming nostalgia over something like disc swapping... come on man... really? It's flat out idiotic to even proclaim in the context of a series that for 75+% of the releases of the series have all been single storage medium technologies with the largest capacity they could grant. Basically it's far more Nostalgic to see Square push a final fantasy to require a BD disc then to see them squander time and effort on a multi disc DVD package and have them take you for a wild ride through their incredibly crafted worlds. #notebookdump
@bean: Nope, not if you sound like an idiot while doing it. What he did was fondly remember a Pencil over a Pen. He didn't fondly remember Final Fantasy.
What's worse is all these X360 fanboys trying to justify an inconvenience with things like "nostalgia". It's sad really, border line buyers remorse. #notebookdump
@KazeEternal: I didn't say it was the most nostalgic thing in there. I'm just saying, it's a minor nostalgic feeling I get which means I don't get aggravated over disc-swapping - if you do, that's fine. For me, it's not an issue. It's just a little throwback to younger days of gaming - and a memory for me tied to this same series (FFs were the only multi-disc games I ever had on the platform, thus my linking the series to it). People get similarly nostalgic about smaller things such as blowing into a cartridge to make it work. That's an annoyance, yes, but nonetheless we have fond memories of it. #notebookdump
@KazeEternal: Sounds more like you want X360 gamers to cry about it a bit more to make you feel better about not having to do it? You seem awfully keen to stomp on other people's enjoyment just because you don't fondly remember the same things.
I may remember and appreciate different things about the series to you, but that doesn't make me 'less of a fan' of it or whatnot. Just one with different preferences to you. These are called opinions, and not everyone shares the same ones. #notebookdump
@bean: apparently not, sadly. Some people just have to make sure they're having more fun (or fun for the 'right reasons') than others. D'ah well. #notebookdump
@Pombar: I never said you're less of a Fan because of your nostalgia. Merely pointing out your fondness for disc swapping is unrelated to your fandome.
As far as X360 owners crying or not. I don't care I'll be playing my copy of FFXIII on my PS3 and not on my X360, mostly because I'd like to finish the game without having to worry about RRoD. Which btw my system did this past week playing Gears of War 2 with a friend of mine. If I want them to cry over anything it would be that, not disc swapping.
However I also hate it when people come up with stupid reasons to justify their dissatisfying situation. Maybe it stems from some sort of frustration when I was a child or maybe I just encounter allot of really stupid people in my life. When it comes down to it, pretending like Disc Swapping is a non-issue is a bit retarded.
By saying you're ok with it, you're opening the doors for future systems to do the same. You're opening the door by saying "hey it's ok to give me something that would train wreck my experience". Ya it's not a mortal wound to the game itself, but it certainly effects how the designers make their games and how the programmers approach development of the engine and how the scenario plans outline progression. The game changes because of the Hardware. #notebookdump
@KazeEternal: I think you're overestimating how awful disc swapping is. At most it's a minor inconvenience - such that it can not only be ignored but enjoyed for nostalgia's sake in my case. If you have that much aggro about it, it's just as well that you're getting the PS3 version, and have access to it that way. But I won't apologise for encouraging something I do enjoy - be it overworld maps in RPGs, ATB battle systems, or something as small as disc swapping. Indeed, the PS1 FFs made such great use of disc swapping that they even arranged the games into deliberate acts - each with their own climax and suitable ending. Take a look at how each disc ends in FF9 and you'll see they didn't just 'run out of space' - it was a deliberate conclusion to each act in the game's story.
Out of limitation can be born excellence. #notebookdump
@Pombar: On a game like FF, it's usually a minor inconvenience. On a game like Riven... Oh, boy. Riven was such a huge pain... Even MGS1 was a pain, if you ever wanted to go back to disc one (which I did frequently) I suppose the FF games had moments like that, if I remember correctly (disc 2-3 on 7, disc 3-4 on 8) If the game is entirely linear in progression with no need to ever go back to a previous disc, then it's not an issue. If not, it's an issue.
And I wasn't being elitist... I just think it's funny that you could have nostalgia for something so far along in the series that only lasted 3 games (out of the FF series, anyhow), though I suppose there's some nostalgia for me with those games (if not for disc switching), too. When I finally got the PS1, it was a turning point in my gaming. It also introduced many new annoyances. Loading times and disc changing the biggest of them.
I also think that there are so many people who started in the PS1 era, it's a bit strange for those of us who started with the 2600. Of course, with a very small number of exceptions, I wouldn't mind forgetting the 2600 existed.
On an entirely different topic, I remember someone asking me "If you're (26 at the time, 27 now) how can you have started with the 2600? It was out before you were born!"
Just like I've never seen Star Wars or I Love Lucy because they were out before I was born.
Entirely off topic, I know... Talking about the 2600 reminded me of how someone had "gotten" me with their impenetrable logic of catching me in a lie. #notebookdump
@bobtheduck in Korea: Nah, I started with the SNES although many would suppose I'm too young (20) for that - fact is, some of us couldn't afford the then-current console at the time and had to go second hand with the previous generation.
And similarly, I've played all the main series FFs despite them being before my time. I'll admit, I'm one of those terrible worthless human beings whose first FF was 7. But that was an age thing, and not exactly a deliberate choice. So yeah, there're lots of things I get nostalgic about from that age - disc-swapping is among the most minor. It's just, apparently disc-swapping was the one I wasn't allowed. #notebookdump
By the way, I have to say, the MSNBC thing was definitely great. I like you as it is, but seeing you do that just made it all the better.
It's nice to know that this stuff can be explained by people who don't come off as pretentious industry figureheads. Nobody would listen to their explanations. #notebookdump
@Sonyphonics: THe auto promote thing is meant to deter people from feeding trolls... It's sort of like people complaining about seatbelt, drunk driving, and no cellphone when driving laws. #notebookdump
@excel_excel:
I'd like to add my super-cool-dude double thumbs-up to that. And also formally select Totilo for the 'best video games guy talking about video games somewhere else where they don't know much about video games' award. #notebookdump
@Stephen Totilo: Your welcome Stephen!
Thats also awesome the way you always reply in comments and when you review a game too answering questions. #notebookdump
@Stephen Totilo:
If gaming were a ship, I'd strap you naked to the prow as our glorious figure-head, parting the waves of ignorance with eloquence and intriguing debate. And sexiness. #notebookdump
@excel_excel:
Can I take this moment to say something?
Stephen- I was very skeptical of Kotaku hiring you before you came on board. See, I'm an old school Kotaku fan- reading for years, only recently posting- and didn't want any "new blood" coming along and changing things.
I can honestly say, that you have become my favorite of the journalists [sorry Bashcroft :( ] It's nothing against anyone else, but it's all about how well you write, the thoughtful and interesting stories you come up with, and the willingness to do things that haven't been done before around here. The "Nintendo asks Sony asks MS" things was brilliant.
Enough ass kissing, I'm just very happy to see you a part of this family and I hope you stay around for a long time
Ps- Brians: I still love you #notebookdump
i agree. that was awsome. i thought they were going to jump to the usual games r bad thing. but u set them straight. did u see the look on the woman`s face? lol she was like .. pwned , anyway u did a great job not making gamers look like psychos. #notebookdump
That ME2 drone update makes total sense now. It's nice to hear another class gets a cool perk, I always preferrred playing a soldier myself. #notebookdump
@VSpeck: It just goes to show how high quality Bioware games are. Despite their technical flaws, the games themselves are absolutely riveting. #notebookdump
@VSpeck: Right. If reviews are to keep disregarding their technical flaws, overlooking them in favor of that which has been done right (even if done exceptionally well), then the flaws will continue to be overlooked, even if on a subconscious level.
Yes, they may address the bugs in their future games, but not to the degree where lower scores of the current games would pressure them to achieve. #notebookdump
@NeVeRMoRe666: I don't know. Besides their Baldur's Gate games, I've only played Mass Effect (which is one of my all time favorite games). I also didn't get a chance to play Mass Effect until a year after its release.
It must have been patched well enough by then however. I don't remember the game having any bugs really.
Since I don't have any first hand experience with their bugs, I assumed the complaints above, as well as the reviews, were reliable.
Either way, I'm still definitely purchasing Dragon Age over winter break, and ME2 the day it comes out. #notebookdump
@Stephen Totilo: True, but also, your reviews aren't part of the numeric reviews Vspeck was referring to.
There are numerical reviews on Metacritic that score the game from 90-100. Perhaps the bugs aren't that distracting then, but one of the reviewers did give the game a slightly brutal review and a score of 60.
I have yet to experience the game myself. It was actually Kotaku's review of the PS3 version vs the PC version that convinced me to hold off on the game until I have more free time. #notebookdump
11/21/09
11/20/09
11/20/09
11/20/09
11/20/09
11/20/09
I might in my far future consider game journalism as a hobby and who knows I might make it to Kotaku someday if I'm good lols
Stephen out of all the Kotaku writers, your my favourite, why? Other than being a hard worker, Because your so dang cool, thats why^^ I love your personality you truly seem like a very nice guy.
#speakup
11/20/09
Being only 16, I haven't really looked much into my future, but to me, it would seem like reporting on games would be easier.
11/20/09
11/21/09
I guess that's why good reviewers are good though, they can get the job done and go on to the next one all the same
11/20/09
From what I can tell you, stephen, usually actually report on stuff. You go places and talk to people.
But some others often do very little more than simply literally resposting stuff other sites and other people reported on.
Am I imagining that?
11/20/09
Or at least, thats how I see it.
11/20/09
That's why I like stephen's articles, because they are usually(if not always) actually his.
11/20/09
That reason would be why I love E3; over time (if you stick to a website) you kinda know what the writer likes / dislikes and what games he or she likes / dislikes. So when they do hans on stuff (at E3 amongst other things) it can give you a much better feeling as to if you are going to like the game or not.
#speakup
11/20/09
That's why you see a lot of the same stuff from site to site. It's being broadcast out to several outlets. Maybe there are a few websites who take straight from other sources, but most everyone is on the mailing list for the press releases that detail release dates, contests, new screen shots, etc.
That being said, Kotaku does a lot of original reporting that you can see wrapped up at the end of every week by Owen.
11/20/09
11/20/09
11/20/09
11/20/09
11/13/09
It's like blowing into an NES cartridge; it takes time I could be spending actually playing the game. #notebookdump
11/13/09
11/14/09
11/14/09
11/14/09
I'm gonna agree with the 360 fans on this one... It's better than a 3 minute install ever hour or two like MGS4 had... I wish MGS4 allowed a SINGLE INSTALL. Then I'd love it even more. #notebookdump
11/13/09
11/13/09
11/13/09
At least in MGS4 he like tells you to change disc but then says he's only joking cause the blu ray is dual layer. #notebookdump
11/13/09
11/14/09
I hate switching discs, but I hate multiple installs more. #notebookdump
11/14/09
I appreciate old school as much as the next guy - the hours I sank into the likes of Etrian Odyssey, Dragon Warrior and the like are enough proof for me, anyway - but let's not start with the "my old school is better than yours". That's just ridiculous.
Oh, and it is possible to be nostalgic about disc changes - nostalgic doesn't mean anything about 'the original' way something was done. Merely something that isn't generally done anymore. 'The pain of wishing to return' doesn't require the place of return to be the first evarrrr. Just some time/place/etc you remember fondly.
11/14/09
11/14/09
Nostalgia has nothing to do with the most common, the most 'original' or any other such quantifier - you can be nostalgic about anything that's in the past. #notebookdump
11/14/09
11/14/09
Anyone else would welcome a single disc because they don't want the technology getting in the way of the experience. Honestly that is something we've been trying to get away from since the SNES days which is why CD's were first used in the first place.
Now when it comes down to it, it doesn't matter which version of the damn game you play. However proclaiming nostalgia over something like disc swapping... come on man... really? It's flat out idiotic to even proclaim in the context of a series that for 75+% of the releases of the series have all been single storage medium technologies with the largest capacity they could grant. Basically it's far more Nostalgic to see Square push a final fantasy to require a BD disc then to see them squander time and effort on a multi disc DVD package and have them take you for a wild ride through their incredibly crafted worlds. #notebookdump
11/14/09
What's worse is all these X360 fanboys trying to justify an inconvenience with things like "nostalgia". It's sad really, border line buyers remorse. #notebookdump
11/14/09
11/14/09
I may remember and appreciate different things about the series to you, but that doesn't make me 'less of a fan' of it or whatnot. Just one with different preferences to you. These are called opinions, and not everyone shares the same ones. #notebookdump
11/14/09
11/14/09
As far as X360 owners crying or not. I don't care I'll be playing my copy of FFXIII on my PS3 and not on my X360, mostly because I'd like to finish the game without having to worry about RRoD. Which btw my system did this past week playing Gears of War 2 with a friend of mine. If I want them to cry over anything it would be that, not disc swapping.
However I also hate it when people come up with stupid reasons to justify their dissatisfying situation. Maybe it stems from some sort of frustration when I was a child or maybe I just encounter allot of really stupid people in my life. When it comes down to it, pretending like Disc Swapping is a non-issue is a bit retarded.
By saying you're ok with it, you're opening the doors for future systems to do the same. You're opening the door by saying "hey it's ok to give me something that would train wreck my experience". Ya it's not a mortal wound to the game itself, but it certainly effects how the designers make their games and how the programmers approach development of the engine and how the scenario plans outline progression. The game changes because of the Hardware. #notebookdump
11/14/09
Not cool!!!
No peace-making in the console warz!!! #notebookdump
11/14/09
I can't speak for any of your "fanboys" but I just can't see how disc-swapping is a big deal.
It's even less relevant now that the game can be installed in its entirety onto the HDD! #notebookdump
11/14/09
Point!!!
When did having fun become a zero-sum game??? #notebookdump
11/14/09
Out of limitation can be born excellence. #notebookdump
11/15/09
And I wasn't being elitist... I just think it's funny that you could have nostalgia for something so far along in the series that only lasted 3 games (out of the FF series, anyhow), though I suppose there's some nostalgia for me with those games (if not for disc switching), too. When I finally got the PS1, it was a turning point in my gaming. It also introduced many new annoyances. Loading times and disc changing the biggest of them.
I also think that there are so many people who started in the PS1 era, it's a bit strange for those of us who started with the 2600. Of course, with a very small number of exceptions, I wouldn't mind forgetting the 2600 existed.
On an entirely different topic, I remember someone asking me "If you're (26 at the time, 27 now) how can you have started with the 2600? It was out before you were born!"
Just like I've never seen Star Wars or I Love Lucy because they were out before I was born.
Entirely off topic, I know... Talking about the 2600 reminded me of how someone had "gotten" me with their impenetrable logic of catching me in a lie. #notebookdump
11/15/09
And similarly, I've played all the main series FFs despite them being before my time. I'll admit, I'm one of those terrible worthless human beings whose first FF was 7. But that was an age thing, and not exactly a deliberate choice. So yeah, there're lots of things I get nostalgic about from that age - disc-swapping is among the most minor. It's just, apparently disc-swapping was the one I wasn't allowed. #notebookdump
11/13/09
I'd really like to see the interview on FOXnews as well. #notebookdump
11/13/09
11/14/09
11/13/09
11/14/09
11/13/09
It's nice to know that this stuff can be explained by people who don't come off as pretentious industry figureheads. Nobody would listen to their explanations. #notebookdump
11/13/09
11/13/09
I don't know how it works and it angers me that it promotes people just because I replied to them :[ #notebookdump
11/13/09
11/13/09
11/13/09
11/13/09
11/13/09
11/14/09
11/13/09
11/13/09
And yeah it is funny! But you look like your enjoying yourself too much. ITS TOO MUCH.
11/13/09
I'd like to add my super-cool-dude double thumbs-up to that. And also formally select Totilo for the 'best video games guy talking about video games somewhere else where they don't know much about video games' award. #notebookdump
11/13/09
11/13/09
Thats also awesome the way you always reply in comments and when you review a game too answering questions. #notebookdump
11/13/09
If gaming were a ship, I'd strap you naked to the prow as our glorious figure-head, parting the waves of ignorance with eloquence and intriguing debate. And sexiness. #notebookdump
11/13/09
Can I take this moment to say something?
Stephen- I was very skeptical of Kotaku hiring you before you came on board. See, I'm an old school Kotaku fan- reading for years, only recently posting- and didn't want any "new blood" coming along and changing things.
I can honestly say, that you have become my favorite of the journalists [sorry Bashcroft :( ] It's nothing against anyone else, but it's all about how well you write, the thoughtful and interesting stories you come up with, and the willingness to do things that haven't been done before around here. The "Nintendo asks Sony asks MS" things was brilliant.
Enough ass kissing, I'm just very happy to see you a part of this family and I hope you stay around for a long time
Ps- Brians: I still love you #notebookdump
11/13/09
11/13/09
...Although I did get promoted once by Crecente (squealed like a little girl, I did!). #notebookdump
11/14/09
11/13/09
11/06/09
11/06/09
11/06/09
I like Bioware games as much as the next guy but "high quality" really isn't a word I'd use to describe them. #notebookdump
11/06/09
Yes, they may address the bugs in their future games, but not to the degree where lower scores of the current games would pressure them to achieve. #notebookdump
11/06/09
11/06/09
It must have been patched well enough by then however. I don't remember the game having any bugs really.
Since I don't have any first hand experience with their bugs, I assumed the complaints above, as well as the reviews, were reliable.
Either way, I'm still definitely purchasing Dragon Age over winter break, and ME2 the day it comes out. #notebookdump
11/06/09
11/06/09
There are numerical reviews on Metacritic that score the game from 90-100. Perhaps the bugs aren't that distracting then, but one of the reviewers did give the game a slightly brutal review and a score of 60.
I have yet to experience the game myself. It was actually Kotaku's review of the PS3 version vs the PC version that convinced me to hold off on the game until I have more free time. #notebookdump