• Kotaku
  • io9
  • gizmodo
  • Profile logout login

#newsupermariobroswii#1div

Kotaku

Share Cancel
   
Upload an image | Add an image URL
×

logging in
  • FAQ. Include # before tag:
  • #speakout,
  • #walkthroughs,
  • #screens,
  • #tips,
  • etc.

Denver, 9:47 PM
Tue Nov 24
55 posts in the last 24 hours

AU

KotakuTeam

Tip us:

Editor-In-Chief:
Brian Crecente
| AIM | Twitter

Deputy Editor:
Stephen Totilo
| AIM | Twitter

Senior Editor:
Michael McWhertor
| AIM | Twitter

Senior Contributing Editor, Japan:
Brian Ashcraft
| AIM | Twitter

Contributing Editor, East Coast:
Michael Fahey
| AIM | Twitter

Contributing Editor, Oceania:
Luke Plunkett
| AIM | Twitter

Contributing Editor, Weekends:
Owen Good
| AIM | Twitter

Correspondent, San Francisco:
AJ Glasser
| AIM | Twitter

Columnist:
Leigh Alexander

Columnist:
Tim Rogers

SUBSCRIBE TO Kotaku RSS

New: Breaking news and daily top stories via email
4149 Subscribers
Kotaku
  • Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.
    Dsmvwl  Admin  Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×
    Image of anabbeynormality anabbeynormality
    03:50 PM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    I can't remember the last time playing a game was a gleeful as NSMBW. It's not perfect, but the chaos with everybody talking is part of what makes it so fun. If you're the type of person the has to win or else you're not having fun, well then it's not a good game for you. But if you can shrug off a cheap death and laugh at the antics of your friends, then this game is as close to perfect as I've played.

    I probably would give it a 38 or 39 out of 40, but you have to factor in how they do their scores. It's not one person giving it a score out of 40, it's 4 people giving it a score out of 10. Personally, if I'm at a 9.5, but I have to pick a 9 or 10, then I would pick 10 for this because it's a unique experience. Look how many 9's they give. It seems like for them, a 10 is basically saying, this is something special. So, basically a 40 doesn't mean perfect, it means that all 4 reviewers agree that it deserves special recognition.
     Reply
    Edited by anabbeynormality at 11/24/09 3:50 PM anabbeynormality was starred anabbeynormality was unstarred
    Image of 天 天
    03:23 PM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    Famitsu is known for being stingy with the 10/10 ratings but I can't understand all the rage about the recent dramatic increase in awarding games that score. I always figured that 10/10 didn't mean perfect - it meant masterpiece, triumph, or something along those lines. Maybe the reviewers at Famitsu feel that there have been more masterful games released in recent times. It's just their opinion - you don't have to agree with it, but your disagreement doesn't automatically mean that Famitsu's review scores are invalid/sold for ad space.
     Reply
    天 was starred 天 was unstarred
    Image of UltimatePancakeSensation UltimatePancakeSensation
    03:46 PM

    @天: There was a time when regardless of your taste in games, you could look at every game on Famitsu's perfect list and, even if the game wasn't your cup of tea, see the merit. Those days are long gone.
     Reply
    UltimatePancakeSensation was starred UltimatePancakeSensation was unstarred
    Image of 天 天
    09:12 PM

    @UltimatePancakeSensation: Looking up at the list in the post above, I can see merit in the games listed there that I've played (the first 10 on the list). Even though I didn't like FFXII very much I can still appreciate the good design of the game.
     Reply
    天 was starred 天 was unstarred
    Image of excel_excel excel_excel
    02:27 PM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    I absolutly love the game. Can't honestly believe how good it is, I'd give it 10/10. Purely based on the level design and fun factor alone.

    But Famitsu have always been selective with their 10/10's. Brawl and MGS4 getting perfect scores from 4 different reviewers? Not a chance
     Reply
    excel_excel was starred excel_excel was unstarred
    Image of UltimatePancakeSensation UltimatePancakeSensation
    02:22 PM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    I remember when a Famitsu perfect really meant something. Nowadays they just seem to give them away to the occasional big title.

    I've played this game, and it is far from perfect.
     Reply
    UltimatePancakeSensation was starred UltimatePancakeSensation was unstarred
    Image of Bubbleman! Bubbleman!
    02:29 PM

    @UltimatePancakeSensation: I think I actually agree with Famitsu this time. For a 2D Platformer, NSMB Wii is at the very top. It's the most-polished game of its kind, by far.
     Reply
    天 promoted this comment Bubbleman! was starred Bubbleman! was unstarred
    Image of UltimatePancakeSensation UltimatePancakeSensation
    03:35 PM

    @Bubbleman!: I don't think you've played it in a family multiplayer setting, then.
     Reply
    UltimatePancakeSensation was starred UltimatePancakeSensation was unstarred
    Image of shimage shimage
    11:54 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    PokéPark? Really? Sorry, was that off topic? It's in the picture ...
     Reply
    shimage was starred shimage was unstarred
    Image of Demonbird Demonbird
    08:06 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    Of course they did, because it is a good game.

    I would have taken off some points for the unnecessary motion controls, though.
     Reply
    Demonbird was starred Demonbird was unstarred
    Image of Slagathorian Slagathorian
    09:13 AM

    @Demonbird: But perfect? Hardly.
     Reply
    Demonbird promoted this comment Slagathorian was starred Slagathorian was unstarred
    Image of Demonbird Demonbird
    09:38 AM

    @Slagathorian:
    Agreed. It is a good game, but not deserving of a perfect score. By far.

    #speakup
     Reply
    Demonbird was starred Demonbird was unstarred
    Image of Blore07 Blore07
    06:52 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    I'm really enjoying NSMBW, but I cant think of one memorable level to be honest.
    Its great fun with your mates, it certainly doesnt lack in good platforming level design, its just very safe, throwing things i've seen/played a hundred times before.

    Still, it got my girlfriend to fire up her wii for the first time in months, so its all good by my books.
     Reply
    Blore07 was starred Blore07 was unstarred
    Image of AncientUnknown1 AncientUnknown1
    06:36 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    Dave Halverson must have taken over Famitsu recently.
     Reply
    AncientUnknown1 was starred AncientUnknown1 was unstarred
    Image of Strife Fox † Strife Fox †
    05:48 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    Hahaha what, I can't believe they've given some of these games perfect scroes, yet landed Ucharted 2 with a 37/40, just wow... Don't get me wrong, I like the New Super Mario Bros. Wii, but it's nothing new, Mario Galaxy was FAR more deserving of that score.

    But I guess they're probably quite bias towards Western games, or don't even count them at all due to cultural differences in opinions of "what's cool".
     Reply
    Strife Fox † was starred Strife Fox † was unstarred
    Image of rich8606 rich8606
    02:59 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    Eh... I don;t care much for numbers, what did they say about the game? no cons at all?
     Reply
    rich8606 was starred rich8606 was unstarred
    Image of The Whaleman The Whaleman
    06:07 AM

    @rich8606: No cons at all, besides that half the staff now are divorced after trying to play the game with their spouses.
     Reply
    The Whaleman was starred The Whaleman was unstarred
    Image of Orionsaint Orionsaint
    02:21 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    I didn't know Famitsu used the same review system from EGM. Who stole it from who though? EGM had been
    around since 89. They didn't start using the 4 person rating system till like 92 though. Famitsu been around since 86, but since I never looked at an issue of Famitsu. I wouldn't know.
     Reply
    Edited by Orionsaint at 11/24/09 2:23 AM Orionsaint was starred Orionsaint was unstarred
    Image of NeVeRMoRe666 NeVeRMoRe666
    02:18 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    I think the people bemoaning the fact that Famitsu gave it a 40/40 score is missing the point. What is impressive here is that four individual reviewers, independent of any of the others, thought highly enough of the game to give it their highest recommendation 10/10. How often in life do you have such universal agreement on anything? (4 out of 5 dentists recommend....) or any of your friends all agreeing on heading to the same restaurant? Almost never. The fact that four of them came to the same conclusion should be enough for anyone to realize that they have to play this game. 40/40 be damned, the point is, this is a great review of a great game.
     Reply
    NeVeRMoRe666 was starred NeVeRMoRe666 was unstarred
    Image of Zero1328 Zero1328
    02:36 AM

    @NeVeRMoRe666: Actually, I think you're the one that's missed part of the point. I think no one can really deny that the new Super Mario deserves the perfect score, but the problem is that it's also part of a list that's now starting to appear to grow unusually quickly.

    Just look at the dates on the list. Half of them are now from either 2008 or '09. Famitsu's 40/40 was actually revered, for the reasons you argue. And look at it now. Maybe it's a sign of the times, I don't know. Maybe they really, truly deserve that score. Maybe they don't. Either way, it's starting to feel diluted.
     Reply
    NeVeRMoRe666 promoted this comment Zero1328 was starred Zero1328 was unstarred
    Image of NeVeRMoRe666 NeVeRMoRe666
    02:50 AM

    @Zero1328: In a way, I can see your point. But I think people who worry about such things (no offense meant obviously) miss the point of the reviews. Does it really matter if it gets diluted? Should they be withholding perfect scores to inflate their own notoriety? If every reviewer gave it a 9, the game would have received a 36/40, a mark I don't think it deserved. Yet, what is amazing about any of the games is that 4 reviewers did find it worthwhile enough to give it a ten, regardless of whether it adds up to 40 or not and subseqnetly makes the list we are so hotly debating over.

    The point I'm trying to get at here is that the minor point gradients between perfect and very good don't matter in the grand scheme of things. A good score denotes a good game. The "perfect score" debate is relevant. What matters is that, from the reviews, we know we should be playing these games instead of talking about them or where they score.

    #speakup
     Reply
    NeVeRMoRe666 was starred NeVeRMoRe666 was unstarred
    Image of Zero1328 Zero1328
    03:46 AM

    @NeVeRMoRe666: I understand what you're saying, and I agree with the whole grand scheme of things, idea. I'm not really akin to the whole numbering thing, myself, but the thing is, the point of these discussions is that it's specifically about those minor details, and what those minor differences can mean. Yes, "good" is "good." You can't argue that. But what does "good" mean, now? How did it become, "good"? What leads it there?

    A 40/40 is interpreted as beyond "good". Perfection. So what does "perfection" mean, now? You say it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things. What's the difference between a gold and silver medal? A few milliseconds? Who cares? It doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things.

    Apparently, many people care. They like seeing those minute differences, because that's what perfection means. The increasing frequency of these "gold medals" really dilutes what "perfection" can mean to a person. Maybe not to you and me, but certainly to some people out there, and that's what I meant.

    Lately, there's been accusations of reviewer bias, not limited to just Famitsu. Maybe they're becoming more frequent. I'm not sure. Regardless, the scores are an example of how times are changing, for games. Are more games actually becoming better, or is the curve beginning to flatten, with "good" and "perfection" becoming more blurry? I don't know. I'm not sure if anyone does.

    #speakup
     Reply
    Zero1328 was starred Zero1328 was unstarred
    Image of Scorpi Scorpi
    02:14 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    Actually, they gave the PS3 version a 38.
     Reply
    Scorpi was starred Scorpi was unstarred
    Image of azr azr
    03:20 AM

    @Scorpi: Who are you talking too?
     Reply
    azr was starred azr was unstarred
    Image of daknight daknight
    03:52 AM

    @azr: Bayonetta. The 360 version got the perfect score, but the PS3 had two points less than it, making it a 38/40 game.
     Reply
    Scorpi promoted this comment daknight was starred daknight was unstarred
    Image of Scorpi Scorpi
    06:21 AM

    @daknight: Thanks for the backup, Daknight
     Reply
    Scorpi was starred Scorpi was unstarred
    Image of Atomsk88 Atomsk88
    02:00 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    OH WAIT. Final Fantasy XIII comes out this year in Japan — whatever will Famitsu do?

    They're gonna be rebels and give it a 39. That one lone point will cause the greatest nerd rage. It will be to the point that even the mountains will quake and the oceans will be at the mercy of the salty tears that will flow from the cheeks of otaku everywhere. Even the deaf will hear the roar "Fam... itsuuuuu?!"
     Reply
    Atomsk88 was starred Atomsk88 was unstarred
    Image of Avinash_Tyagi Avinash_Tyagi
    02:13 AM

    @Atomsk88:

    Sounds far better than that crap 2012 movie
     Reply
    Showmeyomoves! promoted this comment Avinash_Tyagi was starred Avinash_Tyagi was unstarred
    Image of Showmeyomoves! Showmeyomoves!
    06:10 AM

    @Avinash_Tyagi: Hey, that movie received a perfect 40/40 from Famitsu. Show some respect.
     Reply
    Showmeyomoves! was starred Showmeyomoves! was unstarred
    Image of Benguin Benguin
    02:00 AM

    In reply to Famitsu Awards New Super Mario Bros. Wii A Perfect Score
    I'm going to have to actually play it before I can make a solid judgment, but I have yet to really be impressed with this game. It seems very much like NSMB for the DS which personally was a let-down. I enjoyed it, but something about it didn't seem right. It was definitely no Super Mario World.
     Reply
    Benguin was starred Benguin was unstarred
    Image of dowingba dowingba
    02:34 AM

    @Benguin: You have yet to be impressed with a game you haven't played.

    Just play it. Yeesh.
     Reply
    dowingba was starred dowingba was unstarred
    Image of Benguin Benguin
    02:54 AM

    @dowingba: I think that's an entirely reasonable position to hold. I'm not denouncing the game in any way yet, just saying that none of the videos I've watched have really piqued my interest. So far the only reason I DO want to play it is because "it's Mario."

    I'll definitely try it out, but I'm not in any real rush. And when I do if it turns out to be way more awesome than I expected, then I'll be very happy. Otherwise oh well.
     Reply
    Benguin was starred Benguin was unstarred
    Image of DLNO-001 DLNO-001
    12:53 PM

    @Benguin: I'm sorry, It seems you're using your brain and common sense.
    didn't you see the "you must be this stupid to post" sign?

    now, seriously, you said it the simplest way possible: - the only reason I DO want to play it is because "it's Mario." -
     Reply
    Benguin promoted this comment DLNO-001 was starred DLNO-001 was unstarred
    Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

Login

Enter your username and password.

Please enter a username.
Please enter your password.
logging in
Login via Facebook | Sign Up | Forgot Password?

Reset Password

Please enter your email address to have your password reset.

Please enter your email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
requesting password reset

Register

Registering will give you a user profile and the ability to add other users as friends. To become a commenter, however, you need to audition.

Want to know more? Consult the Comment FAQ and legal terms.

Please enter a username.
Please enter a password.
Please confirm your password.
Passwords are not identical.
Please enter a valid email address.
registration sent, waiting for reply

Submit Your Comment

You don't need to login to comment. Just enter your email address below.

See how your address will be displayed in the Comment FAQ.

Please enter a valid email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
logging in

Login with your Facebook or Kotaku account.

Sign up here.



  • Archives
  • About
  • Advertising
  • Legal
  • Help
  • Report a Bug
  • FAQ
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.