Kotaku 
Enter your username and password.
Denver, 1:05 PM
Mon Nov 16
36 posts in the last 24 hours
Tip us: tips@kotaku.com
Editor-In-Chief:
Brian Crecente
Email | AIM | Twitter
Deputy Editor:
Stephen Totilo
Email | AIM | Twitter
Senior Editor:
Michael McWhertor
Email | AIM | Twitter
Senior Contributing Editor, Japan:
Brian Ashcraft
Email | AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, East Coast:
Michael Fahey
Email | AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, Oceania:
Luke Plunkett
Email | AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, Weekends:
Owen Good
Email | AIM | Twitter
Correspondent, San Francisco:
AJ Glasser
Email | AIM | Twitter
Columnist:
Leigh Alexander
Columnist:
Tim Rogers
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.
10/12/09
Is it really that different in real life in this day and age?
10/12/09
10/12/09
10/12/09
The weekend romance bit in that game is amusing really.
10/12/09
10/12/09
I love how it plays different music (Barrett's theme) instead of the romantic, slower music when you're on the date with Aeris or Tifa.
10/12/09
And now, WHEN they remake it, I won't be able to do the Tifa or Barrett one either, as I will need to see the touching Aerith one in HD.
Fuck you FF VII, for helping raise me as a wee lad and making me so attached to you.
10/12/09
I never was nice to Aeris....never liked her, I always liked the Barmaid with the hot rack :points to icon:.
Now if I made FFVII, I would just make it to a threeway because really, why choose? Just have them both.
10/12/09
LOL! I just want the game in HD 1080/30fps...that's all I want.
Oh, and I'll still, even after 12 years...will pick Tifa for my date.
10/12/09
It was Gray from Harvest Moon 64, but alas, he would not accept my blue feather.
10/12/09
10/12/09
10/12/09
10/12/09
09/11/09
They actually dock points from you if you kill the suspect after you interrogate/torture them...
WTF?
If anything you should be getting bonuses for burning people alive and decapitating them with windows!
09/11/09
09/11/09
I'd even go as far as to say that Jack Thompson's "murder simulators" accusation holds a little bit credence because playing tons of violent games will desensitize you to violence, and if the flow of a game regularly goes to torturing to get what you want, it will at least come to mind in such a situation in real life... his big failing is assuming that people will then go emulate it - that's a personal moral decision that's separate from inflicting it on avatars and NPCs, and the responsibility is entirely that of the person doing it.
Also... in Punisher you can CHROME A GUY'S HEAD... that doesn't even work in reality - it's cartoon torture and in my opinion, hilariously over the top. I think the presentation makes a big difference about what is disturbing or unacceptable.
09/11/09
2nd, "..accusation holds a little bit credence because playing tons of violent games will desensitize you to violence"
It does, but only to more fake videogame/movie violence.
The real thing is to much for most people that try to act "internet hardcore."
Which is part of why I won't work in hospitals anymore...the real thing sticks with you...
09/11/09
09/11/09
Force Unleashed (may God curse its name forever more), is a good example. I had great fun hovering stormtroopers over great chasms whilst they writhed in my force grip, only to zap them with lightning, flip them high into the air, and watch them plummet to their doom.
Prototype, as well. I'm not as bloodthirsty in it as my flatmate (quite disturbing from a guy who's generally quite peaceful and is also vegetarian), and in fact I usually do my best to avoid civilian casualties, but there's something perversely amusing about grabbing a bystander and running up every tall building you can whilst they writhe deseperately in your grip, before flinging them off into the distance.
...Then again, maybe I have issues. But, on a serious note, would anyone else consider these actions to be torture? Really, they are. The player is causing lengthy stress and pain to the characters. Is that 'okay', whereas doing it in a scripted scene or event isn't? Or would those decrying these torture scenes never do such a thing in a video game?
09/11/09
09/11/09
It's 2009. It's gone past the stage where games are merely a categorically fun experience. There are many other artistic avenues to be explored, and there is no reason why playing a game shouldn't make you intensely uncomfortable in certain circumstances.
If a game puts me in the shoes of a torturer, and makes an intelligent point whilst doing so, then I am all for it. If it throws in gratuitous torture scenes for no reason, that's a different matter.
09/11/09
09/11/09
09/11/09
Hence we have extraordinary rendition, and men like the Birmingham Six can spend 16 years of their lives in prison for crimes they didn't commit.
09/10/09
The use of torture in Brink seems to be like this. "Surprise, we're deeper and more thoughtful than you expected!" Nah. Just a cheap move.
We'll see how the full game handles it.
09/10/09
09/11/09
The Geneva Convention defines torture along the lines of any act which causes "extreme physical or mental anguish".
The problem is when you start trying to draw the line at SOME pain being acceptable. For instance, you claim that tasing isn't torture because it's not as bad as smashing someone's toes with a hammer. I grant you that smashing someone's toes is worse than tasing, but that doesn't mean tasing someone to gain information isn't torture.
Frankly, to address your statement and answer AJ's implicit question in one fell swoop I will say this: any use of physical or mental pain to gain information is torture, plain and simple.
When you start trying to allow some things you end up with the "rule" that existed in most iraqi interrogation camps which was "No Blood, No Foul." In other words they drew a line at a place they deemed reasonable. Unfortunately they could commit horrible acts, such as extreme sleep deprivation, which sounds relatively benign until you hear descriptions of it, without drawing blood. If I had to choose between having my toes smashed or putting up with literally weeks of what some of those detainees had to go through.... well I just might take the hammer.
09/11/09
Inflicting any degree of pain or stress (mental or physical) on a person, particularly for any length of time, particularly to meet some agenda, is torture, plain and simple. I don't think there should ever really be a discussion as to what 'counts' as torture.
A discussion about whether or not it's 'okay'? Sure. Though I don't think it's ever really 'okay'. Useful? That's debatable, too.