GameStop Now Accepting Old Toys For Store Credit. Great. [Update]Mike Fahey9/23/14 11:30am895EditPromoteDismissUndismissHideGo to permalinkRemember back in 2012 when GameStop started allowing customers to trade in original Skylanders figures for store credit, and the customer service folk were completely miserable? Now GameStop is accepting Skylanders and Disney Infinity figures. Update: I traded some, check out what I got for them below.