colinsebastian

posts about #colinsebastian more →
Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
Analyzing the Analysts, Episode Two
Analyzing the Analysts, Episode One
Analyst: Initial Halo 3 Sales Should Hit $200 Million

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

Talleh
12/23/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
I'm looking forward to the day when every single obscure Nintedno character has their own game, not saying Peach is exact obscure, but it's sorta stretching it. It really is great to see Nintendo try something new, but does it have to always be something new tied to something old? Couldn't Wario Ware Shake It have done as well as it did(which...is I have no idea how well/poorly) if it were a new IP? Would it have done better? Worse?

Nintendo can throw the creative folks a bone and let them work outside their mascot-box, and make something that might fail, especially when they're raking in the cash and pumping out the units, they can divert some funds to new IP, and not just making new games with old IP. I mean really, look at metroid prime. How close is it REALLY to the old metroid? Throw in some aesthetic changes, change some story points, and it's basically 100% original from the side-scrolling counter parts.

Really though, when we're playing Wii Sports 6, because it's the only thing released for ten months, I can't help but think why Nintendo would bother with their tired old mascots, or making new ones, when mini-games and non-games might be their only future.
Reply

Talleh was starred Talleh was unstarred

Bernard McGraw
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
Well this time, I'm not going to get excited. I'm going to shut it out completely. Twilight Princess was my whole life ever since I saw the first trailer, and I'd built up a game in my head that just didn't compare to that. I finished in 48 hours over three days and just felt hollow. I can't love it.

Majora's Mask is still my favourite game in the world ever. Nothing since has made me feel those tingles.
Reply

Bernard McGraw was starred Bernard McGraw was unstarred

Demonbird
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
Any signs pointing to a new (good) 2d outing for the little red plumber?
Reply

Demonbird was starred Demonbird was unstarred

jandlecack
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
If Nintendo isn't dropping price, I won't be bothered and still not own a Wii.

I'm not paying Idiot price for GameCube hardware, sorry. Continue screwing over soccer mom's and casuals, not me, Nintendo.
Reply

jandlecack was starred jandlecack was unstarred

Theoutlet
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
Yay, I can't wait to play OOT: Part four.

Oh wait, yes I can.
Reply

Theoutlet was starred Theoutlet was unstarred

Pwnocchio
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
Hopefully they do something more interesting with the gameplay this time around. While the art design was great in Twilight Princess, the gameplay was just too similar to the past couple of games. I feel like most major AAA titles would get panned for not improving on the formula, but Zelda games are largely forgiven for it.
Reply

Pwnocchio was starred Pwnocchio was unstarred

Ueziel
12/22/08

@Pwnocchio: That would be because the base gameplay is still unbelievably good. You don't bash games just because they didn't improve upon something the series pretty much created and perfected.
Reply

Ueziel was starred Ueziel was unstarred

Pwnocchio
12/22/08

@Ueziel:

See, I find the base gameplay to be unbelievably stale. It's the same game repackaged for the last 10 years. If you haven't adapted your gameplay at all since the Nintendo 64 days, then I think something about it should change.
Reply

Pwnocchio was starred Pwnocchio was unstarred

TRT-X
12/22/08

@Pwnocchio: The problem is when a game company does that (see Rare and Banjo Kazooie) ultimately they rip out what made the game fun in the first place.

They could change things up by modifying the setting (perhaps go futuristic for a game or two)
Reply

TRT-X was starred TRT-X was unstarred

maniacmayhem
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
The last really good Zelda game was for the Super Nintendo.

Twilight Princess was nothing more than This Dog's Life.

Nintendy needs to get back to basics with this franchise, no fairies, no dogs, no fishing!
Reply

maniacmayhem was starred maniacmayhem was unstarred

Đipic
12/22/08

@maniacmayhem: You kidding? Don't get me wrong, A Link to the Past is still one of my all time favorite games but Ocarina and Majora's Mask were excellent and frankly I enjoyed Wind Waker slighty more than those too. (not to mention the excellent gameboy games) Twilight Princess on the other hand... meh.
Reply

Đipic was starred Đipic was unstarred

LllusionX Mailed the Fission
12/22/08

@maniacmayhem: werent there also fairies in all the other zelda games?
Reply

Dragonis
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
For the record I call it.

1)Idyllic youth

2)Tragedy

3)You are the hero

4)Three dungeons

5)Plot twist

6)Around 8 more dungeons

7)Final showdown

As much as I love the series, I think they've used that formula enough. I want something unique.

Then again, I'll buy it and I'll love it all the same.
Reply

Dragonis was starred Dragonis was unstarred

SketchyIndividual
12/22/08

@Dragonis: Exactly what I'm trying to say, it's the same story for every Zelda game. Once, just once, I'd like to see them do something original or innovative with the Zelda franchise.

Or, rather, Nintendo just stop dragging the well-used corpses of their old franchises around like puppets and make something new.
Reply

SketchyIndividual was starred

Theoutlet
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual: I, once again, agree.

It's nice to know I'm not alone in this.
Reply

Theoutlet was starred Theoutlet was unstarred

Ueziel
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual: We had that. It was called Majora's Mask. And Minish Cap. And both Oracle games. And Four Swords. None of those use Ganon as an enemy and none of them had even close to the same story.
Reply

Ueziel was starred Ueziel was unstarred

SketchyIndividual
12/22/08

@Ueziel: Minish Cap I'll give you (even though I found myself getting bored more often then not), but Majora's Mask was just a sequel (a painfully short and easy one at that) and still laid Link in Hyrule trying to save the day while putting on different outfits to suit a different situation (I.E. like every game after OoT).

Four Swords was a terrible attempt, and again you're in Hyrule trying to save the etc, etc.

It's all still the same story with slightly different specifics.
Reply

SketchyIndividual was starred

TRT-X
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual: Sorry...but where in Wind Waker did you use different costumes? And I can't recall where that was in Minish Cap or Phantom Hourglass either.

Unless you're considering Twilight Princess to be "Everything after Ocarina".
Reply

TRT-X was starred TRT-X was unstarred

Leobebes
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
Anyone remember growing up and dying in anticipation to see what the new Zelda is going to look on Nintendo's new hardware every console cycle?

Well its gone now.
Reply

Leobebes was starred Leobebes was unstarred

Ueziel
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual: We had that. It was called Majora's Mask. And Minish Cap. And both Oracle games. And Four Swords. None of those use Ganon as an enemy and none of them had even close to the same story.
Reply

Ueziel was starred Ueziel was unstarred

Ueziel
12/22/08

@Ueziel: What the hell? It put the comment in the wrong place haha.
Reply

Ueziel was starred Ueziel was unstarred

Bialia
12/22/08

@Ueziel: LMAO. I was wondering what your point was.
Reply

Bialia was starred Bialia was unstarred

CatboyMac's angry girlfriend
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
Fucking finally.

Wait, didn't the last one just come out? It feels like it's been so long.
Reply

ph15h
12/22/08

@CatboyMac: Three years is a long time when the gaming industries shove sequels out yearly.
Reply

ph15h was starred ph15h was unstarred

moehannes
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
Gypsy fortune tellers...What do they know eh?
Reply

moehannes was starred moehannes was unstarred

Bialia
12/22/08

@moehannes: It's a secret to everybody.
Reply

Bialia was starred Bialia was unstarred

SketchyIndividual
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
Am I the only one who'd like to see the Zelda series put to rest with what dignity it has left? Maybe look to Nintendo for some good new game ideas?

I am? Well damn it.
Reply

SketchyIndividual was starred

Shinta
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual: Yeah, I think you are lol. Twilight Princess was absolutely incredible. It's basically impossible to say a game is better than Ocarina of Time but that game came about as close as possible to beating it.
Reply

Shinta was starred Shinta was unstarred

SketchyIndividual
12/22/08

@Shinta: I didn't think it was that great, it was more-or-less the same exact concept and story as every Zelda game since OoT. I mean, I get nostalgia and all but there comes a point where you either let the series rest in peace, or you innovate it.

Twilight Princess did neither for me, and best-case scenario with the next one is that they won't make it too casual.
Reply

SketchyIndividual was starred

FrigidAir44
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual: Not really. I see the Zelda games and see their quality in design. They are all excellent platform puzzle games.

But they have been done to death. The games aren't really all that different and feel somewhat uninspired (besides Wind Waker for the art style alone).

Put the games to bed? No, please don't. I would like to see more time between releases so the designers can wait a while to really make something special.
Reply

FrigidAir44 was starred FrigidAir44 was unstarred

dae_giovanni
12/22/08

I don't think the series needs to be put to bed, but I would like to see some fresh ideas.

Link in a setting other than Hyrule, perhaps? Have no clue how that would work, but...
Reply

dae_giovanni was starred dae_giovanni was unstarred

Theoutlet
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual: I'm with you.

This and many other series are long overdue, but Nintendo and their loyalists are too afraid of change to try anything new.
Reply

Theoutlet was starred Theoutlet was unstarred

SketchyIndividual
12/22/08

@dae_giovanni: @FrigidAir44: You've both kind of said exactly why I think they need to just let the Zelda series go. The way it's done and the formula used doesn't allow for the game to change or evolve much at all, rather it gives you just enough space to add a new character or two and then you continue with the same exact game.

If you were to, say, take Link out of Hyrule and not involve the same tired story with Princess Zelda then you don't have a Legend of Zelda game, you have a Legend of Link game.

I'm all for continuing on with Link as the hero in some other world with a new setting, story, and driving force for his heroism, but if that happened you're still putting Legend of Zelda to it's much-deserved sleep.
Reply

SketchyIndividual was starred

Paradox me
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual:

I actually agree. Although I'm aware that many people still enjoy the games and ending it for those who don't is silly.

It's a fact that the men and women behind Zelda can make a damn good game, but honestly the whole idea of Zelda is growing a bit tiring. The same goes for a couple of Nintendo's other key franchises.

Take these talented developers and make them work on new games. New characters, new settings, new stories, new EVERYTHING- something that isn't tied down to the Zelda universe. If they're worried about losing the draw of the Zelda name, throw a sticker on the box "From the creators of Zelda!" or something, anything- just give gamers something fresh.

Nintendo is doing well this generation and it's frustrating for me seeing them sticking to the same old stuff when they have so much room to branch out and really wow gamers, be it casual or hardcore.
Reply

Paradox me was starred Paradox me was unstarred

Đipic
12/22/08

@dae_giovanni: Have you not played Majora's mask? Or Link's Awakening or Oracle of Seasons/Ages? None of those took place in Hyrule.

I think Twilight Princess was entirely too much like it's predecessor's (most specifically Ocarina). I think the devs saw how much everyone loved that game and tried to make TP a bigger, better version of that. I think they suceeded but left a stale taste in their fans mouths for the most part (at least the ones who grew up playing all the games in the series). Let's hope the next installment goes in a similar direction that Majora's Mask did (as in, something different from the whole Ganon/Hyrule/Zelda/Trifore spheel.)
Reply

Đipic was starred Đipic was unstarred

Đipic
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual, @Hey_guy: The thing you've got to remember is that some people will never get tired of the games because they will always appeal to another, younger generation of gamers who've never played a Zelda (or at least the earlier ones).
Reply

Đipic was starred Đipic was unstarred

Đipic
12/22/08

@Đipic: Which, even if I don't enjoy them enough to purchase and play them anymore I'm glad a new generation of gamers who won't go back and play the older games get to experience Zelda.

(sorry, hit submit too soon)
Reply

Đipic was starred Đipic was unstarred

SketchyIndividual
12/22/08

@Đipic: Did you really just try to pull the "Majora's Mask wasn't in Hyrule" card? Really? Yes, it's an "alternate version" of Hyrule, but it's still bloody Hyrule with different names. Seriously my friend, as you play that game you can give the proper Hyrulian names to everything you see, because they took the same layout and renamed it.

Yes, Ganon wasn't used, but again it's just the same concept with a different wrapper. The details change, the general ideas are exactly the same (Four Swords was different yes, but more people just tolerated it then actually enjoyed it).

As I've said, and as you've done nothing to disprove, it's the same exact story and concept with different details.
Reply

SketchyIndividual was starred

Ueziel
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual: Haha what? Who "tolerated" Four Swords? Every person I've ever said that has EVER played the game four player has said that it's one of the best multiplayer experiences you could ever have in gaming. It's unbelievably fun.

It ISN'T the same exact story and I really wish you'd quit saying that. The fact that the details are different makes it a different story! That's exactly how stories are differentiated!
Reply

Ueziel was starred Ueziel was unstarred

Đipic
12/22/08

@SketchyIndividual: It's been a long time since I've played both OoT and MM but I'm pretty sure it's a completely different land. Are you saying the geography is the same? I mean, what specifically is the same but with "just a different name"? How was Majora similar to Ganon? What was the impendent doom of the land by the moon similar to? Or the timeline? Where were the Triforces? The ability to transform into a different race? Where was Zelda's doppleganger? Or Epona? Of course it was similar but I fail to see how it was the same story in a different wrapper.
Reply

Đipic was starred Đipic was unstarred

Đipic
12/22/08

@Ueziel: Also what he said. You could use that logic for just about every movie, game, novel, etc. created in modern history.
Reply

Đipic was starred Đipic was unstarred

zerzhul
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
I really enjoyed Twilight Princess, despite the wanky sword waggling. If they are developing strictly for the Wii, I have faith that they might get the control scheme down a little better (although probably not much).

This will most likely be my next purchase for the Wii (the most recent being metroid prime 3).
Reply

zerzhul was starred zerzhul was unstarred

TRT-X
12/22/08

@zerzhul: They will likely release this only AFTER they've released WiiMotion Plus. So while they'll tighten the controls, it'll likely utilize the attachment to really get that perfect experience.
Reply

TRT-X was starred TRT-X was unstarred

Shinta
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
They should put it on the Gamecube too. I don't want to get a Wii.
Reply

Shinta was starred Shinta was unstarred

TRT-X
12/22/08

@Shinta: Sony should put GoW III on the PS2 for this same reason. And also, Halo 3 should've been on Xbox...
Reply

TRT-X was starred TRT-X was unstarred

PhillyRedsox
12/22/08

@TRT-X: Actually Halo 3 Should have been in the trash can. That game blows. It has been the same shit for three games and people are stupid enough to buy it 3 times. The only thing that changed was the coat of paint.
Reply

PhillyRedsox was starred PhillyRedsox was unstarred

TRT-X
12/22/08

@PhillyRedsox: Uh...not what I was going for, but uh...thanks?
Reply

TRT-X was starred TRT-X was unstarred

shaunmcilroy
12/23/08

@PhillyRedsox: I bet your interior designer is always stressed in that case
Reply

shaunmcilroy was starred shaunmcilroy was unstarred

TRT-X
12/22/08

In reply to Another Analyst Dates Next Zelda For 2009
Phantom Hourglass was a sequel to Wind Waker. ;)
Reply

TRT-X was starred TRT-X was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion