Kotaku 
Enter your username and password.
Denver, 12:17 AM
Tue Dec 1
53 posts in the last 24 hours
Tip us:
Editor-In-Chief:
Brian Crecente
| AIM | Twitter
Deputy Editor:
Stephen Totilo
| AIM | Twitter
Senior Editor:
Michael McWhertor
| AIM | Twitter
Senior Contributing Editor, Japan:
Brian Ashcraft
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, East Coast:
Michael Fahey
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, Oceania:
Luke Plunkett
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, Weekends:
Owen Good
| AIM | Twitter
Correspondent, San Francisco:
AJ Glasser
| AIM | Twitter
Columnist:
Leigh Alexander
Columnist:
Tim Rogers
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.
03/07/09
03/07/09
03/07/09
Thanks CBC!
03/07/09
So many errors.
03/07/09
03/07/09
03/07/09
03/07/09
03/07/09
We were in the top 10 for around a month, getting paid and all, and I was NEVER addicted to the game. If I couldn't play a match cause I had to do my homework, there were always at least two people that were able to back me up. I didn't care if I missed an entire week due to school work.
I hate to say this, but Crisp was a total loser. If you get addicted to video games, you have no real friends. If all you can think about 24/7 is video games, you might as well just pack it in right there. To have your entire life revolve around you holding a white controller in your hands and sitting in a chair.... wow.
I love video games, but his entire story, and the way CBC chose to cover it, is full of fail. I never play video games in hopes to make a ton of money. Sure, it would be nice, but I play them to have fun, just like all other games.
03/07/09
03/07/09
03/07/09
Don't worry though, noone watches The Fifth Estate.
03/07/09
Never heard of the Fifth Estate before though. What the hell is the title about/mean/reference anyway?
03/07/09
03/07/09
It's extremely bothersome to know my tax dollars are going toward paying these idiots salaries and providing money to churn out biased sensationalist news propaganda.
And it's not even things like the Crisp story, the fifth estate and CBC in general have created some of the most asinine "reporting" I've ever seen. It's a damn shame.
03/07/09
I watched this piece in its entirety and there were 1 or 2 good points raised, but the entire premise was false.
One fundamental question that she didn't confront the parents on is why they didn't set parental controls on the 360, and why they bought that game for their son.
But to knock the Fifth Estate because of this one bad piece, is somewhat ignorant.
03/08/09
One of the most egregious examples was their Chris Benoit debacle from a couple years ago.
Sensationalism, slanted reporting and fallacious claims all coupled with leading questions to interviewees and non-creditable 'specialists' go toward my problem with the show and CBC.
Did you even bother to read my second to last sentence before spouting off? Here, for you reading pleasure again, "and it's not even things like the Crisp story, the fifth estate and CBC in general have created some of the most asinine "reporting" I've ever seen"
03/07/09
This is bullshit.
03/07/09
How about we take away all the fuckin' cell phones, huh? This is ridiculous. We should buy Cuba and turn it into a gamer country. Nothing would get done... So we'd have to build robots.
03/07/09
Thats fucked, and a completely good example of video games taking the blame for stupid shit, when really, its just *stupid shit*.
03/07/09
Other than occasionally reminding us that they'll give us all cancer (but then, what doesn't?) they ertainly don't want to start a crusade that will result in taking away something they enjoy.
Games are just the latest target in a long line of things teens like that get blamed for things parents don't like. Previous targets, such as comic books, rock and roll, rap, and music videos have all taken their lumps and then eventually became a de facto part of life for people of all ages. It wasn't so long ago that comic books were blamed for children causing mayhem, or that rap started Tipper Gore's "war" on music that resulted in the "Parental Advisory" sticker we now take for granted. Or, God forbid, the Beatles' long hair and Elvis's disgusting hip gyrations. These things are now all largely considered non-issues, except insofar as parents need to take an interest in their childrens' habits.
Video games, even though not new, are certianly more common, interactive, immersive and realistic, and are an easy target for a generation who did not grow up with them. As that generation slowly fades away, so too will the demonization of games and the onus of fault for societies ills.
As gamers, our responsibility is to be responsible individuals, and when necessary, offer reasonable and informed commentary on why games are simply a fun and harmless form of entertainment. Vote when needed to avoid having games become unfairly and needlessly regulated.
03/07/09
03/07/09
He climbed a tree. He fell out of the tree. He died from his injuries.
That has dick all to do with video games, sports, his parents, drugs, sex, pornography, kittens, double peppermint pizza flavoured cookie dough iced cream, or anything else.
He climbed a tree, fell and died.
Sure, he ran away and it was a direct result of him being pissed at his parents for taking away his Xbox. Professional 'gaming', addiction, etc. had nothing to truly do with it. He could have aspired to be a ping pong player and had his paddle taken away for the same reasons and the result would be the same.
Making it anymore than it is, a kid accidentally falling out of a tree, is completely missing the point and sensationalizing something for the sake of it.
Nothing except his own foolishness in climbing a tree lead to his death.
A horrible accident, but that's all it truly was, an accident.
03/07/09
03/07/09
I'm not going to look ... there's no point, surely?
There's enough things that make me angry on the internet without any effort on my part, without me forcing another on myself voluntarily.
03/07/09
Also, while I know that what I do won't make a difference, I'd rather not give page hits to that kind of website.
I can't stop them from being fear-mongerers, but at least I won't increase their traffic and add revenue.
03/08/09
03/07/09
03/07/09
03/07/09
It's clear that Crisp was addicted to the game and that he was not playing it "responsibly"; he didn't go out with his friends, he was playing at all hours, even missing school because of it.
His parents tried to deal with the issue by taking away the game; I don't think that they can be blamed for this attempt at solving the problem, but it clearly wasn't the right thing to do. I think that a more hands-on, interactive approach probably would have been more beneficial than the jarring, upsetting cold-turkey method they used.
That being said, I can't blame the parents. They could have done better, but information about how to deal with addiction in children isn't common knowledge; they did their best as parents. I think the father said it best, "I just never realized how important it was to him."
Clearly they could have been more in-touch with their child, and clearly, both in hindsight and through the more informed eyes of others, they could have done things better, but were they bad parents? I don't think so. Parents are people, too, fallible and accident-prone like the rest of us; they did the best they could based on their knowledge at the time.
Now, should they be scape-goating video games? Of course not, but that's another issue entirely, one that doesn't even need discussing.
03/05/09
...but seriously, dark side of gaming? This has nothing to do with gaming. Since time immemorial, children have been running away when parents do something they don't like, like grounding them, taking away their right to use toy X, etc. This is just the same shit.
Fucking media.
03/05/09
Kids run away all the time for all kinds of reasons. Nine times out of ten they come back, this case was an unfortunate exception where the kid died, most likely from an accidental fall.
What if the boy had run away for another reason, like his parents wouldn't take him to the zoo? Would we now be calling for all zoos to be closed because they kill children?
03/05/09
03/05/09
03/05/09
03/05/09
Which is pretty fair to say that the show is seeking to blame video games for akid running away and falling out of a tree.
Do you see any other rational conclusion?
03/05/09
03/05/09