bencroshaw - Kotaku

posts about #bencroshaw more →
Yahtzee's GameDamage Evolves And Improves
Zero Punctuation Reviews Condemned 2 (And Indigo Prophecy)
Zero Punctuation Previews Going To X-Play
Zero Punctuation Takes on Resident Evil: Umbrella Chronicles
The Secrets of Zero Punctuation Revealed!
Zero Punctuation Invades GDC Awards

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

AncientUnknown1
10/05/09

In reply to Yahtzee's GameDamage Evolves And Improves
Looks great. I will definitely watch. I just hope it doesn't get put on G4. I'm not paying extra a month for that station.
Reply

AncientUnknown1 was starred AncientUnknown1 was unstarred

Taggart6: I don't always drink beer, but when I do...
10/05/09

In reply to Yahtzee's GameDamage Evolves And Improves
Meh...alot of dead pan commentary moments. They need to keep the energy up.
Reply

Railgun5
10/05/09

In reply to Yahtzee's GameDamage Evolves And Improves
The timing of the humor in the show is like a ZP if it was stretched out, which gives it a little less punch. The talk-show bits also needed a bit more work in discussion, so I hope they fixed those issues and made a show that was something to look forward to.

Inb4 G4 hires them for a week.
Reply

Yossarian approved this comment Railgun5 was starred Railgun5 was unstarred

Yossarian
10/05/09

@Railgun5: Agreed. They might consider actually highlighting the guy who is actually famous a little bit more as well.

Yes I know that the other guys do a podcast, but Yahtzee's left toe has more fan clout than either of them, and he's clearly way funnier.

I have no earthly idea why they spent so much time promoting Yug playing host.
Reply

Yossarian was starred Yossarian was unstarred

Railgun5
10/05/09

@Yossarian: The issue is that if they highlighted Yahtzee all the time, it'd be "Oh, let's go watch that show because that guy with a funny accent that talks fast is on it" as opposed to "Let's go watch that show because it's entertaining/informational(?) and has those WACKY antics that we know and love. And Yahtzee too."
Reply

Railgun5 was starred Railgun5 was unstarred

deanbmmv
10/05/09

In reply to Yahtzee's GameDamage Evolves And Improves
Hmm. I'll give it a shot, but I'm still not sure.
Still has that awkwardness there, I just don't think they are cut out for TV. Otakuman mentioned Top Gear of gaming, but I just don't think the charisma or chemistry is there.
Currently I'm fine with the 5-10min ZP sketches, and I'm not sure how they will flesh out a whole show, the little parodies would only go so far before you've covered most of the cliches.
Reply

deanbmmv was starred deanbmmv was unstarred

derFeef
10/05/09

In reply to Yahtzee's GameDamage Evolves And Improves
What did I just watch? A game-bashing show?
Reply

Duin promoted this comment derFeef was starred derFeef was unstarred

rich8606
10/05/09

In reply to Yahtzee's GameDamage Evolves And Improves
Yahtzee shouldn't appear on screen.
Reply

rich8606 was starred rich8606 was unstarred

Yossarian
10/05/09

@rich8606: Hey, at least he looks like he showers.

Can't say that for Yug.
Reply

Yossarian was starred Yossarian was unstarred

fELIXADER
10/05/09

@Yossarian: Wow you have a star. I can only guess you just had a bad day.
Reply

Yossarian promoted this comment fELIXADER was starred fELIXADER was unstarred

Yossarian
10/05/09

@fELIXADER: My apologies if you're a Yuggy.

I'm sure his podcast is fantastic, this, though, not so much.

Anyway, if Yahtzee can tarnish his brilliance with this and still have rabid fans, then I can be a starred commentor and still have opinion and keep at least one or two of the people who have hearted me.

Maybe.
Reply

Yossarian was starred Yossarian was unstarred

fELIXADER
10/07/09

@Yossarian: It was less a problem with your oppinion than how you brougth it up.

I think with a star you should be an good example to all of us and base your oppinion on more and elaborate choosen words to prove all those firsters wrong. ^^

Oh and what is a Yuggy? ^^
Reply

fELIXADER was starred fELIXADER was unstarred

Yossarian
10/05/09

In reply to Yahtzee's GameDamage Evolves And Improves
Why go this route?

Is there not a market for just Yahtzee to keep doing his reviews? Maybe up the production values a bit and write alternate versions that are TV friendly?
Reply

Yossarian was starred Yossarian was unstarred

Lee
10/05/09

@Yossarian: He wants to do other things, expand his life and interests a bit more. Not just be known as 'Zero Punctuation'.
Reply

Yossarian promoted this comment Lee was starred Lee was unstarred

Yossarian
10/05/09

@Lee: It's idiotic decisions like that, that lead to things like Ringo Star's solo career and Kingdom of the Crystal Skull.
Reply

Edited by Yossarian at 10/05/09 12:23 PM Yossarian was starred Yossarian was unstarred

False
10/05/09

@Yossarian: Because eventually "Zero Punctuation" gets old. I know a lot of guys that have stopped watching entirely because they've moved on to the next thing. No one blames Yahtzee for trying to expand.
Reply

Yossarian promoted this comment False was starred False was unstarred

Jon
10/05/09

@Yossarian: Ben isn't just known for his Zero Punctuation series you know - ok that is where he got his internet fame, but he has been an indie game developer and journalist for years.
Reply

Yossarian promoted this comment Jon was starred Jon was unstarred

Yossarian
10/05/09

@False: If you can't stay fresh and interested putting together one 5 minute bit per week, then good luck turning out twenty-three 22 minute shows per season.

Hey could prove me wrong, but this doesn't seem to be in his wheelhouse. Zero Punctuation, however, clearly is. IMO he should be taking that format and trying to see how to expand it. Doing a variety game review show may not cut it.
Reply

Yossarian was starred Yossarian was unstarred

Yossarian
10/05/09

@Jon: Both of which are completely irrelevant to his skills as an entertainer, which he is very good at.
Reply

Yossarian was starred Yossarian was unstarred

DeborahSilkworm
10/05/09

In reply to Yahtzee's GameDamage Evolves And Improves
Yay....British snarkiness at its worst. Three guys who have never done anything in the games industry. I didn't think it would be possible to get worse than Yahtzee's terrible cynicism but it looks like he dug up two additional overly critical loudmouths to pollute the internet with . Lame...I wont be watching this.....ever.
Reply

deanbmmv approved this comment DeborahSilkworm was starred DeborahSilkworm was unstarred

deanbmmv
10/05/09

@DeborahSilkworm:
1. Ben Croshaw ( Yahtzee) is the only British one, other two are Australian
2. Ben has also got some indie game development and games journalism under his belt
3. No one is forcing you to watch it.
Reply

deanbmmv was starred deanbmmv was unstarred

ObZen
10/05/09

In reply to Yahtzee's GameDamage Evolves And Improves
I'd like to comment on the video as a whole but I'm too busy thinking about the naughty things I'd do to the girl in pink.
Reply

Yossarian promoted this comment ObZen was starred ObZen was unstarred

Yossarian
10/05/09

@ObZen: Sounds like you may need to join the Beaterator-off to take your mind off her.
Reply

Yossarian was starred Yossarian was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

SUBSCRIBE TO Kotaku

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment