Kotaku 
Enter your username and password.
Denver, 7:16 AM
Thu Dec 10
58 posts in the last 24 hours
Tip us:
Editor-In-Chief:
Brian Crecente
| AIM | Twitter
Deputy Editor:
Stephen Totilo
| AIM | Twitter
Senior Editor:
Michael McWhertor
| AIM | Twitter
Senior Contributing Editor, Japan:
Brian Ashcraft
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, East Coast:
Michael Fahey
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, Oceania:
Luke Plunkett
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editor, Weekends:
Owen Good
| AIM | Twitter
Correspondent, San Francisco:
AJ Glasser
| AIM | Twitter
Columnist:
Leigh Alexander
Columnist:
Tim Rogers
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.
09/06/09
09/07/09
09/06/09
09/08/09
09/06/09
09/06/09
09/06/09
09/06/09
Chances are EA is going to lose money on this until the game receives a significant price drop.
09/06/09
09/06/09
09/09/09
Clearly YOU don't. Because then you'd realize they're not the ones giving these rhythm games multi-million unit sales.
09/06/09
09/06/09
09/06/09
09/06/09
09/06/09
09/06/09
Really, I'd enjoy this game the most if I could BE George or John, playing their guitar part and singing their part of the harmony.
09/06/09
(1) Why would you want "Rock Band" to play differently? That's just stupid. If they made changes, then I'll have to buy new plastic instruments -- and why would I want to do that, when the plastic guitars for RB1 work perfectly fine.
(2) Why would you want "filler songs"? The Beatles have how many albums and how many songs? Already, there's quite a few popular songs that are missing for the 45 on the disc.
09/06/09
One thing I've always felt should've been there from the beginning is timing judgement. The ability for players to freely select their own scrolling speed would be great, too. Stop treating speed like a cheat. We shouldn't all be locked to a slow speed if someone is on Easy and everyone else is on Expert.
09/06/09
Also, why not have some of the solo stuff for after they broke up? Perhaps even introduce it as a separate branch that put the songs back on par with the original Guitar Hero games where you do just one or two parts rather than the whole thing.
Then, for a kicker, perhaps an alternate-reality section where they accepted Lorne Michaels's piddly $4,000 check to re-unite on Saturday Night Live. They'd play "Come Together" just for their own amusement.
09/06/09
Any solo material (if it comes) will be brought into the main Rock Band series. Not this game.
09/08/09
Yes, but was that a Harmonix decision or a remaining Beatles and their next of kin decision?
My guess is that all they'd have to do is license the solo stuff if it's not already part of the Apple Corps catalog (which I'm assuming it isn't). And, if they hadn't already, then they'd have to get permission.
I get that some people, perhaps, don't want to re-live the Beatles breaking up. I just don't believe them to be part of the target audience.
09/05/09
When you pause the game and then start up again, it shows the note track and does a brief countdown before starting again. No more missed notes just because you had to pause! It is the simplest thing, but something every music game should have from now on.
Another thing I liked was the accuracy in showing who's singing when, who's playing what, etc. Other music games only have one singer on stage no matter how many people are actually singing on that track. In this game, if George is singing lead, he's shown singing and playing. If John and Paul are doing the vocals, they switch back and forth. Even in something like "Yellow Submarine" where John pops in for a few background quips, the mouth on his character animation moves appropriately.
There was one big concern I had though, and I doubt it's been changed because I haven't seen anyone mention it..... I think that always playing the same instruments in the same costumes with the same characters in the same venues will get old pretty fast. I haven't heard anyone say that you can play different songs in different locations. It seems like every time you play Sgt. Peppers, you get the dreamscape. If that's not true please let me know. Can I play songs from the Ed Sullivan show in the Abbey Road studio? Can I wear Sgt. Pepper costumes on the rooftop? Sure its not accurate but I would think it could unlock after you beat the song the "right" way.
Also, I understand that they wanted a sameness of art style, but if the visuals for each song are indeed ALWAYS the same, why not use more live action archival footage from concerts, TV appearances, and movies?
Final critique....the game should have had three-part guitar to go with that three-part vocal. Sure you couldn't do all three AND drums locally, but they could have given you the option for local play of doing bass/guitar/guitar or bass/guitar/drums. Seeing as how this is a stand alone game, that would have been a nice change of pace from other music titles.
Overall, loved the game. Even though you can't export tracks I'm strongly leaning towards a buy.
09/06/09
09/09/09
That's kind of a shame. Seems like it will reduce replayability, and makes the logic behind having CG versions of the characters make even less sense. If the backgrounds for each song NEVER change, why not just use real footage and photos? Why not play over the actual real TV footage from the Ed Sullivan show?
09/05/09
09/05/09
Good. I hate the obvious "padding" that the non-band songs in those titles brings.
The Beatles is an example of a band-centric title done right. It's all about the band, and leave the other bands out. Not to mention that supporting it with DLC is infinitely more than the fire and forget strategy that is the Hero band-centric discs.
09/06/09
09/05/09
I was worried that Harmonix would include a bunch of crappy extra songs nobody wanted to play in the first place, and am pleasantly surprised to hear it contains only Beatles songs.
09/05/09
Or any other releases for that matter or is the instruments I have now obsolete and I have to go pick up another space hogging set just to keep up?
I haven't touched the musical rhythem genre since one but I might have to for this, I love the Beatles!
09/05/09
09/05/09
Yes you can use RB1 instruments in Beatles.
I would strongly recommend buying a disc-only cop of RB2. It's available pretty cheap now and would give you a ton of songs to add to your RB1 tracks. You could then export the RB1 tracks to your hard drive and play them in RB2.
09/06/09
09/06/09
09/05/09
I am shocked.
SHOCKED.