dead space to the right, i think replies should be tabbed over a few spaces to right, that way you know more easily when you're reading another reply or a reply's reply or if its a whole new comment.
Ban everyone in the Starcraft 2 posts saying they will pirate the game because there's no LAN and spreading misinformation about non-existent draconian DRM methods. Don't like the game? Don't buy it. But do not go around bragging about how you will steal video games and encourage others to do it.
@KirbyMorph: Seriously, the "change the game or I'll pirate it," stance doesn't help grass roots movements to get LAN put back in. It only makes it more likely for the Devs to ignore their pleas.
@KirbyMorph: I honestly feel that most of these people will pirate it anyway, but want to use that fact to try and leverage companies to do something for a product that they're not going to pay for anyway.
Exactly what kind of behavior is worthy of a banhammer assault on Ban Monday? I have a couple of posters who I don't think need to be dirtying our poster pool due to their piss-poor behavior, but I don't know if their actions are bad enough to warrant removal from this site. Anybody?
Sometimes it's quite easy to know who needs a swift kick. There was that guy who would write "penis" in every comment. Yeah, he's not here anymore. Or those that wrote racial or homophobic slurs--they're gone.
Basically if they are name-calling, disrespectful, or disrupting the post and or community, then they can be banned. You can even be banned for "firsts" or "not news" or any of those other one word answers.
Just read the above link if you have any doubts. :)
@Phydeaux: No, but I don't think many people will be sad to see this one go.
@bakagaijin: I usually link "first!"-posters to the Guide, except for the one time where I screencapped a poster who typed "first", yet failed to actually be first, and posted the screencap in a separate thread so everybody could laugh without having to promote the comment in question, so I'm well acquainted with the guide. It's just that the community is fairly tolerant of certain individuals such that they make offensive comments, and they're still around weeks later (occasionally with a star), so I thought that nothing short of live cannibalism was a bannable offense. I would also kinda feel bad for being responsible for someone else's posting privileges being taken away, but then I remembered that posting on Kotaku is exactly that--a privilege.
In short, if people can get banned for posting "slow news day" or "first", then it probably goes that poor behavior, name calling, and Godwin's Law quantifying will do the same as well.
The only thing I don't like about the commenting system is that starred commenters who reply to a starless commenter, don't promote the comment they're replying to. The result is that only the starred commenters reply is visible, which makes it really hard to follow a discussion.
@Caduceus81: the option to promote the comment has been taken away/broken for a week or two now. It used to do it automatically, and everyone could join in in the conversation.
No matter what the star commenter does, the unapproved commenter cannot have his comment promoted. Unless a mod promotes it. So dont blame the star commenter. It isn't really their fault. I hope something is done about it soon
This is a sort of different topic, but I figured "what the hell?".
I noticed a few people around who used to be star commenters are no longer. I didn't see anything in the commenting rules about LOSING a star, so I was just kind of wondering if they had said something to lose their star, or maybe they weren't posting frequently enough? I figured once you had a star, unless you said something totally off the wall or uncalled for, you pretty much had it for good.
@fauxbravo: They obviously said something totally uncalled for. I've been in a few arguments where I was a little more rude than I probably should have been and I didn't lose it, so I guess you really have to do something that's almost banable to lose your star.
I wouldn't like to push it just to find out though.
@fauxbravo: Once the new system went into play, the Powers That Be became much more stingy with stars; I think this might even have extended to people whose star appeal was more a thing of wit and popular appeal as opposed to erudition and lenghthy posts.
(I have my own personal misgivings about aspects of the new system-- I think it's become too oligarchic and has had a chilling effect on discourse. But that's just my own aside.)
@stikkbomber: Sad song inspired by a troubled 16 year-old Brenda Ann Spencer, who decided "I don't like Mondays".
She shot at kids playing outside a school across the street from her house in San Diego.
8 kids and a cop were hurt and 2 adults died. She was up for parole this year.
@Stormgazer: Describing her as "troubled" is a bit much for me. Some of her alleged responses shortly after the incident wer "I had no reason for it, it was just a lot of fun" and "It was like shooting ducks in a pond...". Sounds more like she did it for kicks and grins (her own of course) than out of some sense of "trouble".
@stikkbomber: Her father had given the .22 cal to her for Christmas with 400+ rounds of ammo. She described that her life after her parents were divorced, was that of total neglect and that she felt like a Latchkey kid.
She claims she was drinking whiskey,popping pills,watching tv and smoking pot with pcp and started hallucinating(seeing army guys in commando suits coming after her).
It's probably a good thing if she's never paroled.
@dudehuge:
That's because you have to get your account verified first. That will happen as long as you don't make stupid comments like "F1RST!" or "Not news!". Just give it time.
11/27/09
11/27/09
11/29/09
10/25/09
11/01/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
Theres all this -------------------------->
dead space to the right, i think replies should be tabbed over a few spaces to right, that way you know more easily when you're reading another reply or a reply's reply or if its a whole new comment.
Very confusing at times.
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
At any rate, I doubt Blizzard is worried.
08/24/09
Quit scaring the children Bashcraft. Your a puppy and we all know it.
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
Sometimes it's quite easy to know who needs a swift kick. There was that guy who would write "penis" in every comment. Yeah, he's not here anymore. Or those that wrote racial or homophobic slurs--they're gone.
Basically if they are name-calling, disrespectful, or disrupting the post and or community, then they can be banned. You can even be banned for "firsts" or "not news" or any of those other one word answers.
Just read the above link if you have any doubts. :)
08/24/09
08/24/09
@bakagaijin: I usually link "first!"-posters to the Guide, except for the one time where I screencapped a poster who typed "first", yet failed to actually be first, and posted the screencap in a separate thread so everybody could laugh without having to promote the comment in question, so I'm well acquainted with the guide. It's just that the community is fairly tolerant of certain individuals such that they make offensive comments, and they're still around weeks later (occasionally with a star), so I thought that nothing short of live cannibalism was a bannable offense. I would also kinda feel bad for being responsible for someone else's posting privileges being taken away, but then I remembered that posting on Kotaku is exactly that--a privilege.
In short, if people can get banned for posting "slow news day" or "first", then it probably goes that poor behavior, name calling, and Godwin's Law quantifying will do the same as well.
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
08/24/09
No matter what the star commenter does, the unapproved commenter cannot have his comment promoted. Unless a mod promotes it. So dont blame the star commenter. It isn't really their fault. I hope something is done about it soon
08/24/09
08/24/09
I noticed a few people around who used to be star commenters are no longer. I didn't see anything in the commenting rules about LOSING a star, so I was just kind of wondering if they had said something to lose their star, or maybe they weren't posting frequently enough? I figured once you had a star, unless you said something totally off the wall or uncalled for, you pretty much had it for good.
08/24/09
I wouldn't like to push it just to find out though.
08/24/09
Yeah, I went there.
08/24/09
08/24/09
I lost my star because I said that stars are ridiculous.
08/24/09
(I have my own personal misgivings about aspects of the new system-- I think it's become too oligarchic and has had a chilling effect on discourse. But that's just my own aside.)
08/24/09
08/24/09
She shot at kids playing outside a school across the street from her house in San Diego.
8 kids and a cop were hurt and 2 adults died. She was up for parole this year.
08/24/09
I think her parole was once again denied fwiw.
08/24/09
She claims she was drinking whiskey,popping pills,watching tv and smoking pot with pcp and started hallucinating(seeing army guys in commando suits coming after her).
It's probably a good thing if she's never paroled.
08/24/09
Gather 'round, young ones, an' I'll spin ye a yarn of one TitillatedOcelot, and his fateful encounter with the Bludgeon of Ban.
Meh, I'll skip the "Ye Olde" yarn. Moral of the story: steer clear of random incest jokes.
Happy Monday!
08/24/09
08/24/09
That's because you have to get your account verified first. That will happen as long as you don't make stupid comments like "F1RST!" or "Not news!". Just give it time.
08/24/09