Same with GiantBomb. Although they're maybe lesser known compared to the big game journalism sites their writing roster is very well-rounded, and their video content is second to none.
I don't really find myself interacting with website communities as much as I used to, but from what I can tell the readership of both sites are pretty mature and thoughtful.
I used to come to Kotaku a lot more than I do now, but it's been alienating me more and more over the years to the point that I'm not really interested in coming back. Partly the changes and directions the site has taken - editorially, functionally, and cosmetically. All with a kind of cold shoulder to community feedback and a kind of off-putting sense of self-seriousness. Crecente's departure was the final nail in a coffin, I think.
I'm not flaming or trolling or debating anything, and for those who might just say to head elsewhere, that's exactly what I plan to do. Just merely wanted to throw in my 2 cents about how I feel the quality of the website has slid in the past few years, since a few others are voicing the same opinion. Who knows, maybe it's not you but me, but regardless I'm going to carry on elsewhere. Thanks for the good years regardless.