While in Seattle a few weeks ago for PAX Prime, I went out to dinner with a few game designers and Kotaku colleagues. Somewhere between the sirloin and the bananas flambée, conversation turned to Skyrim.
We sat there for a while, telling stories about the cool things we'd found in Bethesda's popular role-playing game. We talked about funny glitches, about hidden items, about getting lost in the hills and caves that make up Skyrim's gigantic world. Each of us had experienced things the others hadn't. It was illuminating.
I can't imagine doing that same thing with a Japanese role-playing game. Can you picture the stories? "So then I made my way out of Midgar and hunted down Sephiroth to the Promised Land." "Me too." "Same."
When game designers talk about games like Skyrim, they like to talk a lot about something called "emergent narrative." In human language, that refers to the story that comes out of your actions within a game. Say you stab the Jarl of Morthal, kill all the guards, run outside, summon your horse, and immediately get killed by a dragon. That's a story. Not a particularly emotional story—but an emergent one, the type you might tell your friends about.
But the problem with this emergent approach is that it limits what a story-teller can do. Bethesda's scribes could have taken months to write and develop the most interesting character in the world, a flawed hero with a tragic past and an even worse future. They could have written arcs and climaxes and torturous obstacles for that hero, taking her along some sort of crazy journey that changed the way she looked at life. And you might have never met her. You might have killed her. You might have put a bucket on her head and immediately lost all ability to take her seriously. Quite frankly, the biggest obstacle to telling a good story in a video game is... you.
Don't get me wrong: there are some great moments in Skyrim. Great dinner-table stories. You'll find interesting books and get betrayed by nasty elves and stumble upon lighthouses haunted by demon centipedes. But the writers were limited by the player's freedom. You can walk away in the middle of a story, go find something else to do or someplace else to go. It's simple to screw with pacing and kill any chance Skyrim might have at achieving emotional resonance. Just go do some quests out of order, or make a mess of someone's kitchen while they're telling you about their dead son.
Even Skyrim's main plotline—a weighty affair that involves saving the planet from dragons—is relatively thin, and hard to care about, mostly because the nature of the game makes it tough to empathize with the characters that inhabit Skyrim's world. You don't meet many people with strong desires and goals; most of your time is spent solo, exploring and fighting through the wilderness. From a ludic perspective, that's ideal. For a story-teller, it's quite the opposite.
The Japanese approach, as we've seen in games like Final Fantasy and Chrono Trigger and just about every other RPG not named Dragon's Dogma, is strikingly different. They don't want you to miss anything. They want to take you on a meticulously-scripted adventure with very little wiggle room. You might not walk away with stories to tell your buddies, but if a JRPG does its job, you'll walk away feeling some sort of powerful connection to the characters. You'll feel their pride as they grow, feel their sorrow as they watch friends and loved ones pass away. You'll connect.
(This is assuming that everything else is also executed well, of course. If the dialogue is awful, or a character's voice acting hurts your ears, or the music doesn't fit, the story might have different issues achieving emotional resonance.)
And when JRPG developers have tried experimenting with narrative, the results have not been great. Final Fantasy VI, for example. For the first half of the game, you're basically on a train. You follow one linear path, characters leave and join your party during scripted moments, and the story takes turns and twists when you don't expect them. It's great.
Later, when everything blows up and you enter the second of FFVI's two acts, you're granted free rein to explore. You can enter the final dungeon and finish the game whenever you'd like, but first, you can go embark upon sidequests, re-recruit old party members, and just generally have your way with the world. To many people, this is when the story falls apart: instead of engaging you in the quest to stop the psychopathic clown Kefka, FFVI then becomes a hodgepodge of different plots and ideas, all fighting for your attention among a desolate landscape of ash and lava. Gone is the ebbing and flowing of a structured story. In its place is an open, disconnected world that feels even more disconnected because you can do things out of order.
When you find an old party member, for example, the game won't recognize who else is in your party. There are no tearful reunions or meaningful connections. Just generic lines of dialogue. It's a bummer.
Now if you don't mind me wayyy over-simplifying things, let's say there are two main approaches to RPG storytelling. Let's call them "linear" and "non-linear." Linear games turn story into a reward for playing; non-linear games create story as a result of playing. Both approaches are valid, and each has its own set of strengths and weaknesses.
Your particular preference might vary. It depends why you play games. And as much as I loved Skyrim, as much as I love sitting around the dinner table and sharing travel stories with friends, I prefer linear stories because they're personal. Emotional. It's those little things: the moment my stomach lurches as an ally betrays me; trying to hold back tears as my hero has to kill his best friend. I don't mind not having some sort of direct impact on the outcome of the story, nor do I mind being led along a linear path for 30, 40 hours of my time. As long as it makes me feel something.
Maybe that's why I spend my spare time playing JRPGs. To me, other genres just can't compare.
Random Encounters is a weekly column dedicated to all things JRPG. It runs every Friday at 3pm ET.
(Above Skyrim concept art via Ray Lederer)