Which Football Game is the Best?

important information 2k ea sports all-pro football 2k8 football ncaa football 08

By Mark Wilson Jul 23, 2007 3:20 PM 9,788

130

Get our top stories

follow kotaku

Which Football Game is the Best?

In a painstaking review process, one reviewer weighs the merits of the two big football games of the moment: NCAA Football 08 and All-Pro Football 2K8. Breaking down graphics, offensive plays, defense controls, graphics, modes of play, freshness, extras, ouxtras and realism, there is one inarguable conclusion—a verdict undeniable in its truth.

Don't buy either. They're freaking football games.

OK, the reviewer's answer was All-Pro Football 2K8 for its online play.

But we like our advice more.

NCAA Football 08 vs All-Pro Football 2K8 [pastapadre]

Contact Mark Wilson:

Comment

Discussion Threads

Show earlier discussions

The Gamer's Guide

mass effect 477 5,567 Watch a Mean Ol’ Reaper Blot A Little Girl’s Sunshine in This Mass Effect 3 Teaser
review 352 13,308 Gotham City Impostors: The Kotaku Review
psychonauts 289 14,926 The Past and Future of Psychonauts 2
batman 285 40,227 See Watchmen, The Dark Knight Rises, The Amazing Spider-Man and The Avengers in All Their Toy Fair 2012 Glory
twisted metal 276 15,008 Twisted Metal Sets Game Critics’ Skulls Aflame
superman 250 4,974 Geoff Johns Says a Great Superman Video Game Needs the “Right Studio”
Are video games evil? 248 9,464 Don’t Blame Your Crappy Marriage On Video Games
impressions 233 2,463 Video Proof That Touch My Katamari Is, At Last, A Good Portable Katamari Damacy
tales 222 1,363 The Cut-Scenes in Tales of the Abyss Sure Are Abysmal
vita 213 14,826 The PlayStation Vita Needs a ‘Dislike’ Button
super mario world 173 18,157 Lowest. Score. Ever. (In Super Mario World)
fancy pants 146 264,749 The Very Best In Cosplay: Lindze
ace attorney 138 21,606 Ace Attorney Is the Best Video Game Movie Ever (Take That, Hollywood!)
watch this 129 12,700 See Curt Schilling Shilling Kingdoms of Amalur on Jimmy Fallon
Speak Up On Kotaku 125 14,514 Stop Copying World of Warcraft, Start Making a Better MMO
gamestop 115 18,574 Child Left in GameStop Leads to Neglect Arrest
skullgirls 113 9,154 Skullgirls Picked Just the Right Day to Reveal the Deadly Nurse Valentine
mass effect 112 92,475 Prepare for a Bunch of Mass Effect 3 Plastic to Invade Earth Soon
The last Guardian 108 18,465 Making The Last Guardian is Very Hard, Sony Admits
transformers 105 8,011 Either You Give Grimlock Your Heart or He Takes It
tim schafer 104 41,207 Wait, it Costs $40,000 to PATCH a Console Game?
metal gear 94 22,001 Metal Gear Online Is Dead
vita 88 9,955 First PlayStation Vita Ad Gives Bad Advice
the elder scrolls 82 44,465 Why You Can See Morrowind From Skyrim
blip 78 1,377 A Fabulously Flirty Video Game to Play With Your Valentine
love plus 67 15,210 A Valentine’s Day Contrast Worth a Thousand Nerds